McCabe v British American Tobacco Australia Services Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

MAJOR TORTS LIST

No. 8121 of 2001

ROLAH ANN McCABE Plaintiff
v
BRITISH AMERICAN TOBACCO AUSTRALIA SERVICES LIMITED Defendant

---

JUDGE:

Eames J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATES OF HEARING:

24, 30-31 January, 1, 4-8, 11-13, 25-27 February, 1 March 2002

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

22 March 2002

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

McCabe v British American Tobacco.

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2002] VSC 73

First Revision 12 April 2002

---

Discovery – application to strike out defence - destruction of documents by defendant before proceedings issued and at a time when no other proceedings on foot - whether documents destroyed at a time when litigation was anticipated – purpose for the destruction of documents - whether failure to comply with orders for discovery - abuse of process –obligation of candour in discovery process – whether plaintiff denied a fair trial – defence struck out - R.S.C Orders 24.02, 24.05.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr J. Rush QC,
Mr J. Forrest QC,
Mr J. Gordon
Slater and Gordon
For the Defendant

Mr J. Ruskin QC,
Mr J. Middleton QC,
Mr D. Beach SC,
Mr S. O’Meara

Clayton Utz

Table of Contents

The 1985 Document Retention Policy............................................................................................ 6

The 1990-1992 review of the Document Retention Policy.......................................................... 8

The Clayton Utz Strategy of 1990.................................................................................................. 13

The Advice of Allen Allen & Hemsley, 1990.............................................................................. 20

The Australian proceedings........................................................................................................... 25

A Multitude of Lawyers.................................................................................................................. 26

The Post-1992 Document Retention Policy................................................................................. 29

(a) The Record Managers’ Training and Education Workbook........................................... 30
(b)  The Staff Handbook.............................................................................................................. 32

The Scope of a Hold Order............................................................................................................. 34

A Strategy to Confine Plaintiffs to documents in the public Domain.................................. 35

Destroyed Documents Pre-1998.................................................................................................... 36

Creation of a Cremona Data Base................................................................................................. 39

The Scope of the Cremona Data Base.......................................................................................... 41

1998:  The Cancellation of the Hold Order and Implementation of the Document Retention Policy.............................................................................................................................................................. 44

What Documents were Destroyed in March/April 1998?......................................................... 55

Inadequate Discovery:  The deficiencies of the Affidavit of Documents........................... 57

(A) The categories identified for discovery.............................................................................. 57
(B) The Affidavit of Documents................................................................................................ 59

A Matter of Interpretation.............................................................................................................. 63

Misleading conduct? - The pre-trial directions hearings......................................................... 65

(A) The grounds of complaint.................................................................................................... 65
(B) The correspondence between the solicitors...................................................................... 66
(C) Was the destruction of documents properly disclosed in affidavits?........................... 67
(D) The Chalmers’ affidavit of 6 December 2001.................................................................... 68
(E) The Namey Affidavits of 10, 17 and 21 December 2001.................................................. 71
(F) The Namey Affidavit of Documents of 14 January 2002................................................. 71
(G) The submissions of counsel................................................................................................. 79

Intention............................................................................................................................................ 87

Anticipated proceedings................................................................................................................. 90

Findings............................................................................................................................................. 93

Prejudice – Denial of a fair Trial................................................................................................... 98

The Warehousing of documents................................................................................................. 109

The Law............................................................................................................................................ 114

What outcome for this application?............................................................................................ 127

Conclusion and Orders................................................................................................................. 132

HIS HONOUR:

  1. Counsel for the plaintiff have made application by summons dated 25 January 2002 for an order that the defendant’s defence be struck out and for supplementary or alternative orders.  The grounds on which the relief is sought were set out in writing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McCabe v British American Tobacco Australia Services Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] VSC 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McCabe commenced proceedings against British American Tobacco Australia Services Limited alleging damages for misleading or deceptive conduct. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The central legal issues were whether the defendant had unlawfully destroyed documents prior to the commencement of proceedings, whether this destruction constituted an abuse of process, and if the plaintiff had been denied a fair trial as a result of these actions.

The court considered whether the defendant's destruction of documents before proceedings were issued, and when no other proceedings were pending, was done with the purpose of avoiding the discovery process. It also assessed whether the destruction amounted to a failure to comply with discovery orders, and if this warranted striking out the defendant's defence. The court found that the destruction of documents was deliberate and aimed at thwarting the discovery process, which constituted a serious breach of the duty of candour required in the discovery process. The court concluded that the actions of the defendant had denied the plaintiff a fair trial and struck out the defence.

The Supreme Court held that the actions of the defendant warranted the striking out of their defence, and that the obligation of candour in the discovery process is a fundamental aspect of the administration of justice. The court emphasised the importance of adherence to the rules of court and the necessity for parties to act in good faith. The orders made by the court included the striking out of the defendant's defence and the imposition of costs associated with the application to strike out.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established