Mater Misericordiae Ltd Trading as Mater v Robyn Tyler

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
[2025] FWC 1396

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.120—Redundancy pay

Mater Misericordiae Ltd Trading AS Mater
v

Robyn Tyler

(C2025/1795)

COMMISSIONER SIMPSON

BRISBANE, 21 MAY 2025

Variation of redundancy pay – Acceptable employment offered – Offer rejected – Redundancy pay reduced to zero.

  1. This decision concerns an application by Mater Misericordiae Limited T/A Mater (Mater) under s.120 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) to vary the redundancy pay owing to an employee, Ms Robyn Tyler (Ms Tyler).

  1. Ms Tyler has been employed by Mater for approximately 6 years, entitling her to 11 weeks or $18,699.6814 in redundancy payment.

  1. Mater submitted that Ms Tyler had been offered a suitable alternative position, which had been rejected by Ms Tyler and therefore the redundancy payment should be reduced to nothing.

Relevant Legislation

  1. Section 120 of the Act states:

“120  Variation of redundancy pay for other employment or incapacity to pay

(1) This section applies if:

(a) an employee is entitled to be paid an amount of redundancy pay by the employer because of section 119; and
(b) the employer:

(i) obtains other acceptable employment for the employee; or
(ii) cannot pay the amount.

(2) On application by the employer, the FWC may determine that the amount of redundancy pay is reduced to a specified amount (which may be nil) that the FWC considers appropriate.

(3) The amount of redundancy pay to which the employee is entitled under section 119 is the reduced amount specified in the determination.”

Background

  1. On 21 January 2019 Ms Tyler’s employment commenced with Mater as an RTO Educator on a 12-month fixed-term contract. On 3 December 2019 Mater extended Ms Tyler’s fixed-term contract in the same role for a further 12 months until 26 December 2021. On 17 June 2021, Ms Tyler was appointed as a permanent part-time Educator – Curriculum design.

  1. On 30 January 2025, Mater commenced consultation with Ms Tyler regarding structural changes within their Education and Training division. As part of their structural changes, Ms Tyler’s role as Educator – Curriculum design was identified as no longer required.

  1. Ms Tyler was issued a letter outlining the impact of the proposed changes on her employment and inviting her to provide feedback.

  1. On 9 February 2025, Ms Tyler provided feedback by email:

“Hi Toni-Maree,
(and ladies copied in)
Below is my feedback regarding our change to work role. I have tried to keep this to dot
points so if you need any more information or would like to have a chat about any of these please let me know.

Proposed Structure:

·   Integrating the curriculum staff into the everyday workspaces of the educators has worked really well in the certificate space. It allow for ‘watercooler’ conversations regarding curriculum and processes around it.

·   I have concerns however regarding curriculum staff reporting to other areas of the business who may not understand the finer details of the curriculum role, workload and timeframes.

·   Currently exists great confusion around…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mater Misericordiae Ltd Trading as Mater v Robyn Tyler and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FWC 1396
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, Robyn Tyler, an employee of Mater Misericordiae Limited (Mater), has applied for a variation of her redundancy pay following the restructuring of the Education and Training division. Mater sought a reduction in the redundancy pay to zero based on the offer of an alternative position that Ms Tyler declined. The central legal issue before the Court was whether the alternative employment offered to Ms Tyler by Mater was "other acceptable employment" under section 120(1)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009. If it was, then the redundancy payment could be varied, potentially reducing it to zero.

Mater argued that the alternative role was objectively acceptable employment, considering factors such as rate of pay, hours of work, work location, seniority, fringe benefits, workload, job security, continuity of service, and other relevant criteria. The Court examined these factors and found that the alternative role offered to Ms Tyler was indeed acceptable employment. The role retained the same rate of pay, hours of work, and seniority, and provided job security and continuity. The only difference was the requirement to work onsite during standard business hours, which the Court deemed a reasonable expectation in employment. Additionally, while Ms Tyler preferred more flexibility in working from home, this was not a contractual right but rather a discretionary benefit at Mater's discretion.

Given that the alternative role was found to be acceptable employment, the Court concluded it was appropriate to reduce Ms Tyler's redundancy entitlement to zero. The Court found that Ms Tyler's objections were based on personal preferences rather than genuine employment-related disadvantages. Therefore, her refusal of the alternative role justified the reduction in redundancy pay.

In conclusion, the Court found in favor of Mater, reducing Ms Tyler's redundancy pay to zero. This decision aligns with the objective assessment of acceptable employment under the Fair Work Act, ensuring that employees do not unfairly reject reasonable alternative positions while retaining their prima facie entitlement to redundancy pay.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established