[2000] QDC 436
IN THE DISTRICT COURT
HELD AT BEENLEIGH
QUEENSLAND
Rockhampton Plaint No. 69 of 1997
BETWEEN:
JEFFREY ROBERT McARTHUR
Plaintiff
AND:
MERCANTILE MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
Defendant
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
| 1, | This is an action by Jeffrey Robert McArthur (“the Plaintiff”) for |
payment of an agreed benefit under a Group Life Contract (“the Policy”)
issued by Mercantile Mutual Life Insurance Company Limited (“the
Insurer”) or for damages for breach of the Policy by the Insurer. In order
to explain the issues which arise for determination it is necessary to set
out a basic chronology and explanation of the orders made to this time.
| 2, | The Plaintiff is an eligible beneficiary under the Policy. Following |
periods of absences from his employment at the Norwich Park Mine his
employment was terminated in February 1995. On 28th March, 1995 he
lodged a claim for payment of an agreed benefit under the Policy on the
basis he was totally and permanently disabled (TPD). His entitlement to a payment under the Policy at that stage was dependent upon the
Insurer forming an opinion that, as a result of injury or illness, he was
likely never to be engaged in any suitable gainful employment.
3. The definition of total and permanent disablement (TPD)1 in the
Policy is relevantly:-
“(b) in the case of an Insured Person who is engaged in a gainful occupation, business, profession or employment –
(i) the Insured Person is totally unable to and does not in fact engage in that gainful occupation, business, profession or employment, as a result of an injury or illness for a consecutive period of six (6) months, and
(ii) after that period of six (6) months, we are of the opinion that, as a result of that injury or illness, the Insured Person is disabled or incapacitated to such an extent as to render the Insured Person likely never to be engaged in any gainful occupation, business, profession nor employment, for which the Insured Person is reasonably suited by training, experience or qualification.”
| 4, | In order to consider whether it should form the opinion of future |
disablement in the TPD definition the Insurer collected various
statements and medical reports from two treating doctors (Dr. Kemp,
Dr. Holford). After reviewing the medical information it had collected the
Insurer decided to defer consideration of the claim until July 1996. It is competent for an Insurer in these circumstances to defer consideration of
the question or to obtain its own advice on the question provided the
Insurer in deferring consideration is acting reasonably and in good faith
and with due regard to the interests of the claimant.
5. While the further consideration of the claim was deferred the
Insurer apparently took no further steps to process the claim until the
Plaintiff’s solicitors forwarded a report from a psychiatrist
(Dr. Mulholland) dated 10th July 1996 to it. The Insurer then wrote to
Dr. Mulholland requesting he address a number of specific issues.
Dr. Mulholland replied by…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McArthur v Mercantile Mutual Life Insurance Co Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] QDC 436
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the insurer's decision to reject McArthur's claim was unreasonable and whether the court should determine whether McArthur was TPD under the policy definition. The court also had to consider the appropriate approach to determining whether McArthur was TPD and the admissibility of evidence not before the insurer at the relevant time.
The court found that while the insurer's decision not to form the TPD opinion was not necessarily unreasonable, the insurer breached its duty to act reasonably, fairly, and in good faith when considering the claim. The court held that the insurer had lost the benefit of the condition precedent and that the court should determine whether McArthur was TPD under the policy. The court decided to determine whether McArthur was TPD under the policy definition as if the condition precedent was not in the definition. The court considered all relevant evidence available at the date of trial.
The court concluded that McArthur was not TPD under the policy definition and dismissed the plaintiff's action. The court found that the failure of the plaintiff to give evidence meant that the plaintiff's case was technically unproven. The court also noted that considerations of necessity and justice militated against the approach proposed by the plaintiff's counsel.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi