Maybury & Maybury & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MAYBURY & MAYBURY AND ORS [2012] FamCAFC 57

FAMILY LAW – APPEAL – PROPERTY – Financial orders – Where the parties obtained from the second respondent a line of credit and a mortgage secured on the title of the former matrimonial home to establish a business – Where the parties defaulted on obligations to the second respondent and the orders of the Federal Magistrate included a provision that the parties deliver up possession of the property to the second respondent – Where the parties’ company entered into a lease granted by the third respondent and defaulted on the lease obligations – Where the third respondent obtained a judgment sum in another court against the parties – Where the husband unsuccessfully asserted the contracts with the second and third respondents were the responsibilities of the wife only – Where the husband failed to demonstrate that the orders were not just and equitable – Where the husband failed to establish that the Federal Magistrate erred in his treatment of the liabilities to the second and third respondents – No appealable error demonstrated – Appeal dismissed.

FAMILY LAW – APPEAL – PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – Application for leave to proceed in the appeal without a transcript – leave granted.

FAMILY LAW – APPEAL – COSTS – Where no formal application for costs was filed or served by the wife – Where the husband was not aware of the application and consequently did not file submissions in response – Where the Federal Magistrate made an order for costs based on the unfiled submissions of the wife – Appeal allowed.

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) - s 93A(2)
CDJ v VAJ (1998) 197 CLR 172
Kowaliw and Kowaliw (1981) FLC 91-092
Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Citibank Savings Ltd and Others (1995) 38 NSWLR 116
APPELLANT: Mr Maybury
RESPONDENT: Mrs Maybury
SECOND RESPONDENT: Suncorp Metway Pty Ltd
THIRD RESPONDENT: K Pty Ltd
FILE NUMBER: BRC 9198 of 2009
APPEAL NUMBER: NA 55 of 2011
DATE DELIVERED: 26 April 2012
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: Faulks DCJ, May & Stevenson JJ
HEARING DATE: 20 April 2012
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Federal Magistrates Court
LOWER COURT JUDGMENT DATE:

10 June 2011

1 March 2012

LOWER COURT MNC:

[2011] FMCAfam 540

[2011] FMCAfam 581
[2012] FMCAfam 165

REPRESENTATION

THE APPELLANT: In person
THE RESPONDENT: In person (by telephone)
SOLICITOR FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: No appearance
SOLICITOR FOR THE THIRD RESPONDENT: No appearance

Orders

  1. The husband is granted leave to proceed with his appeal in the absence of a transcript of proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court.

  2. The husband is granted leave to amend his Notice of Appeal filed on


    8 July 2011 so as to include an appeal against the costs order of 1 March 2012.

  3. The husband’s appeal against the order for costs made on 1 March 2012 is allowed and the order is set aside.

  4. The wife have liberty to make an application for costs in the substantive proceedings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maybury & Maybury & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FamCAFC 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal arose from a family law matter where the parties had obtained a line of credit and a mortgage secured on the title of their former matrimonial home to establish a business. The parties defaulted on their obligations to the lender and the orders of the Federal Magistrate included a provision that the parties deliver up possession of the property to the lender. The parties' company also entered into a lease granted by another party and defaulted on the lease obligations. The husband asserted that the contracts with the lender and the lessor were the responsibilities of the wife only. The husband also argued that the orders of the Federal Magistrate were not just and equitable and that the Federal Magistrate erred in his treatment of the liabilities to the lender and the lessor. The wife did not formally apply for costs, but the Federal Magistrate made an order for costs based on the unfiled submissions of the wife. The husband was not aware of the application and consequently did not file submissions in response.

The legal issues in this case were whether the husband's appeal against the orders of the Federal Magistrate and the costs order should be dismissed or allowed. The court had to determine whether the husband had demonstrated that the orders were not just and equitable, that the Federal Magistrate had erred in his treatment of the liabilities to the lender and the lessor, and whether the order for costs was appropriate. The court also had to consider whether the husband was granted leave to proceed with his appeal in the absence of a transcript of proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court and whether he was granted leave to amend his Notice of Appeal to include an appeal against the costs order.

The court found that the husband had not demonstrated that the orders were not just and equitable or that the Federal Magistrate had erred in his treatment of the liabilities to the lender and the lessor. The court also found that the order for costs was not appropriate because the husband was not aware of the application and consequently did not file submissions in response. The court held that the husband was granted leave to proceed with his appeal in the absence of a transcript of proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court and that he was granted leave to amend his Notice of Appeal to include an appeal against the costs order. The court allowed the husband's appeal against the costs order and set it aside. The court dismissed the husband's appeal against the orders of the Federal Magistrate.

The court made several orders in relation to this appeal. The husband was granted leave to proceed with his appeal in the absence of a transcript of proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court. The husband was also granted leave to amend his Notice of Appeal to include an appeal against the costs order of 1 March 2012. The husband's appeal against the order for costs made on 1 March 2012 was allowed and the order was set aside. The wife was granted liberty to make an application for costs in the substantive proceedings within 21 days of the making of this order and upon such application being made, the matter was to be listed before Federal Magistrate Coates for directions. The husband's appeal was otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The husband is granted leave to proceed with his appeal in the absence of a transcript of proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court.

2.

The husband is granted leave to amend his Notice of Appeal filed on

8 July 2011 so as to include an appeal against the costs order of 1 March 2012.

3.

The husband’s appeal against the order for costs made on 1 March 2012 is allowed and the order is set aside.

4.

The wife have liberty to make an application for costs in the substantive proceedings within 21 days of the making of this order and upon such application being made, the matter be listed before Federal Magistrate Coates for directions.

5.

The husband’s appeal is otherwise dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At pp 118 – 119 Bryson J held:Indemnity for obligations incurred on request and without consideration:When it is established that the second defendants entered into their obligation without consideration at the request of Ralph Panebianco the principle upon which the High Court of Australia disposed of Israel v Foreshore Properties Pty Ltd (1980) 54 ALJR 421; 30 ALR 631 is attracted. The law applied in that case was stated by Aickin J with the concurrence of the other members of the Court (at 423-424; 636) in these terms: ‘The case may thus be regarded as one in which money was paid without consideration by Foreshore at the request and for the benefit of Mitta, Israel and the Carpenters, or as one in which Foreshore, at the request of Mitta, Israel and the Carpenters, undertook the obligation of a surety for them at their request. The obligation so undertaken was Foreshore's promise to pay the McLaughlins $65,000 with interest incorporated in the instrument of mortgage, such payment being secured by mortgage of its land. A person who acts on such a request to pay, or who accepts the role of surety in that manner and who pays the debt, is entitled to an indemnity from those who made the request to pay or to act as surety. This is trite law as appears from Rowlatt on Principal and Surety, 3rd ed (1936) at 182-188, especially at 184, and the cases there cited. As long ago as 1799 Lord Kenyon CJ said in Exall v Partridge (1799) 8 Term Rep 308 at 310; 101 ER 1405 at 1406: ‘I admit that where one person is surety for another, and compellable to pay the whole debt, and he is called upon to pay, it is money paid to the use of the principal debtor, and may be recovered in an action against him for money paid, even though the surety did not pay the debt by the desire of the principal. …’ The same general principle applies to a case of money paid by one party at the request and for the benefit of another.’The principle stated by Aickin J appears to me to be a sufficient basis for the dismissal of these proceedings. Innocenzo and Saveria Panebianco gave their guarantee without consideration at the request and for the benefit of Ralph and Rosa Panebianco. There clearly was a benefit for Ralph and Rosa Panebianco in the provision of credit to their company. The second defendants have a right at law to be indemnified against any liability arising under the guarantee, and the existence of this right negates the asserted right to contribution. … In the present case, the husband and wife were both found to have participated in the acquisition of the business and its early operation. They were equal shareholders in company H, hence they each had control over its activities. The husband in these proceedings was thus in a vastly different position, in both legal and practical terms, to Mr and Mrs Panebianco Senior in Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Citibank Savings Ltd and Others. For all of these reasons, we conclude that there is no substance to ground four of the appeal.