Maxwell Delahunty and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

[2014] AATA  864

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/3070

Re

Maxwell Delahunty

APPLICANT

And

Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr A G Melick SC, Deputy President

Date 3 October 2014
Date of written reasons 21 November 2014
Place Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision and substitutes a decision that the Applicant’s retirement impairment diminished his capacity to undertake civilian employment by 35 per cent and hence he is to be classified as Class B with effect from 1 September 1973.

..........................[SGD]..............................................

Mr A G Melick SC, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

DEFENCE – defence force retirements and death benefits – applicant’s retiring impairment at date of discharge – percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment – decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 ss 3, 30, 34, 37, 99(2)

CASES

Cox v O’Donnell & Anor (1992) 34 FCR 42

Freeman v Defence Force Retirement Death Benefits Authority (1986) 5 AAR 156
Re Boss v Defence Force Retirement Death Benefits Authority (1977) 20 ALR 663

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr A G Melick SC, Deputy President

X November 2014

  1. The Applicant, Mr Maxwell Delahunty, made an application to this Tribunal for the review of a decision made by the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC) on 12 June 2013. The CSC affirmed a prior determination of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (DFRDBA) dated 7 February 1974, which found that under section 30 of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Act 1973 (the Act), Mr Delahunty’s incapacity was five per cent and fell within Class C. This decision had effect from 1 September 1973.

  2. In the original 1974 decision, a delegate of the DFRDBA determined that chronic phobic anxiety state was an appropriate description of the Applicant’s impairment at the time of retirement, taking into consideration the relevant kind of civil employment of salesman, marine technical propulsion and engine driver. 

  3. The Applicant requested an investigation of retrospective medical discharge pursuant to section 37 of the Act. Mr Delahunty submitted that the medical records indicated that he was suffering from a significant psychiatric condition prior to his discharge. In a decision dated 6 May 2013 the Respondent allowed the Applicant to make a request for reconsideration of the determination dated 7 February 1974, beyond the 30 day time limit allowed under section 99(2) of the Act. 

  4. In correspondence dated 3 February 2012, the Applicant requested a reconsideration of the decision dated 7 February 1974, pursuant to section 99 of the DRFDB Act. The Respondent affirmed the determination made on 7 February 1974.

  5. The Applicant seeks review of the Respondent’s decision with this Tribunal. 

    BACKGROUND

  6. I accept the key facts, as set out by the Applicant. Mr Delahunty was born in 1947 and is now 67 years of age. The Applicant completed Year 10 in 1962 before enlisting in the Australian Defence Force on 8 July 1963. Mr Delahunty was medically discharged on 31 August 1973 and classified under section 30 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maxwell Delahunty and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporatio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 864
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Maxwell Delahunty and Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation involves a review of a decision made by the Respondent regarding the retirement benefits of Mr Delahunty, who served in the Australian Defence Force and was discharged on 31 August 1973. The Applicant seeks to challenge the decision which assessed his retirement impairment and classified him under section 30 of the relevant Act. The Tribunal is tasked with determining the accuracy of the decision concerning the types of civil employment Mr Delahunty could undertake, the impact of his conditions on his employment capacity, and whether he was incapacitated from suitable remunerative employment due to his psychological condition.

The legal issues in this case revolve around the interpretation and application of section 30 of the Act, specifically subsections (1) and (2). The primary issue is the determination of Mr Delahunty's percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment at the date of his discharge. This involves considering his vocational skills, qualifications, and experience, as well as the types of employment he could reasonably undertake. Furthermore, the Tribunal must assess the extent to which Mr Delahunty's physical and mental impairments affected his capacity to undertake such employment. The court must ensure that the decision was made in accordance with the statutory provisions and that all relevant factors were properly considered.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal carefully examined the evidence presented, including the contemporaneous determinations by the Medical Board and the reports of Dr White and Dr Rowland. The Tribunal also considered Mr Delahunty's personal testimony and the impact of his experiences during his service, such as the sexual assault and the explosion on HMAS Sydney. After thorough consideration, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Delahunty's retirement impairment diminished his capacity to undertake civilian employment by 35 per cent. Therefore, the Tribunal set aside the Respondent’s decision and determined that Mr Delahunty is to be classified as Class B with effect from 1 September 1973.

