MAURICE HOURANI and TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2012] AATA 518

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2010/5015

Re

MAURICE HOURANI

APPLICANT

And

TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S E Frost

Date 7 August 2012
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

............[sgd]............................................................

Deputy President S E Frost

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION AND REVENUE – tax agents – registration – fit and proper person – improper dealings with client monies – conduct during tax audit – privilege against self-incrimination – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 60

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 4, 128

Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) s 20-5, 20-15

CASES

Ex parte Tziniolis; Re the Medical Practitioners Act (1966) 67 SR(NSW) 448

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S E Frost

7 August 2012

  1. Maurice Hourani applied to the Tax Practitioners Board for registration as a tax agent.  The Board refused his application.  It was not satisfied that he was a “fit and proper person”.  As a result he was not eligible for registration.  Mr Hourani has applied to the Tribunal for review of that decision.

  2. Like the Board, I am not satisfied that Mr Hourani is a fit and proper person.  As a result, I will affirm the decision to refuse him registration as a tax agent.  My reasons follow.

    THE LEGISLATIVE PROVISIONS

  3. Under s 20-5 of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (TAS Act), an individual such as Mr Hourani is “eligible for registration” as a tax agent if the Board is satisfied that, among other things, he is a “fit and proper person”. In deciding whether it is satisfied that Mr Hourani answers that description, the main question to which the Board must have regard is whether he is of “good fame, integrity and character”: s 20-15 of the TAS Act.

  4. On review, these are the questions that the Tribunal, standing in the shoes of the Board, must consider.

    A PRELIMINARY QUESTION CONCERNING S 128 OF THE EVIDENCE ACT

  5. Before the hearing, Mr Hourani’s counsel foreshadowed that Mr Hourani may wish to claim the privilege against self-incrimination and for that reason may ask the Tribunal to give a certificate in his favour under s 128 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Section 128 provides:

    128  Privilege in respect of self-incrimination in other proceedings

    (1)This section applies if a witness objects to giving particular evidence, or evidence on a particular matter, on the ground that the evidence may tend to prove that the witness:

    (a)     has committed an offence against or arising under an Australian law or a law of a foreign country; or

    (b)     is liable to a civil penalty.

    (2)The court must determine whether or not there are reasonable grounds for the objection.

    (3)If the court determines that there are reasonable grounds for the objection, the court is to inform the witness:

    (a)     that the witness need not give the evidence unless required by the court to do so under subsection (4); and

    (b)     that the court will give…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MAURICE HOURANI and TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 518
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Maurice Hourani and the Tax Practitioners Board, the primary dispute involved the fitness and propriety of Mr. Hourani, a former tax agent, to be registered as such. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with reviewing a decision made by the Tax Practitioners Board regarding Mr. Hourani's registration. The Tribunal had to determine whether Mr. Hourani was a fit and proper person to hold such registration, given past allegations of improper conduct, including dealings with client funds and behaviour during an audit.

The legal issues before the court included whether Mr. Hourani could invoke the privilege against self-incrimination during the review process and if the AAT had the authority to grant a certificate under Section 128 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Additionally, the court had to assess the credibility of Mr. Hourani's evidence and the weight of character evidence provided by Father Hailkal, who testified on Mr. Hourani's behalf.

The AAT found that Mr. Hourani was not a fit and proper person to be registered as a tax agent, primarily due to his conduct during the relevant period and his inability to convincingly address the allegations against him. The court dismissed Mr. Hourani's claim that he could invoke the privilege against self-incrimination and that the AAT could grant a certificate under Section 128 of the Evidence Act. The AAT concluded that Mr. Hourani's evidence did not meet the necessary standards to overturn the Board's decision, and the character evidence provided by Father Hailkal was deemed insufficient as he was unaware of the allegations against Mr. Hourani. Consequently, the AAT affirmed the Board's decision to deny Mr. Hourani's registration as a tax agent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

