McCarthy v Police No. Scciv-02-1134

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

McCARTHY v POLICE

[2003] SASC 31

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. MULLIGHAN J                 The appellant was charged on complaint with one count of assault and one count of larceny. It was alleged that he committed the offences at Adelaide on 12th June 2001 during the course of an incident at West Terrace. He denied the charges and after a trial before a learned Magistrate, he was found guilty and convicted of both charges and sentenced to 168 hours of community service and ordered to pay some fees and costs. He appeals against the convictions.

  2. The prosecution case was that the appellant took a backpack from Mr Sorak whilst on a bus as it was stopping at a bus stop at West Terrace and ran off with his companions. He was chased by Mr Sorak and, during a scuffle over the backpack, he assaulted him. The backpack was retrieved by Mr Sorak. The charge of larceny was that the appellant stole the backpack and its contents.

  3. The appellant acknowledged that he was on the bus and that he left it at West Terrace but he denied that he was involved in any incident with Mr Sorak or that he was with any companions.

  4. The prosecution case was based in large part upon the evidence of Mr Sorak. He said that he boarded a bus at Old Reynella at about 12.06 pm to travel to the City. He sat at the rear of the bus on the near side. The bus was about half full of passengers. He saw a young man board the bus with four other young men. At least three of them were drinking bourbon and cola. The young man was alleged to be the appellant. According to Mr Sorak, the young man at first sat about two seats in front of him. When the bus stopped at the Flinders Medical Centre and some passengers left the bus and others boarded, the young man moved and sat next to Mr Sorak on the back seat, a little more than half a metre away. The other young men sat further along the bus.

  5. Mr Sorak had a blue backpack, a wallet, keys, mobile telephone and a walkman. He listened to the walkman through headphones whilst on the bus. He claimed that he recognised the young man when he boarded the bus as a person with whom he had worked at Bi Lo at Christies Beach. He said that the young man had starting working at Bi Lo in about November 1998, he was not sure.  Mr Sorak was working there at that time until January 1999. He did not have much to do with him when they were working at Bi Lo but they exchanged greetings and brief conversation on about two occasions. They worked in different departments. He did not remember his name. In cross-examination his evidence was that he had much more extensive contact with this young man when he was working at Bi Lo in that he saw…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCarthy v Police No. Scciv-02-1134 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McCarthy v Police, heard in the South Australian Supreme Court, involves an appeal by the appellant against convictions for assault and larceny. The appellant was found guilty by a Magistrate following a trial and was sentenced to 168 hours of community service, along with fees and costs. The prosecution alleged that the appellant stole a backpack from Mr Sorak while on a bus and assaulted him during the incident. The appellant denied these charges and the appeal centred on the admissibility of certain evidence and the Magistrate's approach to assessing the credibility of witnesses.

The court identified several grounds of appeal, focusing on the admissibility of evidence related to the identification of the appellant by Mr Sorak through a photographic folder. The court found that the evidence was inadmissible and incorrectly used by the Magistrate as evidence of consistency. The court also found that the Magistrate erred by considering the appellant's refusal to participate in a line-up as significant. Furthermore, the court held that the Magistrate wrongly used the appellant's alleged lies as positive evidence of guilt. Lastly, the court determined that the Magistrate erred in not considering all elements of the charges of assault and larceny, particularly whether the evidence proved the intent to permanently deprive the victim of the backpack or its contents.

Given these errors, the court concluded that the convictions could not stand and allowed the appeal. The convictions for assault and larceny were set aside, the charge of larceny was dismissed, and the sentence was quashed. The charge of assault was remitted to the Magistrates Court for a retrial by another Magistrate. The court recognised the difficulties of a retrial given the time elapsed since the offence, but determined that an acquittal on appeal was not appropriate.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant was charged with one count of assault and one count of larceny following an incident on a bus at West Terrace on 12 June 2001. The prosecution's case was that the appellant, along with a group of young men, boarded a bus at Old Reynella and sat at the rear of the bus. The complainant, Mr Sorak, sat on the same side of the bus about two seats in front of the appellant. The appellant was alleged to have attempted to grab Mr Sorak's backpack on two occasions during the journey and, upon reaching West Terrace, grabbed the backpack and ran off the bus with his companions. Mr Sorak chased the group and, during a scuffle, the appellant allegedly kicked him in the head and he fell to the ground. Mr Sorak managed to retrieve his backpack, but his walkman and mobile telephone were lost or taken during the incident. The appellant denied any involvement in the incident.

The prosecution's case relied heavily on the evidence of Mr Sorak, who claimed to have recognised the appellant as someone he had worked with at Bi Lo at Christies Beach. Mr Sorak identified the appellant in court and selected his photograph from a folder shown to him by the police. The defence argued that the appellant was wearing a blue plaster cast on his right arm at the time of the incident, which was not observed by any of the witnesses. The appellant and his witness, Mr Stuart, gave evidence denying any involvement in the incident and asserting that the appellant was sitting alone on the bus and left without incident. The learned Magistrate found the prosecution witnesses to be truthful and reliable, and the appellant and Mr Stuart to be untruthful. The appellant was found guilty of both assault and larceny and sentenced to 168 hours of community service and ordered to pay fees and costs. The appellant appeals against his convictions.

