Matheson and Matheson

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MATHESON & MATHESON [2010] FamCA 772
FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Where property orders were entered into and set aside by consent – Where the substantive asset of the parties is a motor vessel – Where a partial property settlement was made by consent – Where there is dispute about the interpretation of an Order – Where the Wife submits that her entitlement should be prioritised over her former solicitors – Issue of outstanding cheques – Where the solicitors contend that the Court no longer has jurisdiction to deal with monies in the trust account – Whether the Court is functus officio – Application of the slip rule
APPLICANT: Ms Matheson
RESPONDENT: Mr Matheson
FILE NUMBER: BRF 1279 of 2005
DATE DELIVERED: 6 September 2010
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: Barry J
HEARING DATE: 30 July 2009

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: The Applicant Wife appearing in person
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: The Respondent Husband appearing in person
Mr Z, Solicitor appearing on behalf of the Trustee for Z Lawyer’s Trust Account

Orders

  1. Of the Court’s own motion order 7 of the order of the 23 July 2008 is amended to read:

    “a.All outstanding applications filed by [D Matheson] are dismissed and these proceedings removed from the active pending cases list.

    b.The applications filed by the Applicant and First Respondent on the 21 January 2008 are dismissed.

    c.The issue of property settlement is adjourned to a date to be fixed.”

(2)

(a)Z Lawyers are to pay to the Collector of Public Monies at the Brisbane Registry of the Family Court from monies held in their trust account in the name of the wife the sum of $4,739;

(b)Z Lawyers are to continue to hold the balance of funds in their trust account in the name of the wife pending the determination of final orders for property settlement by this Court.

  1. The Collector of Public Monies at the Brisbane Registry is to pay the SPER fines in the name of the Wife for all amounts outstanding as at 12 April 2007.  The Collector of Public Monies is to satisfy himself that the monies owing to SPER by the Wife as set out in Exhibit 1 were all incurred in the period prior to the 12 April 2007 less any monies paid by the Wife to SPER between the


    12 April 2007 and the present time.

  2. The Collector of Public Monies is to reimburse the Wife any monies she has paid to SPER since the making of the orders of the 12 April 2007 referrable to fines accumulated prior to the 12 April 2007.

  3. I direct the Registrar to formally notify the Wife, the Husband, Forbes Dowling as solicitors for Mr Y and Ms Y as Trustees for the Y Family Trust (the Sixth Respondents) and the Trustee in Bankruptcy for the husband of a date for a directions hearing for the outstanding property settlement issues.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Matheson and Matheson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FamCA 772
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Matheson and Matheson, Barry J of the Family Court of Australia considered applications filed by the applicant and first respondent, and outstanding applications by the second respondent, D Matheson. The proceedings concerned a dispute regarding property settlement.

The court was required to determine the disposition of outstanding applications, the allocation of funds held in trust by Z Lawyers, and the payment of outstanding SPER fines incurred by the wife. The court also needed to schedule further proceedings for the determination of property settlement issues.

Barry J ordered the dismissal of all outstanding applications filed by D Matheson and the applications filed by the applicant and first respondent on 21 January 2008, removing these proceedings from the active pending cases list. The issue of property settlement was adjourned to a date to be fixed. Z Lawyers were directed to pay a specified sum from monies held in trust for the wife to the Collector of Public Monies and to retain the balance pending final property settlement orders. The Collector of Public Monies was instructed to pay the wife's outstanding SPER fines incurred prior to 12 April 2007 and to reimburse the wife for any payments made to SPER since that date for fines accumulated before 12 April 2007. Finally, the Registrar was directed to notify relevant parties of a date for a directions hearing concerning the outstanding property settlement issues.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

Of the Court’s own motion order 7 of the order of the 23 July 2008 is amended to read:

“a. All outstanding applications filed by [D Matheson] are dismissed and these proceedings removed from the active pending cases list.

b. The applications filed by the Applicant and First Respondent on the 21 January 2008 are dismissed.

c. The issue of property settlement is adjourned to a date to be fixed.”

(2)

(a) Z Lawyers are to pay to the Collector of Public Monies at the Brisbane Registry of the Family Court from monies held in their trust account in the name of the wife the sum of $4,739;

(b) Z Lawyers are to continue to hold the balance of funds in their trust account in the name of the wife pending the determination of final orders for property settlement by this Court.

3.

The Collector of Public Monies at the Brisbane Registry is to pay the SPER fines in the name of the Wife for all amounts outstanding as at 12 April 2007. The Collector of Public Monies is to satisfy himself that the monies owing to SPER by the Wife as set out in Exhibit 1 were all incurred in the period prior to the 12 April 2007 less any monies paid by the Wife to SPER between the

12 April 2007 and the present time.

4.

The Collector of Public Monies is to reimburse the Wife any monies she has paid to SPER since the making of the orders of the 12 April 2007 referrable to fines accumulated prior to the 12 April 2007.

5.

I direct the Registrar to formally notify the Wife, the Husband, Forbes Dowling as solicitors for Mr Y and Ms Y as Trustees for the Y Family Trust (the Sixth Respondents) and the Trustee in Bankruptcy for the husband of a date for a directions hearing for the outstanding property settlement issues.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established