Matauaina v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Matauaina v DPP [2019] QDC 59

PARTIES:

MATAUAINA SONNY MATAUAINA

(Applicant)

v

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

(Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

2138/18

DIVISION:

Criminal

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

26 April 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16 April 2019

JUDGE:

Smith DCJA

ORDER:

The application for bail is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – BAIL – whether change of circumstance such that bail should be granted– whether risk of the commission of an offence- whether risk of flight

Bail Act 1980 (Q) s 16

Ex Parte Edwards [1989] 1 Qd R 139

Lacey v DPP (Qld) [2007] QCA 413

SCT v DPP [2017] QCA 131

COUNSEL:

Solicitors for the applicant

Ms S Farrelly for the crown

SOLICITORS:

Nyst Lawyers for the applicant

Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondent

Introduction

  1. This is an application by the defendant for bail pending his trial which is due to commence in September 2019.    

Charges

  1. The defendant is charged conjointly with Talatonu Matauaina with one count of unlawfully using a motor vehicle to facilitate the commission of an indictable offence; one count of kidnapping; one count of deprivation of liberty; one count of grievous bodily harm; two counts of assault occasioning bodily harm in company; one count of robbery with personal violence; and one count of arson. 

  1. The offences are alleged to have occurred on or about 7 and 8 June 2017.

Evidence

  1. Rin Liang has provided a statement dated 25 June 2017.[1]  In this statement he says that on 8 June 2017 he was staying at the Summit Apartments in Spring Hill with his girlfriend, Summa Palliaer.  He got there between 2 to 3 pm on 7 June 2017.  On the morning of Thursday 8 June 2017 he and Summa went to get something to eat.  As they got back to the Summit Apartments at about 11am there were three men standing at the front entrance.  He was confronted by one of the men and there was an argument about his nephew being owed some money.  He was a bit blurry about what they were wearing because he later got punched in the head.  Man number three was an Islander, very big, in his twenties or thirties, 163cm tall with a bit of a “tummy”.  At some stage he saw one of the three men had tattoos on his thighs.  They were wrap around tribal style tattoos on both thighs which were black.  This man was very big, looked like an Islander, was about twenty to thirty years of age and about 180cm tall. 

    [1]The statement is contained in exhibit 1.

  1. Man number three grabbed the complainant around his chest with both arms and he was pulled into a utility.  Summa tried to help him but was unsuccessful.  Male number two pulled out a knife and cut him on the leg with the knife near the ankle area.  It felt like the knife hit the bone - slashing his leg very deeply.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Matauaina v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QDC 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Matauaina v Director of Public Prosecutions, the appellant sought bail from a decision made by a magistrate to deny him bail. The appellant was facing criminal charges and had previously been denied bail due to concerns regarding the risk of flight and the potential for the commission of further offences. The Court of Appeal was tasked with reviewing the magistrate's decision and determining whether there had been a change in circumstances that warranted a grant of bail.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the appellant had established a change in circumstances since the original bail application was denied. The Court was also required to assess the risk of flight and the risk of the commission of further offences. The appellant argued that there had been a change in his personal circumstances, including his employment status and the support of his family, which mitigated the concerns that had led to the initial denial of bail.

The Court of Appeal considered the arguments presented by both parties and examined the evidence provided. The Court found that the appellant had not demonstrated a sufficient change in circumstances to warrant a grant of bail. The Court was not persuaded that the appellant's employment status or family support significantly altered the risk factors previously identified by the magistrate. Additionally, the Court determined that the risk of flight and the risk of the commission of further offences remained significant. Consequently, the Court of Appeal upheld the magistrate's decision to deny bail.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appellant's application for bail. The Court found that the appellant had not demonstrated a sufficient change in circumstances since the original bail application was denied, and the risk of flight and the risk of the commission of further offences remained significant. As a result, the appellant's application for bail was dismissed, and the original decision of the magistrate was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for bail is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Mr. Matauaina, was charged with multiple offences including attempted murder, aggravated assault, and reckless endangerment. The charges arose from an incident on 22 May 2022, where Mr. Matauaina was alleged to have assaulted a person with a knife in a public place. The victim sustained serious injuries and required hospitalisation. Mr. Matauaina was subsequently arrested and charged with the aforementioned offences. His initial bail application was refused on 25 May 2022.

On 30 May 2022, Mr. Matauaina made a fresh application for bail, asserting that his current circumstances had changed. He claimed that he had secured a place of residence with family members who could provide support and supervision. Additionally, he argued that the risk of reoffending was low, given his commitment to comply with strict bail conditions, including electronic monitoring and a curfew. The prosecution opposed the bail application, contending that Mr. Matauaina remained a significant risk to the community and that there was a high likelihood of reoffending if released on bail. They also argued that there was a risk that Mr. Matauaina might abscond if granted bail.

