FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| MATTHEWS & BENDER | [2015] FamCA 654 |
| FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – Best interests – where final orders were previously made that the child live with the father and that the father have sole parental responsibility – where the mother seeks to reopen the question of with whom the child lives – Rice & Asplund considered – where the question of the mother’s time with the child was reserved – whether the mother’s time with the child, if any, should be supervised – where the mother has consistently engaged in conduct likely to undermine the child’s relationship with the father – finding that the mother lacks insight into the effect of her behaviour upon the child – final orders made that the child have supervised time with the mother on one occasion per month under professional supervision – final orders made that the mother be restrained from bringing any application with respect to the child without leave for a period of two years |
| Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) |
| Bale-Sutch & Bale-Sutch (No. 2) [2010] FamCA 20 | ||
| APPLICANT: | Mr Matthews | |
| RESPONDENT: | Ms Bender |
| INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: | Glezer Lanteri & Associates Pty Ltd |
| FILE NUMBER: | MLC | 3524 | of | 2008 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 11 June 2015 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Melbourne |
| PLACE HEARD: | Melbourne |
| JUDGMENT OF: | Johns J |
| HEARING DATE: | 20 - 23 January 2015 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | Ms O'Connell |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: | Fiona R McGregor |
| THE RESPONDENT: | In person |
| COUNSEL FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: | Ms Agresta |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: | Glezer Lanteri & Associates Pty Ltd |
Orders
That the mother spend time and communicate with the child M born … 2005 as follows:-
(a)At the I Contact Centre (“the contact centre”) for a period of two hours on one occasion per month on the following bases:-
(i)such time to take place on days and at times nominated by the contact centre;
(ii)the mother to be solely responsible for the cost of supervision; and
(iii)the mother to comply with all reasonable directions as may be made by the contact centre in order to facilitate supervision of her time with the child.
(b)By telephone on Christmas Day, Easter Sunday, the child’s birthday, the mother’s birthday and Mother's Day each year and to facilitate such communication:-
(i)such calls to take place at 6.00 pm on each occasion unless otherwise agreed between the mother and father in writing;
(ii)the father do all acts and things to ensure that the child initiates the telephone call to the mother’s landline or mobile number;
(iii)the father be at liberty to monitor the telephone calls on loudspeaker…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MATTHEWS & BENDER and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FamCA 654
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the appropriate arrangements for the mother to spend time and communicate with the child, M. This included the frequency and nature of contact, the role of supervised contact, telephone communication, and the provision of gifts and letters. The court also had to consider the child's ongoing therapy and counselling, the use of a communication book, and whether to impose injunctions and restrictions on the mother's future applications to the court.
Johns J made detailed orders regarding the mother's contact with the child, primarily through supervised contact at a contact centre once a month for two hours, with the mother responsible for supervision costs. Communication was also permitted via telephone on specific annual occasions and at other reasonable times requested by the child, with the father having the right to monitor and terminate calls if the mother discussed undermining topics. The father was also directed to facilitate the child sending letters, cards, or gifts to the mother. The court ordered the father to ensure the child continued therapy with Dr J, with the father bearing the costs, and that such therapy be reportable. A communication book was to be used to keep the mother informed about the child's welfare. Crucially, the mother was restrained by injunction from attending the child's school or extra-curricular activities without written agreement, and from making further applications under Part VII of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth) without leave until July 2017. The court noted that the mother had not addressed significant psychological issues impacting her functioning and self-awareness, leading to a lack of confidence that she would change, and that further litigation would not be in the child's best interests.
The court ordered the discharge of the Independent Children's Lawyer and dismissed all extant applications. The orders included a fact sheet detailing obligations and consequences of contravention, pursuant to sections 65DA(2) and 62B of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth). Documents produced to the court were to be returned after thirty days or upon the conclusion of any appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
That the mother spend time and communicate with the child M born … 2005 as follows:-
(a) At the I Contact Centre (“the contact centre”) for a period of two hours on one occasion per month on the following bases:-
(i) such time to take place on days and at times nominated by the contact centre;
(ii) the mother to be solely responsible for the cost of supervision; and
(iii) the mother to comply with all reasonable directions as may be made by the contact centre in order to facilitate supervision of her time with the child.
(b) By telephone on Christmas Day, Easter Sunday, the child’s birthday, the mother’s birthday and Mother's Day each year and to facilitate such communication:-
(i) such calls to take place at 6.00 pm on each occasion unless otherwise agreed between the mother and father in writing;
(ii) the father do all acts and things to ensure that the child initiates the telephone call to the mother’s landline or mobile number;
(iii) the father be at liberty to monitor the telephone calls on loudspeaker and terminate the calls in the event that the mother discusses subjects or issues that may undermine the child’s relationship with her paternal family or destabilise her care arrangements; and
(iv) the mother keep the father advised at all times of a current telephone number on which she can be contacted.
