Matthews and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Matthews and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2020] AATA 1163 (6 May 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2018/5544

Re:Timothy Matthews

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:R CAMERON, SENIOR MEMBER

DR S LEWINSKY, MEMBER

Date:6 May 2020  

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.........[sgd]...............................................                   ……[sgd]……………………….
R CAMERON, SENIOR MEMBER  DR S LEWINSKY, MEMBER            

Catchwords

CIVIL AVIATION – Class 1 and Class 2 medical certificate – medical standards – brain injury – substance abuse disorder – personality disorder – medically significant condition – safety-relevant condition – can any conditions be imposed – no conditions able to ameliorate risk – reviewable decision affirmed

Legislation

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth)

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21
Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952

REASONS FOR DECISION

R CAMERON SENIOR MEMBER & DR S LEWINSKY MEMBER

6 May 2020

INTRODUCTION: THE REVIEWABLE DECISION

  1. The Applicant seeks a review of a decision made on 24 September 2018 by the        Senior Aviation Medical Officer of the Respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (“CASA”), confirming a previous decision to refuse to issue to the Applicant a Class 1 and Class 2 Medical Certificate (“the reviewable decision”).

    THE APPLICABLE REGULATORY REGIME

  2. CASA is the regulator of civil aviation in Australia established under the relevant provisions of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”).

  3. Section 3A of the Act specifies as its objects the establishment of a “regulatory framework for maintaining, enhancing and promoting the safety of civil aviation, with particular emphasis on preventing aviation accidents and incidents.”

  4. Section 9A of the Act requires CASA, and the Tribunal stepping into its shoes as a decision maker, to have regard for the safety of air navigation as the most important consideration when exercising the powers and performing the functions conferred upon it under the Act.

  5. The Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1988 (Cth) (“CASR”) have been made under the powers conferred by the Act, and these regulate the issue of various categories of applicable medical certificates.

  6. The applicable regulations of the CASR are referred to for their full force and effect but need not be reproduced in these reasons. Under the applicable regulations, the holder of a pilot licence, whether commercial or private, must also hold the applicable class of medical certificate.[1] In this case the applicable medical certificates are Class 1 and 2.

    [1] CASR 61.410 and 61.415.

  7. The requirements for the issue of medical certificates are found in Part 67 of the CASR.

  8. The Tribunal refers to several definitions contained in “Subpart 67.A - General” of the CASR that are relevant to the issues for determination by the Tribunal in this application.

  9. The term “medically significant condition” is subject to a comparatively broad definition which applies to any of several conditions identified “no matter how minor” (emphasis added)[2]. These conditions include any illness or injury, bodily or mental infirmity defect or incapacity or sequela, abnormal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Matthews and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered an application by Mr. Matthews for a Class 1 and Class 2 medical certificate, which had been refused by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). The dispute centred on whether Mr. Matthews met the required medical standards for such a certificate, given his history of a significant head injury, substance abuse disorders, and a personality disorder. CASA contended that these conditions were medically significant and safety-relevant, potentially endangering air navigation.

The Tribunal was required to determine three key issues: first, whether Mr. Matthews met the medical standards for the issue of a Class 1 or Class 2 medical certificate; second, if he did not, whether his failure to meet those standards was likely to endanger the safety of air navigation; and third, if so, whether any conditions could be imposed on a medical certificate to mitigate the identified risks to air safety. The Applicant identified his head injury, drug use, and personality disorder as issues for consideration, while CASA specifically contended for opiate, alcohol, and cannabis use disorders, as well as a personality disorder and the sequelae of a closed head injury.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the safety-relevant nature of the Applicant's conditions. It found that the Applicant's head injury, evidenced by left frontal lobe gliosis and subsequent encephalomalacia, constituted a medically significant and safety-relevant condition. This condition meant the Applicant did not meet specific medical standards related to neurological function and cognitive efficiency. Furthermore, the Tribunal concluded that due to the nature of the head injury, no conditions could be imposed on a medical certificate that would adequately ameliorate the threat posed to air safety.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed CASA's decision to refuse the medical certificate. It found that Mr. Matthews did not meet the medical standards for a Class 1 or Class 2 medical certificate, that his failure to meet these standards was likely to endanger air navigation, and that no conditions could be imposed to mitigate this risk.