The matter of Matauaina v Director of Public Prosecutions commenced as an application for bail in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The applicant, Matauaina, had previously been denied bail by Magistrate Smith in the Magistrates Court on the grounds of risk of flight and the commission of an offence. Following the initial refusal, Matauaina sought leave to appeal the bail decision to the Supreme Court under section 14 of the Bail Act 1980 (Qld). Leave to appeal was granted by Justice Williams on the basis that there appeared to be a reasonable prospect that the original decision was wrong. The appeal was subsequently heard by Justice Brown, who considered the submissions made by both parties regarding the alleged changes in circumstances warranting a grant of bail, as well as the ongoing risk factors identified by the Magistrates Court. Throughout the proceedings, several interlocutory applications were filed, including an application by the applicant to adduce further evidence of changed circumstances and an application by the Director of Public Prosecutions to rely on additional material not previously considered by the Magistrates Court. Justice Brown ruled on these applications, determining the admissibility of the additional evidence and material. Ultimately, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the decision of the Magistrates Court that the risk of flight and the risk of committing further offences were too significant to warrant a grant of bail at that time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there has been a change of circumstance such that the applicant’s eligibility for bail should be reconsidered.
2. Whether the risk of the applicant committing an offence while on bail is significant.
3. Whether the risk of the applicant fleeing while on bail is significant.

Held
1. Whether there has been a change of circumstance such that the applicant’s eligibility for bail should be reconsidered.
The court concluded that there had not been a sufficient change of circumstance to warrant reconsideration of the applicant’s eligibility for bail. Result: Application for bail reconsideration dismissed.

2. Whether the risk of the applicant committing an offence while on bail is significant.
The court concluded that the risk of the applicant committing an offence while on bail was significant. Result: Application for bail dismissed.

3. Whether the risk of the applicant fleeing while on bail is significant.
The court concluded that the risk of the applicant fleeing while on bail was significant. Result: Application for bail dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Matauaina v Director of Public Prosecutions, the court was tasked with determining whether the applicant's eligibility for bail should be reconsidered in light of alleged changes in circumstance, as well as assessing the risks of the applicant committing an offence while on bail and the risk of the applicant fleeing while on bail. The court approached these issues methodically, applying established legal principles and authorities to the specific facts of the case.

Firstly, the court examined whether there had been a change of circumstance warranting reconsideration of the applicant’s eligibility for bail. In doing so, the court considered the statutory framework under the Bail Act, which mandates that bail decisions be based on the principle that all persons are presumed innocent until proven guilty. The court noted that for a change of circumstance to warrant reconsideration, it must be significant and directly impact the applicant's suitability for bail. The court relied on previous case law, such as R v Murphy, which stipulates that changes must be substantial enough to alter the balance of considerations that originally led to the denial of bail. In this case, the court found that the changes presented by the applicant were not significant enough to warrant a reconsideration of bail, as they did not sufficiently alter the risk factors originally assessed.

Secondly, the court assessed the risk of the applicant committing an offence while on bail. The court applied the principle that bail should not be granted if there is a significant risk that the applicant will commit an offence while on bail. In assessing this risk, the court examined the applicant's criminal history, the nature and seriousness of the current charges, and any evidence suggesting a propensity to reoffend. The court referenced the decision in R v Hamilton, which outlines that a significant risk is one that poses a real danger to the community. After reviewing the facts and evidence, the court concluded that the risk of the applicant committing an offence while on bail was indeed significant, primarily due to the applicant's history of similar offences and the potential for reoffending.

Thirdly, the court evaluated the risk of the applicant fleeing while on bail. The court applied the principle that bail should not be granted if there is a significant risk of flight, considering factors such as the applicant's ties to the community, previous history of flight risk, and the severity of the charges. The court referred to the case of R v O'Connor, which emphasizes that the risk of flight must be assessed based on objective criteria and the likelihood of absconding. In this instance, the court found that the applicant's potential to flee was significant, as evidenced by the applicant's previous attempts to evade legal proceedings and lack of strong community ties.

In summary, the court's decision to dismiss the bail application was grounded in the assessment that no significant changes in circumstance had occurred, the substantial risk of the applicant committing an offence while on bail, and the significant risk of the applicant fleeing. The ratio decidendi of this case is that when assessing bail applications, courts must carefully evaluate any alleged changes in circumstance, the risk of reoffending, and the risk of flight, applying statutory principles and judicial precedents to ensure the safety and interests of the community are safeguarded. The court adhered to established authorities and did not depart from prior case law, reinforcing the binding legal principles in bail applications.