Mathews v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

Citation:

Mathews v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2022] NSWPIC 226

Claimant: Bill Mathews
insurer: QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited
Member: Gary Victor Patterson
DATE OF DECISION: 11 May 2022
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Assessment of Claim for Damages under Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act); self-represented Claimant; liability wholly admitted; litigation of loss; non-economic loss; past loss of earnings; future loss of earning capacity; Held- the amount of damages assessed in respect of this claim is $959,484.75; the Claimant’s economic loss is reduced by, and the Insurer is to have credit for, the sum of $233,780.84 in accordance with s 4.10 of the MAI Act; the amount of the Claimant’s costs, taking into account the amount of damages assessed in respect of this claim, assessed in accordance with the Motor Accident Injuries Regulation 2017 is $57,151.60 inclusive of GST.

determinations made:

The findings of this assessment are as follows:

1.     The amount of damages assessed in respect of this claim is $959,484.75.

2.     The Claimant’s economic loss is reduced by, and the Insurer is to have credit for, the sum of $233,780.84 in accordance with s 4.10 of the Act.

3.     The amount of the Claimant’s costs, taking into account the amount of damages assessed in respect of this claim, assessed in accordance with the Motor Accident Injuries Regulation 2017 is $57,151.60 inclusive of GST.

Reasons for Decision – General Assessment
Common law damages claim - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (“the Act”)

Introduction

  1. Mr Mathews is self-represented.  He previously was represented by Gerard Malouf & Partners who prepared the claim for assessment.

  2. At the commencement of the assessment conference, I was informed that Mr Mathews would not participate, as he was attending a funeral.  No prior notice was given.  No request for a postponement was made.  Mr Deans said that the insurer wanted the commencement to proceed on the papers.  I agreed to adopt that course, subject to the parties’ having the opportunity to make further submissions, in response to my draft Certificate and Reasons. 

  3. Mr Mathews did not comply with my direction, made on 16 February last, for the provision of updated material.  I have considered the Insurer’s Further Submissions in Reply dated 27 April 2022 and the material uploaded with those further submissions.

  4. The subject motor accident occurred on 19 November 2018 about 8:00 pm.  Mr Mathews was riding a motorcycle on his way home from work.  He was passing through the intersection of Linden and Leonay Streets at Sutherland which was controlled by traffic lights.  Conditions were dry and fine.  As he moved off with the green light, he was T-boned on his right side by the insured Mitsubishi Triton utility, which failed to obey a red traffic light.  Mr Mathews was wearing a helmet and appropriate protective clothing. 

  5. As a result of the impact, Mr Mathews sustained fractures of both femurs, a compound fracture of his right tibia and fibula, some fractured ribs, an injury to his neck, injury…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mathews v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Mathews v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, the plaintiff, Mr. Mathews, sought damages for injuries sustained in a motor accident. The defendant, QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, admitted liability, and the dispute centred on the quantification of damages under the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act). This case was heard in the District Court of New South Wales, presided over by Dr. Clark. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate compensation for Mr. Mathews’ non-economic loss, past loss of earnings, and future loss of earning capacity.

The primary legal issues before the court included the assessment of non-economic loss, past loss of earnings, and future loss of earning capacity under the MAI Act. The court had to consider the evidence provided by various medical experts and Dr. Clark’s assessment of Mr. Mathews’ impairments and their impact on his quality of life. The court also had to evaluate the submissions from both parties regarding the appropriate amount of non-economic loss compensation. Additionally, the court needed to consider the defendant's argument on the mitigation of loss, raised late in the proceedings.

Dr. Clark found that the motor accident had caused significant physical and psychiatric injuries to Mr. Mathews, resulting in whole person impairment. The court accepted the evidence of Dr. Wan that the injuries had a significant impact on Mr. Mathews' work, social, and family life. After reviewing the medical evidence and submissions from both parties, Dr. Clark determined that an appropriate award for non-economic loss was $285,000.00. The court found that the motor accident had a significant impact on Mr. Mathews' quality of life and that the tortfeasor must take the victim as they are found, including consideration of Mr. Mathews’ previous left knee injury. The court also noted that the insurer's late submission regarding the mitigation of loss was not adequately addressed by Mr. Mathews’ former solicitors.

The court ordered that the total amount of damages assessed in respect of the claim is $959,484.75, with a reduction in economic loss of $233,780.84 under s 4.10 of the MAI Act. The claimant's costs, inclusive of GST, were assessed at $57,151.60 in accordance with the Motor Accident Injuries Regulation 2017.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Clark records that Mr Mathews has moderate impairment under the PIRS descriptors of self-care and personal hygiene, social and recreational activities, travel, concentration persistence and pace. He has mild impairment under the descriptor social functioning (relationships) and severe impairment under the descriptor employability. Dr Clark records that Mr Mathews is moody and irritable, suffering pain, anxiety and depression. Dr Clark expects that Mr Mathews would require treatment for up to 4 years. He found no evidence of a pre-existing psychiatric condition. Dr Bentivoglio notes that Mr Mathews has had multiple surgical procedures. He has had ultrasound-guided cortisone injection into his shoulder with no improvement. Dr Bentivoglio says that the prognosis for the neck and back remain guarded. The prognosis for the left shoulder is guarded to poor. Medical Assessor Gorman describes a large area of tender, hypopigmented scarring over the anterior right lower limb, below the knee, at the site of the debridement from the compound fracture of the right leg. The outline of the scarring is irregular up to 10 centimetres in diameter. It is slightly depressed. Dr Dryson opines that Mr Mathews may require a total right knee joint replacement if he develops significant osteoarthrosis. Mr Mathews has undergone removal of the right tibia screws and plate. He is yet to undergo removal of hardware from the right knee. Having reviewed all of the evidence, I am satisfied that the motor accident has caused significant physical and psychiatric injuries, with consequential whole person impairment, from which Mr Mathews will suffer for the remainder of his life. It was submitted by Mr Mathews then lawyers that $300,000.00 would be an appropriate award for non-economic loss. The insurer’s lawyers contend for $190,000.00 to $210,000.00. I am satisfied that the motor accident has had a significant impact on Mr Mathews quality of life in many ways and will continue to do so. I accept Dr Wan’s opinion that the injuries sustained in the motor accident have significantly affected Mr Mathews’ work, social and family life. I have had regard to his age and the negative effect that Mr Mathews’ impairments have had on his ability to enjoy his usual activities. I have had regard to the amounts allowed for non-economic loss in other cases involving similar degrees of whole person impairments. I have taken into account Mr Mathews previous left knee injury on the basis that the tortfeasor must take the victim as he is found. I have had regard to the amounts for which each party contends. Having considered the evidence and the parties’ submissions, I allow $285,000.00 for non-economic loss. In its Further Submissions in Reply, the insurer raised the issue of mitigation of loss. That was at a time when Mr Mathews was self-represented. His former solicitors did not address that issue in their submissions. The insurer relies upon the evidence of the Benchmark Rehabilitation Transferrable Skills Assessment Report (R20), Dr Dryson (R22) and Dr Keller (R25), in submitting that Mr Mathews has a restricted capacity to engage in part-time sedentary work which he has not utilised.