It follows that the Tribunal cannot give a certificate under s 128 of the Evidence Act. The submission at (e) in [6] above does not alter that outcome.THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND The Board’s concerns with respect to Mr Hourani’s fitness and propriety stem from things that Mr Hourani did during the period from about 2000 or 2001, to 2005. What follows is an account of events and circumstances from Mr Hourani’s perspective. Unless otherwise indicated, I accept Mr Hourani’s account as an accurate statement of events as he understands them to have been. That is not to say that I necessarily accept that the events occurred as he describes them, but I do accept that this is his view of what occurred. If events occurred as Mr Hourani describes them, then his employer at the time is cast in an extremely unfavourable light. It would not be fair for me to make findings about the involvement of the employer in these events because he has not been represented here and he has had no opportunity to counter Mr Hourani’s version of events. For present purposes it is sufficient to record, and if necessary make findings in relation to, what Mr Hourani observed, how he processed what he observed, and how he reacted to it. Whether his observations are accurate is another question, and one that does not need to be answered in the context of these proceedings.Improper dealings with client money During the period of concern to the Board, Mr Hourani had been employed in a professional practice known as MSB Taxation & Accounting Services. MSB operated in a number of suburban locations, including Bankstown, Fairfield, Merrylands, Liverpool, Bossley Park, Blacktown and Campbelltown. Mr Hourani started working for the practice in 1995 and stayed there until 2006. His duties included providing financial and taxation advice, preparing financial statements and preparing tax returns. MSB was owned and operated by an accountant and registered tax agent named Mofid Bebawy. Mr Hourani was 25 years old when he met Mr Bebawy and started working for MSB. At the time he was MSB’s only employee. Mr Bebawy seems to have been something of an entrepreneur. By about 2002 he had established a number of businesses under the name “Advance”, including Advance Home Loans and Advance Travel Centre. He eventually employed about 120 people across the Advance group. At one stage, in about 2000, according to Mr Hourani, the MSB accounting practice had as many as 27,000 clients. When Mr Bebawy decided to open the MSB office in Fairfield, he chose Mr Hourani to run that office. It appears to have been a successful venture, with the office growing to a practice roughly 80% the size of the main practice in Bankstown. Mr Hourani developed what he described as a “very close” professional relationship with Mr Bebawy. Mr Hourani says that he regarded Mr Bebawy as a friend and mentor. Apart from their professional relationship, they also socialised to some extent. They would sometimes have lunch together on weekdays. On occasion Mr Hourani would go to Mr Bebawy’s house for dinner on Friday nights. He would sometimes go to Mr Bebawy’s house on Sunday mornings, before going to church.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On review, these are the questions that the Tribunal, standing in the shoes of the Board, must consider.A PRELIMINARY QUESTION CONCERNING S 128 OF THE EVIDENCE ACT Before the hearing, Mr Hourani’s counsel foreshadowed that Mr Hourani may wish to claim the privilege against self-incrimination and for that reason may ask the Tribunal to give a certificate in his favour under s 128 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Section 128 provides:128 Privilege in respect of self-incrimination in other proceedings(1)This section applies if a witness objects to giving particular evidence, or evidence on a particular matter, on the ground that the evidence may tend to prove that the witness:(a) has committed an offence against or arising under an Australian law or a law of a foreign country; or(b) is liable to a civil penalty.(2)The court must determine whether or not there are reasonable grounds for the objection.(3)If the court determines that there are reasonable grounds for the objection, the court is to inform the witness:(a) that the witness need not give the evidence unless required by the court to do so under subsection (4); and(b) that the court will give a certificate under this section if:(i)the witness willingly gives the evidence without being required to do so under subsection (4); or(ii)the witness gives the evidence after being required to do so under subsection (4); and(c) of the effect of such a certificate.(4)The court may require the witness to give the evidence if the court is satisfied that:(a) the evidence does not tend to prove that the witness has committed an offence against or arising under, or is liable to a civil penalty under, a law of a foreign country; and(b) the interests of justice require that the witness give the evidence.(5)If the witness either willingly gives the evidence without being required to do so under subsection (4), or gives it after being required to do so under that subsection, the court must cause the witness to be given a certificate under this section in respect of the evidence.(6)The court is also to cause a witness to be given a certificate under this section if:(a) the objection has been overruled; and(b) after the evidence has been given, the court finds that there were reasonable grounds for the objection.(7)In any proceeding in an Australian court:(a) evidence given by a person in respect of which a certificate under this section has been given; and(b) evidence of any information, document or thing obtained as a direct or indirect consequence of the person having given evidence;cannot be used against the person. However, this does not apply to a criminal proceeding in respect of the falsity of the evidence.Note: Subsection 128(7) differs from subsection 128(7) of the NSW Act. The NSW provision refers to a NSW Court instead of an Australian Court.… Mr Hourani submitted that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to give a certificate under s 128 based on the following:a. Section 60(3) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, (‘AAT Act’) states that a witness in the Tribunal is entitled to certain protections. The subsection is in the following terms:Subject to this Act, a person summoned to attend or appearing before the Tribunal as a witness has the same protection, and is, in addition to the penalties provided by this Act, subject to the same liabilities, as a witness in proceedings in the High Court. (Emphasis added)b. The High Court of Australia is a court to which the Evidence Act applies by force of section 4 of the Evidence Act because it is a “federal court”, as defined in the Dictionary to the Evidence Act.c. The courts have said that the privilege against self-incrimination is a substantive “protection”, rather than a rule of evidence: Pyneboard Pty Ltd v Trade Practices Commission (1983) 152 CLR 328 at 309 [sic]. Accordingly, a provision that protects witnesses against self-incrimination, such as s 128, should properly be regarded as a “protection” within the terms of s 60(3).d. The conjoint operation of s 60(3) of the AAT Act and ss 4 and 128 of the Evidence Act permits the Tribunal to award an evidentiary certificate on terms that are similar to those prescribed by s 128, because this is the protection that is available to a witness in the High Court.e. It is no obstacle to the grant by the Tribunal of a certificate that s 128 empowers a ‘court’ to grant certificates. It is well established that where one statute (‘the primary statute’) incorporates and gives effect to a provision from another statute (‘the incorporated statute’), the provision from the incorporated statute applies mutatis mutandis in conjunction with the primary statute: Georgoussis v Medical Board of Victoria [1957] VR 671, Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1984) 1 FCR 409. Accordingly, it is open for the Tribunal to apply s 128.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no such proof. Father Hailkal’s character evidence does not assist Mr Hourani because Father Hailkal was not aware of what was alleged against Mr Hourani.CONCLUSION I am not satisfied that Mr Hourani is a fit and proper person to be registered as a tax agent. The Board’s decision is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.