The final orders of the Tribunal reflect the determination that Mr Delahunty’s retirement impairment diminished his capacity to undertake civilian employment by 35 per cent. Consequently, he is to be classified as Class B, and the earlier decision by the Respondent is set aside. This classification impacts the retirement benefits he is entitled to receive, ensuring that they reflect his assessed level of incapacity.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant seeks review of the Respondent’s decision with this Tribunal. BACKGROUND I accept the key facts, as set out by the Applicant. Mr Delahunty was born in 1947 and is now 67 years of age. The Applicant completed Year 10 in 1962 before enlisting in the Australian Defence Force on 8 July 1963. Mr Delahunty was medically discharged on 31 August 1973 and classified under section 30 of the Act as 5 per cent Class C with effect from 1 September 1973. During the Applicant’s service he served as an Engineering Mechanic, and at the time of discharge held the rank of Petty Officer. The issues as set out by the Applicant were whether the decision dated 7 February 1974 accurately assessed the following:(a)the kinds of civil employment which a person with the Applicant’s skills, qualification and experience might reasonably undertake; (b)the degree which the Applicant has accepted the conditions impact his ability to undertake suitable civilian employment; and(c)whether the Applicant was incapacitated from undertaking suitable remunerative employment due to his psychological condition. I note that originally, review was also sought in relation to his physical condition, but this was not pressed at hearing.ISSUES The Applicant’s date of discharge was 31 August 1973 and my task is to determine the following. Firstly, what retiring impairment, if any, was suffered by the Applicant as 1 September 1973. When considering this, I note the comments made in Cox v O’Donnell & Anor (1992) 34 FCR 42 at 55 where the court noted: In determining what was the Applicant’s medical condition at the time of his retirement the chief of staff was not confined to a consideration of material that was before the Final Medical Board. Nor was he confined to such materials as was available at the date of the Applicant’s retirement. His obligation was to consider whatever information was available at the time he made his determination that could throw light on the Applicant’s medical condition at the relevant date. Secondly, whether the determination has been made pursuant to section 30 of the Act, and the relevant parts which are subsections (1) and (2). Section 30(1) states:Where a member of the scheme, not being a member of the scheme to whom 36 applies, is, or is about to become, entitled to invalidity benefit. The authority shall determine his percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment, and shall classify him according to the percentage of incapacity as follows Section 30(2) notes the following:In determining, for the purposes of subsection (1) the percentage incapacity in relation to civil employment of a member of the scheme, the authority shall have regard to the following matters only:(a)the vocational, trade, and professional skills, qualifications and experience of the member; (b)the kinds of civil employment which a person with the skills, qualification, experience referred to in paragraph (a) might reasonably undertake;(c)the degree to which the physical or mental impairment of the member that caused the invalidity or physical or mental incapacity because of which he or she was retired has or had diminished the capacity of the member to undertake the kinds of civil employment referred to in paragraph (b); and (d)any other matters, if any, as are prescribed for the purpose of this subsection.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In performing my assessment it was agreed by both counsel that the relevant principles are as set out in Re Boss v Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (1977) 20 ALR 663 at 666 and 667. In line with that authority I have only taken into account the circumstances present as at 31 August 1973 and in the immediate future, omitting the circumstances foreseeable only in the long term. So what were the Applicant’s circumstances as at 31 August 1973? EVIDENCE The Applicant gave oral evidence by way of confirming his statement at T-42, the salient points of which are as follows. In 1963 whilst a 16 year old recruit at HMAS Leeuwin, the Applicant was sexually assaulted in the toilets. He was told by his attackers not to report it, and if he did they would do it to him again. The Applicant said he did not report the assault because “They told me they will get me again.” In 1965 he went to South Vietnam aboard HMAS Sydney which was, at the relevant time, anchored in Vung Tau Harbour. He was tasked with inspecting the outside machinery, space rounds, and also the plumber block space which was a space deep in the bowels of the ship which supported the propeller shaft. He had to go through all the hatches and close them as watertight security as he passed through. Whilst in that compartment he felt a large explosion at his feet. Mr Delahunty noted they’d been continually warned about enemy divers putting mines on the sides of the ship. He thought he was going to drown in that space. The Applicant said that he defecated and urinated. He later took off his overalls and underpants and cleaned himself up with rags which he later threw out. He said he was ashamed that he reacted in the way he did, but noted that at the time he was just 18 years old. Mr Delahunty also mentioned scare charges, which are explosive concussive devices thrown from boats being driven around the ship to knock unconscious or kill any enemy divers. He said that after the scare charge, within about two days, he started to get nightmares and flashbacks about the sexual assault and got to the stage where he could smell the faeces in his mouth and smell the urine. Mr Delahunty said “It was so vivid I felt as though I was back there again.” He also described nightmares about the scare charges, he said “I relive it exactly as it was.” The Applicant went to South Vietnam on three further occasions, on HMAS Stuart in May/June 1967, then again in January/February 1968, and then on Vendetta in October to November 1970. He said that his nightmares continued after discharge on a regular basis, although it could go for several months without happening. They would reappear whenever he was in a stressful situation. He gave evidence about doing a mechanics course at Balmoral and not being able to handle the pressure because of the nightmares. He held himself always in low esteem because of the sexual assault because he always thought in some way it was his fault. And he was also continually ashamed about his reaction to what happened in the space deep down in HMAS Sydney.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Obviously this determination is one that’s difficult to make with any precision, but I take guidance from the contemporaneous determination by the Medical Board surveys of 27 July 1973, the reports of Dr White and Dr Rowland. From these, the evidence of the Applicant and his wife, and the other materials, I consider the Applicant’s impairment to have been at least 30 per cent, and allowing a small extra component for the matters referred to in Freeman (and the discussion therein of X’s case), bearing in mind the distinction I’ve already drawn, I assess the impairment at 35 per cent.DECISION For the reasons set out above, the Respondent’s decision of 12 June 2013 is set aside, and I determine that the Applicant’s retirement impairment diminished his capacity to undertake civilian employment by 35 per cent and hence he is to be classified as Class B with effect from 1 September 1973.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.