Maxims Entertainment Pty Ltd v Chinatown Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE - application under Order 10, r 7 against respondents who had failed to comply with directions – proof required – power of Court under Order 33 r 3 to dispense with compliance with rules of evidence on ground that facts are not genuinely in dispute or on the ground of unnecessary or unreasonable expense or delay.

Federal Court Rules, O 10 r 7, O 33 r 3

Australian Securities Commission v Macleod (1994) 54 FCR 309 followed
Pearce v Button (1986) 8 FCR 408 applied
Arab Monetary Fund v Hashim (No. 7) [1993] 1 WLR 1014 applied

MAXIMS ENTERTAINMENT PTY LTD & ORS v CHINATOWN ENTERPRISES PTY LTD & ORS

NG 918 of 1995

Burchett J
Sydney
16 December 1998

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

 NG 918 of 1995

BETWEEN:

MAXIMS ENTERTAINMENT PTY LTD
FIRST APPLICANT

LONG SHONG PICTURES (HK) LTD
SECOND APPLICANT

PRO-VISION ENTERTAINMENT LTD
THIRD APPLICANT

POWER WORLD PRODUCTION LIMITED
FOURTH APPLICANT

RISING SUN PICTURES LIMITED
FIFTH APPLICANT

AND:

CHINATOWN ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
FIRST RESPONDENT

MANDARIN FILMS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD
SECOND RESPONDENT

WING CHEUNG
THIRD RESPONDENT

THO VINH HUYNH
FOURTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BURCHETT J

DATE:

16 DECEMBER 1998

PLACE:

SYDNEY

EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

The applicants move for judgment against the first, third and fourth respondents (the second is in liquidation) pursuant to Order 10, r 7 and Order 20, r 1.

There have been clear failures by the respondents to comply with directions, and particularly with a direction I gave on 9 September 1998 requiring the filing, in certain circumstances which have arisen, of an affidavit disclosing the position, insofar as it is able to be ascertained, as to the results of the exploitation of each of the four films in question in this proceeding, and giving in summary form the financial results of each exploitation.  That, I ordered, was to be done by 20 November 1998.  Up to and including today, there has been no compliance with this direction. 

The nature and persistence of the respondents’ failures lead me to conclude that the case is an appropriate one for the making of orders under Order 10, r 7.  The respondents have shown themselves not prepared to co-operate in the process of bringing this matter to readiness for hearing in accordance with the rules.   See Australian Securities Commission v Macleod (1994) 54 FCR 309 at 310 and 313.

In Macleod, Drummond J held that Order 10, rule 7 does not enable proof of an applicant's case to be dispensed with.  I agree.  Accordingly, it was necessary for the applicants here to prove their case, though ex parte.  However, in considering the evidence, I am entitled, if I think it proper, to afford the applicants the benefit of the exercise of my discretion under Order 33, r 3.

Drummond J mentioned this matter in Macleod at 314, saying:

“[N]otwithstanding the generally restrictive approach the Court has taken to O 33, r 3, as to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maxims Entertainment Pty Ltd v Chinatown Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] FCA 1707
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia heard an application by Maxims Entertainment Pty Ltd and others against Chinatown Enterprises Pty Ltd and others. The applicants sought judgment against the respondents for failing to comply with court directions and for copyright infringement. The court was required to decide whether the respondents' failure to comply with the directions justified the granting of judgment in default, and if so, whether the court could dispense with the usual rules of evidence.

The court held that the respondents' persistent failure to comply with the directions justified the granting of judgment in default, as per the precedent set in Australian Securities Commission v Macleod. The court noted that while proof of the applicant's case was necessary, it was entitled to exercise its discretion under Order 33, rule 3 of the Federal Court Rules to dispense with compliance with the rules of evidence if the facts were not genuinely in dispute or if compliance would cause unnecessary or unreasonable expense or delay. The court found that in this case, the facts were not genuinely in dispute due to the respondents' conduct and that compliance with the rules of evidence would cause unnecessary and unreasonable expense and delay.

Based on the evidence presented, the court found that the copyright in the films in question belonged to one or more of the applicants, and that the first and third respondents had infringed these copyrights. The court awarded the applicants damages in the amount of $15,680 and ordered the first and third respondents to pay seven-eighths of the applicants' costs, including any reserved costs. The matter against the fourth respondent was struck out with no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Maxims Entertainment Pty Ltd, along with three other applicants, initiated legal proceedings against Chinatown Enterprises Pty Ltd and three other respondents regarding the alleged infringement of copyright in four films. The applicants sought damages for the infringement and claimed ownership of the copyright in the films. The case involved the exploitation and financial results of the films, with the applicants asserting that they had entered into distribution agreements that would have resulted in significant income had the infringements not occurred. The applicants also claimed to have already paid out sums related to the films. The respondents failed to comply with court directions to provide relevant information about the exploitation of the films and their financial results.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for judgment against the respondents for their failure to comply with court directions. The applicants sought judgment under Order 10, rule 7 and Order 20, rule 1 of the Federal Court Rules. The court heard the application ex parte due to the respondents' non-compliance with the directions. Justice Burchett considered the evidence presented by the applicants and exercised discretion under Order 33, rule 3 to dispense with the strict rules of evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicants were required to prove their case to be entitled to judgment under Order 10, rule 7.
2. Whether the court could exercise its discretion under Order 33, rule 3 to dispense with the compliance with the rules of evidence in this case.
3. Whether the respondents had genuinely disputed the facts that the applicants sought to prove.
4. Whether compliance with the rules of evidence would cause unnecessary or unreasonable expense or delay in this case.

Held
1. The applicants were required to prove their case to be entitled to judgment under Order 10, rule 7. The court concluded that the applicants needed to prove their case, albeit ex parte, and accordingly, the court found in favour of the applicants.
2. The court could exercise its discretion under Order 33, rule 3 to dispense with the compliance with the rules of evidence in this case. The court exercised its discretion to allow the applicants to rely on affidavit evidence, hearsay evidence, summaries of writings, and generally expressed accounts of events.
3. The respondents had not genuinely disputed the facts that the applicants sought to prove. The court concluded that the facts which the applicants had to prove were not genuinely in dispute in the sense intended by the relevant authorities.
4. Compliance with the rules of evidence would cause unnecessary or unreasonable expense or delay in this case. The court determined that in the circumstances of the case, it would cause unnecessary and unreasonable expense and delay to comply with all of the rules of evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that Order 10, rule 7 does not enable proof of an applicant's case to be dispensed with, and thus, the applicants were required to prove their case. In considering the evidence, the court was entitled to exercise its discretion under Order 33, rule 3 to allow the applicants to rely on affidavit evidence, hearsay evidence, summaries of writings, and generally expressed accounts of events. The court reasoned that the respondents' conduct had resulted in a justified application under Order 10, rule 7, and had also resulted in a hearing proceeding ex parte, thus, the facts which the applicants had to prove were not genuinely in dispute. Furthermore, the court found that unnecessary and unreasonable expense and delay would be occasioned by compliance with all of the rules of evidence. The court referred to Australian Securities Commission v Macleod (1994) 54 FCR 309, Pearce v Button (1986) 8 FCR 408, and Arab Monetary Fund v Hashim (No. 7) [1993] 1 WLR 1014 to support its decision. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that Order 10, rule 7 requires applicants to prove their case, and Order 33, rule 3 may be exercised to dispense with the rules of evidence in appropriate circumstances.