The matter originated from a conviction in the Magistrates Court of South Australia where the appellant, McCarthy, was found guilty of assault and larceny. Following a trial, the Magistrate convicted McCarthy and sentenced him to 168 hours of community service along with fines and costs. McCarthy appealed against his conviction to the Supreme Court of South Australia, contending that the Magistrate erred in various aspects of the trial process. The appeal was heard by Mulighan J who reviewed the evidence and legal arguments presented. Key procedural steps in the appeal process included the filing of the notice of appeal, the preparation of grounds of appeal by McCarthy's legal representative, and the subsequent hearing before Mulighan J. During the appeal hearing, Mulighan J considered the admissibility of certain evidence, the weight given to witness testimonies, and the overall credibility of the witnesses. The Supreme Court found that the Magistrate had erred in several respects, leading to the setting aside of the convictions and a subsequent order for a retrial of the assault charge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MULLIGHAN J
Issues
1. Did the learned Magistrate err in admitting evidence of what Mr Sorak told the police about his assailant?
2. Did the learned Magistrate err in considering the evidence of recognition of the photograph of the appellant by Mr Sorak as admissible and in using it as evidence of consistency?
3. Did the learned Magistrate err in using what he considered to be lies told by the appellant as positive evidence of his guilt?
4. Did the learned Magistrate err in proceeding on the basis that the only issue at the trial was whether the appellant was the assailant and that there was no issue that the crimes of assault and larceny had been committed by the assailant?
5. Did the learned Magistrate err in his approach to the issue of the credibility of Mr Sorak, the appellant and Mr Stuart?

Held
1. The court held that the learned Magistrate erred in admitting evidence of what Mr Sorak told the police about his assailant, as there was no basis of admissibility. This evidence was incorrectly used to show consistency on the part of Mr Sorak.
2. The court held that the learned Magistrate erred in considering the evidence of recognition of the photograph of the appellant by Mr Sorak as admissible and in using it as evidence of consistency. The evidence was inadmissible as there had been no issue that Mr Sorak knew the appellant.
3. The court held that the learned Magistrate erred in using what he considered to be lies told by the appellant as positive evidence of his guilt. The so-called lies were no more than a denial by the appellant in evidence at the trial that he was the assailant and could not amount to positive evidence of guilt.
4. The court held that the learned Magistrate erred in proceeding on the basis that the only issue at the trial was whether the appellant was the assailant and that there was no issue that the crimes of assault and larceny had been committed by the assailant. The learned Magistrate had to be satisfied that all of the elements of each charge had been proved beyond reasonable doubt.
5. The court held that the learned Magistrate erred in his approach to the issue of the credibility of Mr Sorak, the appellant, and Mr Stuart. The learned Magistrate did not have regard to the matters indicating that Mr Sorak could have been wrong in his evidence that the appellant was the assailant and whether he should have had a reasonable doubt about the matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MULLIGHAN J

The court's reasoning in this case revolved around several key issues. Firstly, the court found that the learned Magistrate erred in admitting evidence of what Mr Sorak told the police about his assailant. The evidence of what Mr Sorak said to the police officers was inadmissible as there was no basis of admissibility such as to refute recent invention or to establish a prior inconsistent statement. The court held that the learned Magistrate should not have used this evidence to show consistency on the part of Mr Sorak.

Secondly, the court found that the learned Magistrate erred in considering the evidence of recognition of the photograph of the appellant by Mr Sorak as admissible and in using it as evidence of consistency. The court held that the evidence of recognition of the photograph of the appellant was inadmissible as there had been no issue that Mr Sorak knew the appellant. The court found that the learned Magistrate incorrectly used this evidence as evidence of consistency and that no suggestion of inconsistency had arisen.

Thirdly, the court found that the learned Magistrate erred in using what he considered to be lies told by the appellant as positive evidence of his guilt. The court held that the so-called lies were no more than a denial by the appellant in evidence at the trial that he was the assailant and could not amount to positive evidence of guilt.

Fourthly, the court found that the learned Magistrate erred in his approach to the issue of the credibility of Mr Sorak, the appellant and Mr Stuart. The court held that the learned Magistrate used inadmissible evidence to find that Mr Sorak had been consistent in his assertion that the appellant was the assailant. The court found that the learned Magistrate equated a finding that Mr Sorak was a credible and truthful witness with his being an accurate witness, which are different concepts. The court held that the latter had to be determined in the context of all the evidence in the case.

Lastly, the court found that the learned Magistrate erred in proceeding on the basis that the only issue at the trial was whether the appellant was the assailant and that there was no issue that the crimes of assault and larceny had been committed by the assailant. The court held that the learned Magistrate had to be satisfied that all of the elements of each charge had been proved beyond reasonable doubt, and that the appellant's lack of contest that the crimes were committed by someone did not absolve the prosecution from discharging the burden of proof.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the learned Magistrate erred in admitting inadmissible evidence, using it as evidence of consistency, using lies as positive evidence of guilt, and failing to consider all the evidence in the case when assessing the credibility of witnesses. The court held that these errors led to an unsafe and unsatisfactory conclusion and that the convictions for assault and larceny could not stand. The court allowed the appeal, set aside the convictions, dismissed the charge of larceny, quashed the sentence, and remitted the charge of assault to the Magistrates Court to be heard by another Magistrate.