Matthews v. Commissioner Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2005] QSC 122

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

McMURDO J

No BS2817 of 2005

RUSSELL GORDON HAIG MATTHEWS Applicant

and

COMMISSIONER BOB ATKINSON
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 27/04/2005

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  This is the return of an originating application filed by Mr R G H Matthews against the Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service.  The application seeks three orders by way of final relief.  It seeks two declarations and an injunction.

The applicant's case is that he suffers from a disability discrimination which is unlawful as contrary to The Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth).  His disability, according to the evidence, comes from a brain injury which, according to a letter from Dr R J Moyle of the University Health Service of the University of Queensland, affects his lifestyle and contributes to his feeling of isolation.

The applicant maintains that he needs to go anywhere accompanied by his two dogs.  According to Dr Moyle:

"Without the dogs he would feel bereft and his life would lack the only positive interactions he seems to have.  He takes them everywhere and provides for their care."

The applicant is undertaking some study at the University of Queensland.  In the course of his submissions he told me that he was pursuing a PhD.  He therefore is a frequent visitor to a library or libraries at the University of Queensland and a problem which has arisen there, as it has elsewhere, is that his dogs are not welcome.  He is told when he goes there that he is not to bring the dogs into the library and, on occasions, the police have been called to insist upon the dogs not being there.  Similarly, he has encountered problems travelling with his dogs on public transport within Brisbane and again that has resulted in the police being called.

He therefore maintains that he is the subject of discrimination by not being able to access premises and use facilities, which discrimination contravenes section 23 and 24 of the Act.

In turn, he says that the Commissioner of Police is a proper respondent because the Police Service has been called upon to effectively apply what he says is this unlawful discrimination. 

He seeks a declaration that he is entitled to access premises, areas and spaces, including public transport, accompanied by his dogs.  He seeks an injunction to restrain the respondent, the Commissioner of Police, from removing him or requiring him to remove himself from premises, areas or spaces, including public transport, when he is accompanied by his dogs.  He also seeks a further declaration:

"The applicant is owed a fiduciary duty by the defendant and his servants and agents."

The application is in all respects opposed by the respondent. The principal basis for the respondent's opposition is that he is not an appropriate party and that this Court is not the appropriate forum for any complaint of such discrimination. Instead, it is submitted the appropriate avenue of complaint is through the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Matthews v. Commissioner Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QSC 122
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Queensland, the case of Matthews v. Commissioner Queensland Police Service was heard by McMurdo J. The applicant, Russell Gordon Haig Matthews, filed an originating application against the Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service, alleging discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) due to his disability, which stems from a brain injury. Matthews claims that his disability necessitates the presence of his two dogs, which he relies on for companionship and to alleviate feelings of isolation. He argues that he faces discrimination when denied access to certain public spaces, such as libraries and public transport, because of his dogs. Matthews sought a declaration affirming his right to access these spaces with his dogs and an injunction to prevent their removal by the police.

The court needed to determine whether Matthews could establish unlawful discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act, which would warrant the granting of declaratory and injunctive relief. Additionally, the court had to assess if the Supreme Court was the appropriate forum for such a complaint and if the necessary factual findings could be made in this proceeding. The Commissioner argued that the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission was the proper body to address such discrimination claims. The court concluded that the application was not suitable for final relief via a summary hearing due to the absence of relevant parties and the complexity of the factual issues involved.

The court dismissed the application on the grounds that it was not the appropriate forum for the complaint, and the necessary factual findings could not be properly made in the current proceeding. Additionally, the court found no basis for the applicant's request for a declaration of a fiduciary duty owed by the Commissioner of Police. Consequently, the originating application filed on 27 April 2005 was dismissed without any order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Russell Gordon Haig Matthews, the applicant, suffers from a disability discrimination resulting from a brain injury. The injury affects his lifestyle and contributes to his feeling of isolation. Matthews requires constant companionship of his two dogs, which he takes everywhere and cares for. These dogs provide him with the only positive interactions he has. Matthews is a student at the University of Queensland, pursuing a PhD, and frequently visits the university libraries. However, these libraries do not permit dogs, which has resulted in Matthews being told not to bring his dogs into the library and the police being called on occasions. Matthews has also encountered problems with bringing his dogs on public transport in Brisbane, resulting in police intervention. Matthews asserts that these incidents are instances of discrimination that contravene sections 23 and 24 of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). He argues that the Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service, as the respondent, should be held accountable because the police have been involved in enforcing these discriminatory practices.

The case originated as an application filed by Matthews against the Commissioner of the Queensland Police Service. Matthews sought three orders by way of final relief: two declarations and an injunction. The application was filed on 27 April 2005. The respondent, the Commissioner of Police, opposed the application, arguing that Matthews was not an appropriate party and that the court was not the appropriate forum for his complaint. The respondent contended that the appropriate avenue for such complaints was through the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission under part IIB of the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Matthews has established the factual matter of unlawful discrimination as required to ask the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour to grant declaratory and/or injunctive relief.
2. Whether the present proceedings permit any necessary factual finding to be properly made.
3. Whether the court is the appropriate forum for Matthews' complaint of discrimination.
4. Whether the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission is the appropriate body to handle Matthews' complaint.
5. Whether the absence of relevant parties, such as the University of Queensland and those responsible for the operation of public transport, is a critical consideration in the exercise of the discretion to grant or not grant declaratory and injunctive relief.
6. Whether Matthews is owed a fiduciary duty by the Commissioner of Police and his servants and agents.

Held
1. The court concluded that Matthews had not established the factual matter of unlawful discrimination as required to ask the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour to grant declaratory and/or injunctive relief.
2. The court held that the present proceedings would not permit any necessary factual finding to be properly made.
3. The court determined that the court was not the appropriate forum for Matthews' complaint of discrimination.
4. The court found that the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission was the appropriate body to handle Matthews' complaint.
5. The absence of relevant parties, such as the University of Queensland and those responsible for the operation of public transport, was a critical consideration in the exercise of the discretion to grant or not grant declaratory and injunctive relief.
6. The court held that Matthews was not owed a fiduciary duty by the Commissioner of Police and his servants and agents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by noting that Matthews would need to establish the factual matter of unlawful discrimination before asking the Court to exercise its discretion in his favour to grant declaratory and/or injunctive relief. However, the court found that the present proceedings, as they were constituted, would not permit any necessary factual finding to be properly made. The court observed that even if Matthews was disabled, the case that there was discrimination would need to be shown to be within either section 6 or section 9 of the Disability Discrimination Act, which the present material did not support. Furthermore, the parties allegedly discriminating were not before the court, and the court was not the appropriate forum for such complaints. The court concluded that the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission was the appropriate body to handle Matthews' complaint, as it provided a specialist regime for such circumstances and particular procedures for the resolution of such disputes. The absence of relevant parties, such as the University of Queensland and those responsible for the operation of public transport, was a critical consideration in the exercise of the discretion to grant or not grant declaratory and injunctive relief. Finally, the court found that there was no basis for Matthews' request for a declaration that he was owed a fiduciary duty by the Commissioner of Police and his servants and agents.

===