CITATION: Mayer v Whittingham [2001] NSWSC 985 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division FILE NUMBER(S): SC 4509/99 HEARING DATE(S): 31/10/01 JUDGMENT DATE:
7 November 2001PARTIES :
Yvonne Maria Mayer v Ken Whittingham - Estate of Trevor ShadeJUDGMENT OF: Master Macready at 1
COUNSEL : Mr A. Enright for plaintiff
Mr J. Wilson for defendantSOLICITORS: Harris Hyde Page for plaintiff
Deacons Lawyers for defendant
CATCHWORDS: Family Provision. Application by a daughter who was given half of deceased's estate. Discussion of obligation of a parent to a child and the need for evidence to quantify claim for provision. - Application dismissed. DECISION: Paragraph 25
This is an application under the Family Provision Act in respect of the estate of the late Trevor Shade who died 21 May 1999 aged 79 years. The deceased was survived by his daughter, Yvonne Mayer, who is the plaintiff in these proceedings. The deceased made his will on 15 December 1998 and probate was granted to the defendant in July 1999. That will gave certain items of personalty in clause 4 to Warwick Purcell a friend of the deceased. Clause 5 then provided:-
“I direct my trustee to divide my estate as follows:-
“(1) To my daughter, Yvonne Mayer 50 % of my estate.
(2) To my friend, Warwick Jack Purcell 20% of my estate.
(3) To the Vietnam Veterans Association of Australia New South Wales Incorporated being Registered Charity No. CC 24654 5% of my estate. The receipt of the charity’s secretary or treasurer is a sufficient discharge to my Trustee for payment.
(4) To St Catherine’s Aged Care Services of Balaclava Road Eastwood the rest and residue of my estate. The receipt of the charity’s secretary or treasurer is a sufficient discharge to my Trustee for payment.”
2 By the time of his death the deceased’s house had been sold and his estate reduced to cash. At the date of hearing the estate assets total $517,000. There have been costs incurred on the plaintiff’s part amounting to $42,000 and on the defendant’s part amounting to $51,750.
3 I will deal with some of the family history in order to give context to the matter. The deceased was born on 24 September 1919 and he married on 24 December 1938. The plaintiff, the couple’s only child was born on 3 June 1940. In 1942 the deceased and the plaintiff’s mother separated. The mother and the plaintiff moved to Mitchell’s Flat and stayed with the mother’s parents. After separating the deceased joined the army and served in the army throughout the war. It was not until May 1949, after the war, that the plaintiff saw her father again. On that occasion he met her and stayed with her grandparents at Mitchell’s Flat for a few weeks. In 1951 the plaintiff again met her father when his ship docked at Newcastle. By then he was actively engaged in matters that took him away. At this stage the plaintiff had moved to Charlestown in Newcastle…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mayer v Whittingham and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] NSWSC 985
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue in this case was whether Mayer had provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that her father had an obligation to provide for her needs, and if so, whether this justified a greater share of the estate. The court was required to consider the principles of family provision under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) and assess the evidence presented by Mayer regarding her father's conduct and their relationship. The court had to balance Mayer's claim with the principle that the division of an estate should reflect the deceased's intentions, as expressed through his will.
In delivering the judgment, the court emphasised the necessity for clear and compelling evidence to establish that a parent had an obligation to provide for a child, and that this obligation was not met. The court found that Mayer had not provided sufficient evidence to support her claim that her father had an obligation to provide for her, nor had she demonstrated that the division of the estate did not reflect his true intentions. The court dismissed Mayer's application, holding that the evidence did not justify altering the distribution of the estate as determined by the will.
The court's decision was definitive, and no further orders were made. Mayer's application for a greater share of the estate was dismissed, and the distribution of the estate as per the father's will was upheld.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi