MAXWELL v POLICE
[1998] SASC 6780
Magistrates Appeal (Ex tempore)
Bleby J
The appellant appeals against a sentence imposed upon him by the Magistrates Court sitting at Whyalla, for the offence of driving whilst disqualified, contrary to s91(5) of the Motor Vehicles Act 1959. He pleaded guilty to the offence on 18 March 1998, and was also sentenced on that date. This was not the first time that the appellant had been convicted of the offence of driving whilst disqualified, so the maximum penalty that was applicable to the offence was Division 5 imprisonment, being a term of imprisonment not exceeding two years. The learned sentencing magistrate sentenced the appellant to imprisonment for 18 months, with a non-parole period of 12 months. The sentence was not suspended. The sole ground of appeal alleges that the sentence is manifestly excessive.
The circumstances of the offence were that at about 9.20pm on the night of Wednesday, 10 December 1997, the attention of a mobile police patrol was attracted to a car being driven by the appellant because its tail-lights were very dim. They stopped the car and spoke to the appellant about the tail-lights and some other minor matters pertaining to the condition of the vehicle, and asked whether he had a driver's licence. He replied that he believed that he may have been disqualified from driving, as a result of having lost the required number of demerit points. He denied that he had ever been formally served with a notice of disqualification. In fact, he had been disqualified from driving in South Australia from 29 October 1997 to 28 January 1998, as a result of having lost the prescribed quota of demerit points.
Before the magistrate, the appellant claimed no recollection of having been served with the notice of disqualification, but accepted that it had been so served. His explanation for the driving was that he was trying out a car that he was interested in purchasing. At the time that the appellant was observed driving by the police, traffic was light, the roads along which he travelled were well lit, were sealed, and were in good repair. It was conceded that there was no embarrassment to other road users being caused by the appellant's vehicle, and there were apparently no other traffic offences being committed.
The appellant is a 29 year old man. He has a very poor record for offences of this type, having been convicted on no less than fourteen other occasions for the offence of driving whilst disqualified. He also has numerous convictions for a wide variety of driving offences, as well as for offences of dishonesty and offences of violence. His record is not impressive.
Of particular significance, for present purposes, is his record of previous convictions for this offence. They began in 1986 when there were two offences. There were three in 1988, four in 1990, but prior to this offence there had only been one since 1993, namely one in early 1995. However, for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MAXWELL v POLICE No. SCGRG-98-797 Judgment No. S6780 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6780
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court began by examining the circumstances of the offence. The appellant had driven whilst disqualified for a period of time, with no aggravating factors such as dangerous driving or causing inconvenience to other road users. The court recognised that while the appellant's disregard for the law was blatant, it was not in the worst category of offending. The court also considered the appellant's plea and cooperation with the police, which entitled him to some discount. The court emphasised the importance of considering the offender's previous record to show whether the instant offence was an uncharacteristic aberration or whether the offender had manifested in his commission of the instant offence a continuing attitude of disobedience of the law.
In light of the appellant's extensive criminal history and contumacious disregard for the law, the court deemed a substantial term of imprisonment justified both as a need to deter the appellant from further offending and to deter others who might be tempted to do the same. However, the court found the original sentence to be excessive, particularly as it was made concurrent with the appellant's existing sentence, which was deemed improper. The court considered two recent decisions to ensure consistency in sentencing offenders for the same offence. The appeal was allowed, and the court substituted the original sentence with a head sentence of twelve months imprisonment and a non-parole period of seven months, to be served from the date of the appellant's release from custody for the sentence he was serving at the time of his sentence in the current case.
The court's decision highlights the importance of considering the offender's previous record and the nature of the offence when determining an appropriate sentence. The court also emphasises the need for consistency in sentencing offenders for the same offence and the importance of ensuring that the sentence reflects the court's estimate of the degree of culpability involved in a crime.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi