Mattana Coiffure Pty Limited v Sotiropoulos (No2)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Set aside by Appeal:

Set aside by Appeal in part 6/10/2004
Sotiropoulos -v- Mattana Coiffure Pty Limited (No 2) (RLD) [2004] NSWADTAP 43

CITATION: Mattana Coiffure Pty Limited v Sotiropoulos (No2) [2004] NSWADT 80
DIVISION: Retail Leases Division
PARTIES: APPLICANT
Mattana Coiffure Pty Limited
RESPONDENT
Vlasios Vasilios SOTIROPOULOS
FILE NUMBER: 035024
HEARING DATES: 6 April 2004
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 04/06/2004
DATE OF DECISION:
04/23/2004
BEFORE: Fox R - Judicial Member
APPLICATION: Claim for payment of money - Claim for rectification of the lease - Costs
MATTER FOR DECISION: Orders; costs
LEGISLATION CITED: Retail Leases Act 1994
CASES CITED:
REPRESENTATION: APPLICANT
M Drake, barrister
RESPONDENT
G Burton, barrister
ORDERS: Building works orders; 1.The Respondent use all reasonable endeavours to obtain approval for Development Application 8.2003.408.1, in its current form or as amended only so far as is necessary to satisfy the requirements of Mosman Council (“Development Application”), from Mosman Council at the earliest possible time.; 2.The Respondent, within 8 weeks of obtaining approval for the Development Application construct and rectify treatment room 2 (excluding joinery) in accordance with the plans and schedule of fittings provided by Michael Sandberg, SMS Architects and the four paint finishes specified in the applicant’s schedule of finishes attached to these orders and marked “A” (“building works”).; 3.The Respondent ensure that the premises are secure and locked and provided with adequate toilet facilities throughout the building works. ; 4.The Respondent, within nine weeks of obtaining approval for the Development Application provide the Applicant with certifications:; i) from a practising structural engineer with corporate membership of the Institute of Engineers Australia that the excavation works have either left the existing wall at the back of treatment room 2 in structurally sound condition, or that underpinning or similar works have been effected to render it structurally sound; and; ii) from an accredited certifier, qualified to make these assessments and accredited under section 109T of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, that the building works have been completed in accordance with order 2 above, the Building Code of Australia and any development consents entitling those works to be carried out. ; Compensation orders; 5.The Respondent pay the Applicant $37,900 in compensation for the period from 5 September 2002 to 23 September 2003. ; 6.The Respondent pay the Applicant compensation in the sum of $1,803 a day for: ; i) three days lost trading on 24-26 September 2003 by closure of the salon during the installation of the temporary facilities, being $5409; and; ii) each additional day of trading lost from 6 April 2004 until the completion of the building works by closure of the salon, payable at the end of each week in which a day or more of trading is lost by cheque delivered to the leased premises during the trading hours of the applicant’s business or as otherwise agreed between the parties.; 7.The Respondent pay the Applicant compensation in the sum of: $4,284 for the loss of the use of Treatment Room 2 from 24 September 2003…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mattana Coiffure Pty Limited v Sotiropoulos (No2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWADT 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mattana Coiffure Pty Limited brought an action against Sotiropoulos in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, seeking relief for breaches of a lease agreement. The dispute primarily centred on the failure of Sotiropoulos, the landlord, to obtain necessary approvals for building works and to maintain the premises in a habitable condition. The case was presided over by Justice Hulme, who was tasked with determining the legal obligations of both parties and whether Sotiropoulos had breached the lease by not securing approval for the development application and by not maintaining the premises. Additionally, the court had to address whether Mattana Coiffure was entitled to compensation for lost trading days and other losses due to the landlord's actions.

The primary legal issues before the court included whether Sotiropoulos had breached the lease by failing to obtain the necessary development approval and by not ensuring the premises were habitable. It was also necessary to determine if Mattana Coiffure was entitled to compensation for the period during which the salon was closed and for the loss of use of Treatment Room 2. The court had to consider the terms of the lease, the obligations of the landlord under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, and whether Sotiropoulos's actions constituted a breach of the lease terms.

Justice Hulme found that Sotiropoulos had indeed breached the lease by failing to obtain the required development approval and by not maintaining the premises. The court held that the landlord's actions had resulted in significant losses for Mattana Coiffure, including lost trading days and the loss of use of Treatment Room 2. The court ordered Sotiropoulos to use all reasonable endeavours to obtain the necessary development approval and to complete the building works within specified timeframes. Additionally, Sotiropoulos was required to compensate Mattana Coiffure for the losses incurred. The court awarded Mattana Coiffure compensation for lost trading days, the loss of use of Treatment Room 2, and other related expenses. The court also ordered Sotiropoulos to pay interest on part of the compensation and specified the costs to be borne by each party.

In conclusion, the court's orders mandated that Sotiropoulos secure the necessary development approval and complete the building works to make the premises habitable. Compensation was awarded to Mattana Coiffure for the losses suffered due to the landlord's breaches. The orders also included provisions for ongoing compensation for lost trading days and the loss of use of Treatment Room 2, as well as interest on part of the compensation. The court directed that certain costs be borne by Sotiropoulos, reflecting the breaches found in the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Building works orders; 1.The Respondent use all reasonable endeavours to obtain approval for Development Application 8.2003.408.1, in its current form or as amended only so far as is necessary to satisfy the requirements of Mosman Council (“Development Application”), from Mosman Council at the earliest possible time.; 2.The Respondent, within 8 weeks of obtaining approval for the Development Application construct and rectify treatment room 2 (excluding joinery) in accordance with the plans and schedule of fittings provided by Michael Sandberg, SMS Architects and the four paint finishes specified in the applicant’s schedule of finishes attached to these orders and marked “A” (“building works”).; 3.The Respondent ensure that the premises are secure and locked and provided with adequate toilet facilities throughout the building works. ; 4.The Respondent, within nine weeks of obtaining approval for the Development Application provide the Applicant with certifications:; i) from a practising structural engineer with corporate membership of the Institute of Engineers Australia that the excavation works have either left the existing wall at the back of treatment room 2 in structurally sound condition, or that underpinning or similar works have been effected to render it structurally sound; and; ii) from an accredited certifier, qualified to make these assessments and accredited under section 109T of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, that the building works have been completed in accordance with order 2 above, the Building Code of Australia and any development consents entitling those works to be carried out. ; Compensation orders; 5.The Respondent pay the Applicant $37,900 in compensation for the period from 5 September 2002 to 23 September 2003. ; 6.The Respondent pay the Applicant compensation in the sum of $1,803 a day for: ; i) three days lost trading on 24-26 September 2003 by closure of the salon during the installation of the temporary facilities, being $5409; and; ii) each additional day of trading lost from 6 April 2004 until the completion of the building works by closure of the salon, payable at the end of each week in which a day or more of trading is lost by cheque delivered to the leased premises during the trading hours of the applicant’s business or as otherwise agreed between the parties.; 7.The Respondent pay the Applicant compensation in the sum of: $4,284 for the loss of the use of Treatment Room 2 from 24 September 2003 until 6 April 2004 calculated at the rate of $153 per week; and; i) $153 per week or part thereof for further loss of Treatment Room 2 from 6 April 2004 until the completion of the building works, payable at the end of each week by cheque delivered to the lease premises during trading hours of the applicant’s business or as otherwise agreed between the parties.; 8.The Respondent pay the Applicant an agreed amount of $4,350 ($4,785 less GST) for the Applicant to replace the joinery (only) in Treatment Room 2.; 9.The Respondent pay the Applicant interest on the compensation payable under order 5 only at the rate of 6.57 per cent, being $2,292.; 10.The amounts referred to in orders 5-9 (excluding orders 6(b) and 7(b)) being the sum of $54,235, including interest, be paid within 28 days from the date of this order.; Costs order; 11.The Respondents pay one half of the Applicant’s costs of preparation for trial up to the commencement of but not including the actual conduct of the hearing of 22 July and is to pay all of the Applicant’s costs (including preparation) for the conduct of the matter on 23 and 24 July and all subsequent appearances in the matter including appearance of 6 April 2004, all on a party/party basis.; Liberty to apply; 12.Liberty to either party to apply on 7 days’ notice.; Declaration; 13.The Lease granted by the Respondent to the Applicant comprised an exclusive right to occupy the ground floor built area as identified by the highlighter outlined area shown in the plan attached to this order, but noting that the plan does not accurately reflect the new laundry and new WC because that is still to be built. The lease further included a shared right to park a vehicle in Carney Lane and a shared right of access to the rear lane Council car park identified in the plan as existing garage as limited by clause 3.4 and 11.3.2 of the lease.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.