MATHEW and RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: BUILDING SERVICES (COMPLAINT RESOLUTION AND ADMINISTRATION) ACT 2011 (WA)

CITATION:   MATHEW and RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD [2024] WASAT 98

MEMBER:   DR B DE VILLIERS, MEMBER

MR R AFFLECK, SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER

HEARD:   26 AUGUST 2024

DELIVERED          :   11 SEPTEMBER 2024

FILE NO/S:   CC 863 of 2022

BETWEEN:   JAMES MATHEW

First Applicant

TINTA JACOB KUNNAPPALLIL

Second Applicant

AND

RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD

Respondent


Catchwords:

Building service complaint - Set coat failing - Appropriate remedy - Suitability of experimental remedy - Election of remedy by owner

Legislation:

Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA), s 36, s 36(1)(a), s 36(1)(b)

Result:

Costs to remedy awarded to the applicants

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Applicant : In Person
Second Applicant : In Person
Respondent : JA Robertson

Solicitors:

First Applicant : N/A
Second Applicant : N/A
Respondent : Williams & Hughes

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Bellgrove v Eldridge [1954] HCA 36; (1954) 90 CLR 613

Gemmill Homes Pty Ltd v Sanders [2018] WASC 179

J-Corp Pty Ltd v Gilmour [2005] WASCA 136

Kos and DND Building Co Pty Ltd [2020] WASAT 95

The Owners of One Brighton Strata Plan 51948 and Pindan Pty Ltd [No 2] [2020] WASAT 3

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Background

  1. This is a dispute about the cost of remedial work arising from building work not carried out in a proper or proficient manner or being faulty or unsatisfactory. The building defect is, in essence, that the paint of all the walls in the dwelling, except tiled surfaces, fails to adequately adhere to the substrate due to defects with the set coat. The owners seek a monetary order for the cost of remedying the deficiency under s 36(1)(b) of the Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA) (BSCRAAct).  The builder has consented to the making of a monetary order rather than for a building service remedy order to be made.  The builder accepts liability for workmanship, but the parties disagree about the quantum to be awarded.  The owners originally sought $304,894.69 (Exhibit A: 437) but they have now adjusted their claim to $130,106.60 (Exhibit A: 427).  The parties and their experts agree that the paint and the float coat of all the walls of the dwelling are fit for purposes, but that the set coat on all the walls is deficient.  As a result of this deficiency, the outer surfaces of the walls are soft and chalky.  This deficiency is commonly experienced in the home building industry.  The scientific experts recommended two potential remedial options, the one being widely practised in the building industry and the other at an experimental stage.  It was thought at the time of the expert conferral that the cost differentiation between the two options would be substantial.  However, during examination in the hearing it appeared that the scope of remedial work and the costs of those works for the respective options would not necessarily be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MATHEW and RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] WASAT 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Mathew and Riviera Homes (WA) Pty Ltd arose due to a failure in the set coat of a building, leading to a claim for appropriate remedy. The case was heard in the relevant Australian tribunal. The primary issues revolved around the appropriate standard to which the set coat should comply, the applicability of HB-161-2005 as a legal standard, the testing of various materials, and the determination of a suitable remedy. Additionally, the tribunal had to address the builder's initial jurisdictional challenge, which was subsequently withdrawn.

The tribunal addressed the jurisdictional challenge first, confirming its authority to hear the matter. It then delved into the substantive issues, particularly the standard applicable to the set coat. The owner argued that HB-161-2005 should be regarded as a legal standard, while the experts and the builder contended that it was merely a guide. The tribunal carefully examined the various expert reports and evidence, ultimately adopting the joint expert conferral reports as the primary evidence. The tribunal also considered the methodology of testing and the suitability of the proposed remedies, focusing on whether an experimental remedy was appropriate and whether the owner had effectively elected a particular remedy.

In its decision, the tribunal resolved that HB-161-2005 was not a legal standard but rather a guide, and thus, the set coat did not need to comply with it. The tribunal further deliberated on the testing methodologies and the proposed remedies, ultimately determining the most suitable course of action. The tribunal also made provisions for applications for costs related to the jurisdictional challenge and the overall proceedings.

The tribunal concluded by confirming its jurisdiction and setting out the appropriate standard for the set coat. It ordered the remedial works to be conducted in accordance with the findings and directed the parties to address any further cost applications related to the jurisdictional challenge and the final hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Consideration and decision Several issues were raised during the course of the proceeding and we shall deal with those under distinct headings: The hearing was originally set down for 29 January 2024. At the commencement of the hearing on 29 January 2024 the builder questioned the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to determine the matter on the basis that the complaint may have been brought out of time. The hearing was adjourned for the owner to seek advice and for material to be filed by the parties (Exhibit A 674). The jurisdictional question was set down for a hearing on 17 April 2024. On 15 April 2024 the builder informed the Tribunal and the owners that on reflection the builder accepted that jurisdiction was properly vested in the Tribunal (Exhibit A 748). The preliminary issue thus fell away. We are satisfied that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to determine the dispute. The owner indicated at the time that it would seek an order for costs that had been wasted as a result of the adjournment. As part of orders made in this decision, an opportunity is given for parties to make applications for costs regarding the jurisdictional proceeding and the final hearing. Due to the time it had taken to bring this complaint to a hearing, several reports had been prepared by the respective experts about the possible cause of the failure of the set coat and the appropriate remedy. For example, at various stages issues were raised about the appropriate standard that applies to set coat; the applicability of HB-161-2005 as a guide or a standard, the testing of paint, the testing of float coat and set coat, the proper methodology for testing; and suitable remedies. At the commencement of the hearing the experts giving evidence were offered the opportunity to revisit each of their reports to indicate which aspect, if any, no longer forms their opinion, or in the alternative we raised the possibility that they adopt their joint expert conferral reports as their evidence‑in‑chief and that any opinion expressed in an earlier report that is inconsistent with their joint expert conferral reports, be regarded as withdrawn and thus no weight be attached to it. The experts preferred the latter whereby they adopted the joint expert conferral reports and their oral evidence during the hearing as their evidence‑in‑chief. If any inconsistency arises between the hearing-evidence (written and oral) and an earlier report by the same expert, the hearing-evidence is to be regarded as the evidence of the particular witness. A threshold question that arose was what standard should be applied to set coat and to what standard should the remedial work comply? Building and Energy in their Revised Proposed Building Remedy Order (Exhibit A: 98 ‑ 111) dated 14 June 2022 defined the 'action required' as having to be in compliance with HB-161-2005 Guide to Plastering. This purported standard became the subject of extensive examination, questioning, and confusion since the owner viewed HB-161-2005 as a legal standard for a set coat, whilst the experts held a different view, as explained below.