McBurney v Variety WA Incorporated

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   McBURNEY -v- VARIETY WA INCORPORATED [2018] WASC 57

CORAM:   KENNETH MARTIN J

HEARD:   ON THE PAPERS

DELIVERED          :   19 FEBRUARY 2018

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2194 of 2017

BETWEEN:   PHILIP McBURNEY

Plaintiff

AND

VARIETY WA INCORPORATED
First Defendant

JAMES KOMNINOS
Second Defendant

RODNEY O'DEA
Third Defendant

ANTHONY BEGLEY
Fourth Defendant

JAY WALTER
Fifth Defendant

JOHN HANLON
Sixth Defendant

CRAIG HOLLINS
Seventh Defendant

CHERYL LOCKWOOD
Eighth Defendant

MICHELLE D'ALMEIDA
Ninth Defendant

JUSTINE CAMPBELL
Tenth Defendant

HAYLEY HINCHLIFFE
Eleventh Defendant

JO HUNTER
Twelfth Defendant

DENISE CHEIR
Thirteenth Defendant

Catchwords:

Defamation action - Practice and procedure - Mediation - Representation at mediation - Natural person defendants - Objection to non-attendance of all natural persons - Two representatives of natural persons permitted - Orders accordingly

Legislation:

Associations Incorporation Act 2015 (WA)
Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA)

Result:

Orders made

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     No appearance

First Defendant              :     No appearance

Second Defendant         :     No appearance

Third Defendant            :     No appearance

Fourth Defendant           :     No appearance

Fifth Defendant              :     No appearance

Sixth Defendant             :     No appearance

Seventh Defendant         :     No appearance

Eighth Defendant           :     No appearance

Ninth Defendant             :     No appearance

Tenth Defendant            :     No appearance

Eleventh Defendant        :     No appearance

Twelfth Defendant         :     No appearance

Thirteenth Defendant      :     No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Richard Rowick Barrister and Solicitor

First Defendant              :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Second Defendant         :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Third Defendant            :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Fourth Defendant           :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Fifth Defendant              :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Sixth Defendant             :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Seventh Defendant         :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Eighth Defendant           :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Ninth Defendant             :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Tenth Defendant            :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Eleventh Defendant        :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Twelfth Defendant         :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Thirteenth Defendant      :     Douglas Cheveralls Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Nil

  1. KENNETH MARTIN J:  By his writ of summons of 18 July 2017 the plaintiff brings defamation proceedings against 13 defendants.  The first of the defendants is Variety WA (Inc), which is an incorporated association pursuant to the Associations Incorporation Act 2015 (WA).

  2. As an incorporated association the first defendant is a distinct legal entity.  The effect of its incorporation is stated in s 13 of the Act in the following terms:

    13.Effective incorporation

    (1)Upon incorporation of an association under this Act -

    (a)the association becomes a body corporate with perpetual succession and may have a common seal; and

    (b)the corporate name of the association is the name of the association as stated in the certificate of incorporation concluding with the word 'Incorporated' or the abbreviation 'Inc'; and

    (c)except as provided in subsection (2), all rights and liabilities exercisable against members or members of the management committee of the association in their capacity as such immediately before the incorporation of the association become rights and liabilities of and exercisable against the incorporated association; and

    (d)the association may sue or be sued in its corporate name.

    (2)Subsection (1)(c) is not to be construed so…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McBurney v Variety WA Incorporated and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASC 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of McBurney v Variety WA Incorporated, the plaintiff, Mr McBurney, brought a defamation action against Variety WA Incorporated and various individuals who were, at the relevant time, members of the board of Variety WA Incorporated. The crux of the dispute was whether the defendants had defamed the plaintiff through the publication of a letter addressed to the members of Variety WA Incorporated. The case was heard and determined in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The primary legal issue that the court had to decide was whether the plaintiff's defamation action could proceed against the individual board members of Variety WA Incorporated, given that Variety WA Incorporated is an incorporated association and thus a distinct legal entity. The court also had to consider whether the plaintiff's objection to the non-attendance of all natural person defendants at a mediation session was justified, and whether it was permissible for two representatives of the natural persons to attend the mediation on their behalf.