Background

Background to the litigation

Helpfully, the Respondent has identified what the Tribunal considers to be the relevant issues for determination in this application. Those issues are:(a)Whether the Applicant meets the medical standard for the issue of a Class 1 or Class 2 medical certificate;(b)If not, whether the extent to which the Applicant fails to meet those standards is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation; and(c)If so, whether any conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate which would ameliorate the threat posed to air safety by the Applicant’s failure to meet the Class 1 and/or Class 2 medical standard.SOME RELEVANT FACTS On or about 12 November 2016, the Applicant applied for a Class 1 and 2 medical certificate. A medical examination was conducted by a Designated Aviation Medical Examiner (“DAME”) Dr Jeffrey Farrow on 17 November 2016. A “Medical Examination Summary” of that examination was prepared by Dr Farrow in the prescribed form and submitted to the Respondent.[6] The medical examination addressed several matters, particularly a head injury suffered by the Applicant in approximately June of 1992. The Applicant’s condition arising from the head injury had been brought to the attention of the Respondent previously, in approximately 2000.[6] Document T 10 of the T documents; the CASA Application for Aviation Medical Certificate-Declaration is document T 11 of the T documents. In evidence before the Tribunal there was a report prepared by Dr Michael Poon, a Neurologist/Clinical Neurophysiologist, dated 3 February 2017.[7] In that report, Dr Poon advised that midway through the year of 1992 the Applicant had a horse riding accident when he was not wearing a helmet. He sustained what was described as a closed head injury requiring treatment at St Vincent’s Hospital. A follow-up scan demonstrated left frontal lobe gliosis as a result of the accident. In 2002, an electroencephalogram (“EEG”), a computerized tomography (“CT”) scan and neuropsychology were performed on the Applicant. Dr Poon recorded there had never been any seizures experienced by the Applicant, and that a further EEG and magnetic resonance imaging (“MRI”) had been arranged to be undertaken. Additionally, he noted that with respect to neuropsychology, there had been an assessment performed by Dr Bardenhagen in 2002. However, she had apparently since passed away. It was intended to arrange a further assessment through the Alfred Hospital.[7] Document T 19 of the T documents. The Medical Examination Summary produced by Dr Farrow was considered by a Senior Aviation Medical Officer of the Respondent.The 19 December 2016 letter from the Senior Aviation Medical Officer to the Applicant Following the medical examination and provision of the Medical Examination Summary, on 19 December 2016 Dr Mike Seah, a Senior Aviation Medical Officer, sent a letter to the Applicant identifying five “significant conditions” in the Applicant’s history that required further “clarification/investigation”[8]. The letter specified further information the Respondent required concerning these significant conditions before the application for the relevant medical certificates could proceed further. The significant conditions identified in that letter are discussed below.[8] The letter is document T 12 in the T documents.Head injury

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Regulation 67.165 of the CASR provides that if the Respondent has reason to believe that an applicant for the issue of a medical certificate has a condition that may, if they are issued with the medical certificate, endanger the safety of air navigation, the Respondent may direct such applicant to submit to an examination by an appropriate medical practitioner or health care professional as the case may be. This is relevant to regulation 67.180(2)(F), which provides that the Respondent must issue a medical certificate if, after the Respondent has directed the applicant to undergo such an examination it has taken place and having taken into account the results of same, the Respondent is satisfied that issuing a medical certificate to the applicant would not endanger the safety of air navigation.THE EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL There was both oral and documentary evidence before the Tribunal at the hearing of the application. Dr Sharma, Senior Medical Officer, Aviation Medicine of CASA and Dr Michael Atherton, a Psychiatrist and Addiction Specialist, gave oral evidence. The following documentary evidence was tendered before the Tribunal:·a document prepared by the Applicant and lodged with the Respondent “Response to refusal of class 1 & 2 medical” dated 12 March 2019;·medical Report of Dr Plumley dated 20 March 2019;·email dated 20 May 2019 from Steve Brass to Timothy Matthews;·statement of Dr Sharma dated 8 May 2019; and·medical Report of Dr Atherton dated 2 May 2019. Both parties also lodged various submissions and Statements of Facts, Issues and Contentions. The Applicant did not give oral evidence at the hearing but instead decided to make submissions from the bar table. He was given the opportunity to enter the witness box and give evidence on oath or affirmation, but he chose not to do so. The Tribunal does not draw any adverse inferences against him by reason of him not giving oral evidence.ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION Helpfully, the Respondent has identified what the Tribunal considers to be the relevant issues for determination in this application. Those issues are:(a)Whether the Applicant meets the medical standard for the issue of a Class 1 or Class 2 medical certificate;(b)If not, whether the extent to which the Applicant fails to meet those standards is likely to endanger the safety of air navigation; and(c)If so, whether any conditions could be imposed upon a medical certificate which would ameliorate the threat posed to air safety by the Applicant’s failure to meet the Class 1 and/or Class 2 medical standard.SOME RELEVANT FACTS On or about 12 November 2016, the Applicant applied for a Class 1 and 2 medical certificate. A medical examination was conducted by a Designated Aviation Medical Examiner (“DAME”) Dr Jeffrey Farrow on 17 November 2016. A “Medical Examination Summary” of that examination was prepared by Dr Farrow in the prescribed form and submitted to the Respondent.[6] The medical examination addressed several matters, particularly a head injury suffered by the Applicant in approximately June of 1992. The Applicant’s condition arising from the head injury had been brought to the attention of the Respondent previously, in approximately 2000.[6] Document T 10 of the T documents; the CASA Application for Aviation Medical Certificate-Declaration is document T 11 of the T documents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given these circumstances, the Tribunal cannot conclude that the Applicant does not meet the Class 1 or Class 2 medical standards by reason of an alleged personality or anxiety disorder.CONCLUSION The Tribunal finds that based on the available evidence, the Applicant’s head injury is a safety relevant condition within the meaning of regulation 67.015 of the CASR and therefore the Class 1 and Class 2 medical standards 1.1 and 2.1, 1.4 and 2.4 and 1.8 and 2.8. The Tribunal finds that the Applicant does not meet the medical standard for the issue of a Class 1 or Class 2 medical certificate. The Tribunal also finds that the Applicant fails to meet those standards to an extent that would likely endanger the safety of air navigation. The Tribunal also concludes that due to the nature of the head injury, there are no conditions that could be imposed upon a medical certificate that would ameliorate the threat posed to air safety. By reason of the foregoing matters the Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal noted the reference in two reports that monitoring during pilot training was a modality for monitoring the practical impact of the head injury. The Tribunal considers it is not clear how this would come about and evaded the need (obligation) to directly assess the condition for the review at this time.CONSIDERATIONThe Applicants Conditions The Applicant in his final submission identified three issues for consideration:(a)head injury;(b)drug use; and(c)personality disorder. The Respondent in its Outline of Submissions contended that the Tribunal should be satisfied on the basis of the available medical evidence, that the Applicant had the following medically significant conditions:(a)opiate use disorder;(b)alcohol use disorder; and(c)cannabis use disorder. These three disorders adopted by the Respondent are obviously derived from the analysis and conclusions in Dr Atherton’s report.[28] The Tribunal will consider the opiate, alcohol and cannabis use disorders under the collective description “drug use” as used by the Applicant. [28] The specific response to "Q 14" of Dr Atherton's report (Exhibit R3). Dr Atherton did refer to “personality disorder” and some of the other experts indicated concerns in that regard and it also can probably be considered as a useful generic descriptor of that alleged condition or similar ones as described in the material.The Head Injury In its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, the Respondent in various ways refers to what is described as a history of closed head injury, and refers to the recent neuropsychologist testing which indicated a fluctuating speed of information processing as have been previously addressed in these reasons. The Applicant contended that in effect his head injury had stabilised, and its manifestations have remained constant since the accident concerned. He stated that he has never suffered “any side effects as a result of the accident”. It is also contended that he has never had an epileptic seizure or, has any family history of epilepsy. Another contention made by him is that because no comparable neuropsychological tests were conducted before he suffered his head injury, there is in effect, no yardstick by which to measure his cognitive efficiency, and therefore any conclusion to some extent is left open to “assumption and speculation as to any ongoing subsequent issues as a result of the accident”. The Respondent relied on the contents of the various reports referred to above as what it describes as the history of closed head injury with left frontal and right posterior lobe encephalomalacia as a sequela of the accident, which has produced a degree of functional incapacity or risk of incapacitation. It is, therefore, a physical condition which is safety relevant within the definition of the CASR. By reason of these matters, the Applicant does not meet the criteria applicable for medical standards 1.1 (b) and (d), 2.1 (b) and (d), 1.2 and 2.2. Following on from this conclusion, it is contended that the Applicant has a history suggestive of a personality disorder, which could be premorbid or a sequela of an earlier head injury, and further by reason of such matters, the Applicant does not meet the criteria applicable for medical standards 1.4 and 2.4. Once again, it is contended on behalf of the Respondent due to the Applicant’s history of the closed head injury, with a recent brain MRI demonstrating left frontal and right posterior lobe encephalomalacia, he does not meet the criteria applicable for medical standards 1.8 and 2.8.