Mastwyk v Crisp

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mastwyk v Crisp [2011] FCA 349

Citation: Mastwyk v Crisp [2011] FCA 349
Parties: STEPHEN JOHN MASTWYK v GLENN ANTHONY CRISP, MECHANICAL ENGINEERING CORPORATION PTY LTD (ACN 111 479 684), MECHANICAL ENGINEERING SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 109 193 348) and ANTHONY GORDON ELIOTT
File number: VID 749 of 2008
Judge: NORTH J
Date of judgment: 1 April 2011
Date of hearing: 1 April 2011
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 35
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Moore
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr T Donaghey
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Mills Oakley
Counsel for the Second, Third and Fourth Respondents: Ms S Bingham
Solicitor for the Second, Third and Fourth Respondents: Maddison & Associates

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 749 of 2008

BETWEEN:

STEPHEN JOHN MASTWYK
Applicant

AND:

GLENN ANTHONY CRISP
First Respondent

MECHANICAL ENGINEERING CORPORATION PTY LTD (ACN 111 479 684)
Second Respondent

MECHANICAL ENGINEERING SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 109 193 348)
Third Respondent

ANTHONY GORDON ELIOTT
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

NORTH J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 APRIL 2011

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.On or about 15 January 2007, the First Respondent contravened s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) in respect of each person listed in the Schedule to these declarations and orders by his conduct relating to an offer of employment with the Second Respondent made by him on behalf of the Second Respondent to each of those persons on terms and conditions prescribed by an Australian Workplace Agreement.

2.On or about 15 January 2007, the Second Respondent contravened s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) in respect of each person listed in the Schedule to these declarations and orders by the First Respondent’s conduct on behalf of the Second Respondent referred to in paragraph 1.

3.On or about 15 January 2007, the Third Respondent contravened s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) in respect of each person listed in the Schedule to these declarations and orders by being a person involved in the First Respondent’s contraventions of s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) referred to in paragraph 1.

4.On or about 15 January 2007, the Fourth Respondent contravened s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) in respect of each person listed in the Schedule to these declarations and orders by being a person involved in the First Respondnet’s contraventions of s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) referred to in paragraph 1.

5.On or about 23 January 2007, the Third Respondent contravened s 792(1)(a) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) in respect of each person listed in the Schedule to these declarations and orders by dismissing each of those persons for reasons including the reason proscribed by s 793(1)(m) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth).

6.On or about 23 January 2007, the Fourth Respondent contravened…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mastwyk v Crisp and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 349
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mastwyk v Crisp involves several respondents, including Glenn Anthony Crisp, Mechanical Engineering Corporation Pty Ltd (MEC), Mechanical Engineering Services Pty Ltd (MES), and Anthony Gordon Eliott, who was the sole director and shareholder of the Eliott Group of Companies. The dispute revolves around the dismissal of 37 employees by MES, which led to legal proceedings under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth). The primary legal issues the court needed to decide were the penalties for the contraventions of sections 400(5) and 792(1)(a) of the Act by the respondents, and the appropriate quantum of those penalties considering the mitigating factors presented. The court had to evaluate whether the dismissals constituted a single course of conduct and whether there were mitigating factors that should be considered in imposing the penalties.

The court considered the mitigating factors presented, such as the failure to reach a new collective agreement, the protracted industrial dispute, the cancellation of the labour hire agreement, and the fact that MES did not intend to contravene the Act but had sought advice prior to the dismissals. The court found that the dismissals were part of a single strategy targeting the employees as a group rather than individually. Given the seriousness of the contraventions, the court imposed penalties on each respondent, taking into account the mitigating factors and the penalties imposed on the other respondents for the same conduct. The court concluded that the proposed penalties reflected the seriousness of the contraventions, the mitigating factors, and the penalties imposed on other respondents for the same conduct.

The court ordered specific penalties for each respondent, totaling $3,300 for the first respondent, $20,000 for the second respondent, $30,000 for the third respondent, and $5,000 for the fourth respondent. These penalties were to be paid to the Consolidated Revenue Fund by 1 May 2011. The application was otherwise dismissed. The names of the 37 employees affected by the dismissals were listed in the schedule attached to the court’s decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

7. A penalty in the total sum of $3,300.00 be imposed on the First Respondent in respect of the contraventions of s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) referred to in paragraph 1.

8. A penalty in the total sum of $20,000.00 be imposed on the Second Respondent in respect of the contraventions of s 400(5) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) referred to in paragraph 2.

9. A penalty in the total sum of $30,000.00 be imposed on the Third Respondent in respect of the contraventions of s 400(5) and s 792(1)(a) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) referred to in paragraph 3 and 5.

10. A penalty in the total sum of $5,000.00 be imposed on the Fourth Respondent in respect of the contraventions of s 400(5) and s 792(1)(a) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) referred to in paragraph 4 and 6.

11. Each of the penalties referred to above be paid to the Consolidated Revenue Fund on or before 1 May 2011.

12. The application otherwise be dismissed.

SCHEDULE

1. David Alderson;

2. Hardy Alko;

3. Steve Attrill;

4. Wayne Bastin;

5. Alan Bennett;

6. Cory Berkhout;

7. Patrick Brown;

8. Steven Buhagiar;

9. John Cropley;

10. Alan Dingwall;

11. John Geremia;

12. Terry Grech

13. Sydney Grima;

14. Peter Grummisch;

15. Peter Harber;

16. Ray Jordan;

17. Hubert Kerkvliet;

18. Brett Kistemaker;

19. John Kuklinsky;

20. Rodney Marks;

21. Ralph Marshall;

22. Keith McKendry;

23. Joseph Micallef;

24. David Mitchell;

25. Geoffrey Morland;

26. Greg Nicklen;

27. Geoffrey Rea;

28. Chris Robertson;

29. John Scholtes;

30. Ron Schostek;

31. Kevin Sim;

32. Ian Strong;

33. Andrew Tucker;

34. Joseph Vella;

35. David Ward;

36. David Warner;

37. George Wawrzkow.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The first respondent filed short submissions which, in essence, together with oral submissions made by Mr Donaghey, who appeared as counsel for the first respondent, supported the applicant’s written submissions. The second, third and fourth respondents also supported the applicant’s submissions in oral submissions made to the Court. FACTUAL BACKGROUND The following recitation of the facts comes from the summary in the written submissions of the applicant, which has been taken from voluminous statements of agreed facts filed by the parties. The second respondent, Mechanical Engineering Corporation Pty Ltd (MEC), conducted the business of mechanical engineering in Yallourn. The third respondent, Mechanical Engineering Services Pty Ltd (MES) provided labour to MEC. MEC and MES were part of a group of companies, the Eliott Group of Companies. The fourth respondent, Anthony Gordon Eliott (Eliott), was the sole director and shareholder, and governing will of the Eliott Group of Companies. On 27 December 2006, MEC was placed into voluntary administration by Eliott. The voluntary administration ended on 6 June 2007. Whilst MEC was in administration the first respondent, Glenn Anthony Crisp (Crisp), was appointed administrator. The conditions of employment of the employees of MES were governed by a certified agreement which came to an end. It is unnecessary to describe the circumstances in which that occurred. However, the negotiations for a new agreement were protracted and particularly hostile. The employees took industrial action, which started with limited bans, and then escalated into a strike. In response, MES locked out these employees. From 3 November 2006 the employees were locked out again, and the strike continued indefinitely. As a result of the pressure placed on the business by these events, on 27 December 2006, Eliott, constituting the board of MEC, resolved that the company was insolvent and that it be placed into voluntary administration. Eliott advised Crisp that MES could not continue to supply labour to MEC, and MEC should try to provide alternative employment to the MES employees. On 15 January 2007 Crisp wrote to each of the 37 employees of MES referred to in the schedule to the orders made by the Court (the employees) offering them employment under an Australian Workplace Agreement (the AWA offer). The key terms of the offer were as follows:(a) a term of four years;(b)a 4% annual wage increase over the term of the workplace agreement after the first 12 months;(c)one RDO per 28 day / four week period (13 per year); and(d)salary sacrifice option available for employees