The court held that Variety WA Incorporated, being an incorporated association, is a distinct legal entity with its own rights and liabilities. This was based on the provisions of the relevant Act, which state that upon incorporation, an association becomes a body corporate with perpetual succession and may have a common seal. The court further held that the individual board members were not personally liable for the defamation action, as the liability belonged to Variety WA Incorporated as a distinct legal entity. The court also ruled that the plaintiff's objection to the non-attendance of all natural person defendants at the mediation was not well-founded, and that it was permissible for two representatives of the natural persons to attend the mediation on their behalf. The court's reasoning was based on the understanding that the incorporated association and the individual board members are separate legal entities, and that the defamation action should be pursued against the incorporated association rather than the individual board members.

The court ordered that the defamation action proceed against Variety WA Incorporated as the proper defendant, and that the individual board members were not to be personally liable. The court also ordered that the mediation proceed with the attendance of two representatives of the natural persons on behalf of the remaining board members.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As an incorporated association the first defendant is a distinct legal entity. The effect of its incorporation is stated in s 13 of the Act in the following terms:13.Effective incorporation(1)Upon incorporation of an association under this Act -(a)the association becomes a body corporate with perpetual succession and may have a common seal; and(b)the corporate name of the association is the name of the association as stated in the certificate of incorporation concluding with the word 'Incorporated' or the abbreviation 'Inc'; and (c)except as provided in subsection (2), all rights and liabilities exercisable against members or members of the management committee of the association in their capacity as such immediately before the incorporation of the association become rights and liabilities of and exercisable against the incorporated association; and(d)the association may sue or be sued in its corporate name.(2)Subsection (1)(c) is not to be construed so as to relieve or release any person in respect of liabilities incurred by or on behalf of the association prior to incorporation.See also s 17 of the Act. The indorsement of claim to the plaintiff's writ indicates that his defamation action is based upon the alleged publication of defamatory matter contained in a letter addressed to members of the first defendant with that letter's enclosed attachments and/or annexures constituting a package of materials said to have been sent out (presumably to the first defendant's members) on or about early October 2016. The action is the subject of case management in my CMC list. To date the parties have pleaded out their respective cases under:(a)the plaintiff's statement of claim filed 26 October 2017;(b)the defendants' defences filed 15 November 2017; and(c)the plaintiff's reply filed 22 December 2017. Somewhat unusually, the plaintiff's statement of claim photocopies and incorporates in full at par 4 the full text of the letter to the first defendant's members under the letterhead of the first defendant and which is pleaded to have been published by the defendants on 10 October 2016. The above letter in question advises members of a special general meeting of the first defendant to consider an agenda for a meeting comprising only one item - namely, the decision by the board of the first defendant not to accept the applications of three persons (including the plaintiff) to participate in '2016 Bash'. The letter to members notes that a package of materials included:•Notice of Meeting•Information as provided by the Board of Variety (clause 22 of the Constitution permits proxies);•Information as provided by (the three persons the subject of the special general meeting's agenda);•Proxy Form - for those unable to attend the meeting, but still wishing to vote. The letter to members then proceeds to articulate under some 17 following paragraphs the 'Position of the Board'. It concludes as signed by James Komninos (who is described as 'Chief Barker ("Chairman")'. I pause to observe that Mr Komninos is named as the second defendant to the plaintiff's writ. I further observe that although the plaintiff's writ does not carry any such designations, that references to the second through 13th defendants as seen on the plaintiff's following statement of claim are all expressed (with one exception) to be on a basis of twelve natural person defendants being sued 'in his/her capacity as past and present Board Member'. The exception is the seventh defendant, Mr Craig Hollins. In respect of Mr Hollins, a following designation after his name as seventh defendant is 'in his capacity as a past board member'.