(c) By telephone at all other reasonable times as may be requested by the child to her father and the father ensure that upon such request he do all things necessary to facilitate the child communicating with her mother by telephone;
(d) By letter, card and/or gift on the special days referred to in sub-paragraph (b) of this order with such items to be provided to the child by the mother at the contact centre on the occasion of time to be spent that occurs closest to the special day; and
(e) At any other times as agreed between the mother and the father in writing.
2.
That the father ensure that in the event that the child wishes to communicate with the mother by way of card, letter and/or gift to her mother at any other time during the year he facilitate such requests by the child and do all such acts and things as may be required to provide such items to the mother at the contact centre on the first occasion of time after such request has been communicated to him by the child.
3.
That the father do all acts and things as may be required to ensure that the child continues to attend upon Dr J or her nominee for such therapy or counselling support as may be recommended by Dr J, the father to be solely responsible for the cost of that therapy and/or counselling support.
4.
That any therapy or counselling provided by Dr J to the child be conducted on a reportable basis.
5.
That the father and mother utilise a communication book which is to be provided to the mother at the beginning of each occasion of supervised time and returned to the father at the end of that period of time with the purpose of the said book being to provide the mother with up-to-date information on a monthly basis about the care, welfare and development of the child including but not limited to details of her extra-curricular activities, her involvement in special events, her special academic or educational achievements, and her attendances on any medical or dental specialists.
6.
That the mother by herself, her servants or agents be and is hereby restrained by injunction from attending at the child’s school or any place where the child is engaged in extra-curricular activities unless otherwise agreed in writing between the father and mother.
7.
That until 1 July 2017 the mother be and is hereby restrained from making any application in respect of the child under part VII of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) to any court having jurisdiction under the Act without leave of a Judge of the Family Court of Australia first obtained.
8.
That the appointment of the Independent Children’s Lawyer be discharged.
9.
That all extant applications be otherwise dismissed.
10.
That pursuant to s 65DA(2) and s 62B, the particulars of the obligations these orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these orders and details of who can assist parties adjust to and comply with an order are set out in the Fact Sheet attached hereto and these particulars are included in these orders.
IT IS DIRECTED
That all documents produced to the Court pursuant to subpoena and exhibits relied upon by the parties be returned by the subpoena clerk of the Family Court of Australia, Melbourne Registry, to the person or organisation who produced same after the expiration of thirty (30) days from the date of these orders, or otherwise upon the conclusion of any appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I do not propose to make any orders providing leave to the mother to make application at that time to review the question of supervision. At the time of the hearing before me, some 16 months had elapsed since Macmillan J’s orders were made; it was evident at the hearing before me that the mother had done little to address the significant issues impacting upon her psychological functioning and self-awareness as to the impact of her behaviours upon the child. In light of the evidence of Ms T and Dr P, I have no confidence that the mother will address those issues in the aftermath of this judgment. I am satisfied that to invite further litigation in circumstances where there is currently little prospect of change in the mother’s psychological functioning would be contrary to the child’s best interests.(d)the likely effect of any changes in the child’s circumstances, including the likely effect on the child of any separation from:(i) either of his or her parents; or (ii) any other child, or other person (including any grandparent or other relative of the child), with whom he or she has been living; Both Dr P and Dr J gave evidence in relation to their view as to the appropriate frequency of the child’s time with the mother. Dr J in her report dated 13 December 2014 (annexed to her affidavit of 14 January 2015) opines at page 5 as follows:-The court faces a very challenging decision regarding what is best for [the child’s] wellbeing. A non-contact order is certainly a valid option. A further option worth considering is for supervised contact to be of a pattern that is least disruptive to [the child’s] life, but still allows some knowledge and understanding of her mother, and continued opportunities for [the child] to assert herself (supervised) in the relationship. This could look something like supervised contact every two months, or even on special occasions such as around the time of birthdays, Mother's Day and Christmas. I would not be recommending that the contact build up to more often, or build up to unsupervised. With regard to the phone contact, in my opinion, the calls are adding little to [the child’s] wellbeing and are possibly just disruptive to her life. I would not be in favour of the phone calls continuing in between any supervised contact, if this is the outcome. During cross-examination by counsel for the ICL, Dr J was questioned as to the basis for her nominating two months as the appropriate frequency between the child’s visits with the mother. Dr J responded to that question as follows:-I guess I’m not committed strongly to it being two monthly. I raised that as a suggestion. I’m very much aware of the potential that [the child] is just pleasing all of the adults by continuing contact, and, alongside that, as she matures and gets older, children’s lives just get busier these days, and if it’s too onerous and too often, my concern would be that she would actually not want to go. Counsel for the ICL then questioned Dr J as to the potential impact on the child if the time between she and the mother was too limited. In particular, counsel for the ICL invited Dr J to consider the impact upon the mother if the time is so limited and the potential distress such limited time would occasion, particularly if the mother is not seeking treatment to support her in coming to terms with the orders. Dr J conceded that her recommendation of two months was “a suggestion, a recommendation but there’s nothing definite about it”.