Mathews v Health Insurance Commission (No 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mathews v Health Insurance Commission (No 1)
[2005] FCA 1061


PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – discovery – whether discovery necessary – whether statutory immunity a bar to discovery

COURTS & JUDICIAL SYSTEM – immunities – Professional Services Review Committee – application for discovery of documents comprising committee’s file – Health Insurance Act1973 (Cth) s 106F(1)

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act1977 (Cth)
Health Insurance Act1973 (Cth)

Herijanto v Refugee Review Tribunal (No.2); Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal (No.2); Lie v Refugee Review Tribunal (No.2) (2000) 170 ALR 575, applied

MATHEWS v HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION & ORS

NSD 1584 of 2004

EDMONDS J
2 AUGUST 2005
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1584 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

JOHN WILLIAM MATHEWS
APPLICANT

AND:

HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION
FIRST RESPONDENT

ALAN JOHNS HOLMES (in his capacity as Director of Professional Services Review)
SECOND RESPONDENT

BERNARD KELLY, PETER CLYNE AND ANNE STUART (constituting Professional Services Review Committee No. 223)
THIRD RESPONDENT

THE DETERMINING AUTHORITY
(established by section 106Q of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth))
FOURTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 AUGUST 2005

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

  1. The applicant’s motion for an order for discovery be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1584 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

JOHN WILLIAM MATHEWS
APPLICANT

AND:

HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION
FIRST RESPONDENT

ALAN JOHNS HOLMES (in his capacity as Director of Professional Services Review)
SECOND RESPONDENT

BERNARD KELLY, PETER CLYNE AND ANNE STUART (constituting Professional Services Review Committee No. 223)
THIRD RESPONDENT

THE DETERMINING AUTHORITY
(established by section 106Q of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth))
FOURTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE:

2 AUGUST 2005

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT (DISCOVERY)

  1. This is an application under ss5 and 6 of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) [‘the ADJR Act’] and s39B(1A) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) to review:

    (1)the decision, conduct or action of the first respondent to make an investigative referral to the second respondent under s86(1) of the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) [‘the Act’] in respect of the conduct of the applicant;

    (2)the decision, conduct or action of the second respondent to set up a committee comprising the third respondents to make an adjudicative referral to them under s93 of the Act in respect of the conduct of the applicant;

    (3)the decision, conduct or action of the third respondents in preparing the delivering to the applicant for his submissions a draft report regarding the third respondents’ preliminary findings as to the conduct of the applicant; and

    (4)the decision, conduct or action of the third respondents in preparing and giving to the fourth respondent a final report regarding the conduct of the applicant.

  2. The application is founded in constitutional grounds as well as in grounds of jurisdictional error and other alleged errors of law…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mathews v Health Insurance Commission (No 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 1061
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mathews v Health Insurance Commission (No 1), the applicant sought an order of review against the Health Insurance Commission, the Director, and a Committee. The matter was before the court on an application for discovery of documents related to the case. The applicant sought discovery of files, documents, and other materials related to sampling, as well as the qualifications of a particular expert and communications between the expert and the respondents' solicitors. The respondents opposed the application, arguing that the applicant's request was overly broad and sought information from non-parties.

The court had to determine whether the applicant's application for discovery was justified and whether the requested documents should be disclosed. The court considered the scope of the discovery request and the relevance of the documents to the case. The court also had to consider whether the Commission and the Director, who were no longer parties to the action, were required to disclose their files. The court found that the applicant's application for discovery was overly broad and sought information from non-parties. The court also found that the reference in the affidavit of Ms. Selvidge was limited to the Committee's file, and no other file was mentioned.

The court dismissed the applicant's motion for an order for discovery. The court held that the application for discovery by the Commission and the Director in the terms sought should be rejected. The court found that the applicant's request was too broad and sought information from non-parties. The court also found that the reference in the affidavit of Ms. Selvidge was limited to the Committee's file, and no other file was mentioned. The court held that the Commission and the Director had effectively become non-parties in the judicial review action, providing a further reason to reject the application for discovery.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s motion for an order for discovery be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

At a hearing before me on 19 July 2005 I granted the applicant leave to file in Court a further amended application for an order of review dated 18 July 2005 and granted his motion for an adjournment of the substantive hearing until Monday 22 August 2005 to enable expert evidence to be put on from a qualified statistician in response to an affidavit from Professor Desmond Francis Nicholls sworn 15 July 2005, filed on behalf of the respondents on the same date. At that hearing, the applicant sought limited discovery relating to certain matters which were put in issue by the applicant’s further amended application and I reserved my decision on that application.BACKGROUND TO APPLICATION FOR DISCOVERY On 15 July 2005, there was also filed on behalf of the respondents an affidavit of Ms Anne Mary Selvidge sworn the same date. In that affidavit Ms Selvidge deposes that she is the Manager of the Committees Unit within the Office of the second respondent (the Director). She further deposes that she has reviewed the file of the third respondents (the Committee) and she goes on to make certain statements in consequence of her review of that file. Initially, counsel for the applicant put his application for discovery in terms of a notice to produce dated 15 July 2005 which was called on at the hearing on 19 July 2005 and in response to which three documents were produced. I granted the applicant access to those documents. The notice to produce called for the production of the following documents:(1)All files, documents, memoranda, computer software and other documents of whatsoever nature relating to sampling in this matter including but not limited to all requests for the preparation of a preliminary random sample of services and exploratory random sample and all samples produced in relation thereto;(2)All material qualifying Professor Nicholls and any communications between he and the solicitors for the respondents relating to these proceedings. Subsequently, the application for discovery was recast in terms of examining the same files to which Ms Selvidge had access for the purpose of swearing her affidavit. This was put, by counsel for the applicant, as being the file of the Committee, the file or files of the Director and the file or files of the first respondent (the Commission). But it is clear in my view that, contrary to the submissions of counsel for the applicant, Ms Selvidge does not say she reviewed the file of anyone other than the Committee. The reference in paragraph 7 of her affidavit: ‘From my examination of the file …’ is a reference back to the Committee’s file in paragraph 4. No other file is mentioned. For this reason alone, the applicant’s application that the Commission and the Director discover their respective files is rejected. Apart from anything else, as was submitted by counsel for the respondents, the Commission and the Director have, as a result of the abandonment of grounds 1 and 2 in the applicant’s further amended application, effectively become non-parties in the judicial review action. This provides a further reason why the application for discovery by the Commission and the Director in the terms sought should be rejected.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

EDMONDS J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EDMONDS J