who wished to take income protection insurance. In the covering letter sent to the employees with the offer, Crisp stated that:(a)MEC operated as part of the Eliott Group and that MES was the labour supply company to MEC. MES employed the MES Trades Employees at the Site;(b)the continuing industrial dispute had impaired the ability of MEC to service its customers and led to MEC being placed into voluntary administration;(c)unless MEC could procure a reliable supply of labour in the immediate future, he would have no option but to close its business operations;(d)MES had been unable to supply labour to MEC and the labour supply agreement with MES had been partially terminated;(e)MES had provided Crisp with details of all the MES employees to enable the MES employees affected by the partial termination of the labour supply agreement between MES and MEC to obtain alternative employment;(f)the employment offer was conditional upon him receiving acceptances from a satisfactory number of MES employees in each category of skilled employees to make the business viable;(g)employees should advise him within 7 days whether he or she accepted employment on the terms of the enclosed AWA. Later in the letter, he stated that acceptances were required by 5pm on 19 January 2007; and(h)if he did not receive adequate responses by the deadline, he would “have no option but to discontinue operations at” the Site.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Then, in relation to MES, the agreed penalty is $30,000 both for the contravention of s729(1)(a), which arises from the dismissal of the employees, and for its accessorial liability for Crisp’s contravention of s 400(5) in making the AWA offer. The maximum penalty for a contravention of s 792(1)(a) by a body corporate is $33,000. The dismissal of each of the 37 employees constituted a separate contravention of s 729(1)(a). Again, the parties have treated the dismissals as a single course of conduct. The parties contend that the same level of culpability is common to each of the dismissals. The dismissals were all effected on the same date by letters in the same form from Elliott on behalf of MES. MES has admitted that all the dismissals were made for reasons which included the reason prohibited by s 793(1)(m). It follows, so it is submitted, that the employees were dismissed as part of a single strategy which was not directed at any of the employees in their individual capacity but, rather, targeted at them as a group and without distinction. I accept that this is a proper analysis of the facts in this case, whether by reliance upon the single course of conduct concept or by application of the totality principle. It is only the former on which the parties rely.CONSIDERATION The dismissals were a serious contravention of the Act. However, there are factors which contributed to those contraventions which should be taken into account. These are set out in the applicant’s submissions as follows:95.1the failure to reach agreement on a replacement collective agreement to the certified agreement;95.2the protracted industrial dispute which resulted in the voluntary administration of MEC;95.3the cancellation of the labour hire agreement; and95.4the fact that, although MES deliberately terminated the employment of the Employees, it did not intend to contravene s 792 of the Act and had sought and received advice prior to terminating the employment of each of the Employees. As to the accessorial liability of MES for Crisp’s contraventions, it is also appropriate to treat the liability of MES as arising from the single course of conduct for the same reasons. MES was, through Eliott, centrally involved in the contravention of s 400(5). I agree with the conclusion expressed in [98] of the applicant’s submissions, which reflects the agreement of the parties in relation to MES as follows:The proposed penalty of $30,000 in respect of MES’ contravention of ss 400(5) and 792(1)(a) reflects the seriousness of the primary and accessorial contraventions of the WR Act by MES; the existence of mitigating factors in relation to those contraventions and the fact that it is proposed that substantial penalties be imposed on Crisp, MEC and Eliott for contraventions of s 400(5) in respect of the same conduct and on Eliott in relation to s 792(1)(a). In oral submissions, Mr Moore drew attention to other litigation arising out of the circumstances of the dismissal of the 37 employees. In those proceedings, Finkelstein J made orders that the employees were entitled both to redundancy payments and additional notice. In a separate judgment, his Honour found that the failure to make those payments amounted to contraventions of the Act. The parties did not rely on these contraventions as relevant to the imposition of penalties in this proceeding, because the earlier proceedings arose out of the very same circumstances as this proceeding.