Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (Stay application)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (Stay application) [2024] FCA 1024

File number(s): NSD 489 of 2024
Judgment of: HALLEY J
Date of judgment: 23 August 2024
Date of publication of reasons: 4 September 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application by appellants for a stay of civil penalty, consumer redress and costs orders made by the primary judge pending hearing and determination of appeal – respondents consented to stay of civil penalty and costs orders subject to security for costs and appeal being prosecuted expeditiously – where interim stay of consumer redress orders made to enable further submissions – where respondents contend interim stay of consumer redress orders should be discharged because of prejudice to consumers and lack of arguable grounds of appeal – whether a successful appeal is likely to be rendered nugatory – whether either party will be prejudiced by the stay – whether the appeal has arguable prospects of success – consideration of the balance of convenience and competing rights of the parties – order staying consumer redress orders not discharged
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.08

Cases cited:

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (recs apptd) (1985) 2 NSWLR 685

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v BMW (Australia) Limited (No 2) [2003] FCA 864

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 344

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 795

In-N-Out Burgers, Inc v Hashtag Burgers Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 722

Marconi’s Wireless Telegraph Co Ltd v Commonwealth (No 3) (1913) 16 CLR 384

Phillip Morris (Australia) Ltd v Nixon [1999] FCA 1281

Powerflex Services Pty Ltd v Data Access Corp (1996) 67 FCR 65

Redbubble Ltd v Hells Angels Motorcycle Corporation (Australia) Pty Ltd (2022) 168 IPR 74; [2022] FCA 1039

Stefanovski v Digital Central Australia (Assets) Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 1121

Wilson v Church (No 2) (1879) 12 Ch D 454

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Economic Regulator, Competition and Access
Number of paragraphs: 76
Date of last submission/s: 20 August 2024
Date of hearing: 31 July – 2 August 2024
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr S Prince SC with Mr B May
Solicitor for the Appellants: Assure Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Arnott SC with Ms V Brigden
Solicitor for the Respondent: Webb Henderson

ORDERS

NSD 489 of 2024
BETWEEN:

MASTER WEALTH CONTROL PTY LTD (ACN 148 036 677)

First Appellant

DOMINIQUE GRUBISA

Second Appellant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

HALLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 AUGUST 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appellants are to submit a draft index to Part A of the appeal book to a Registrar for approval, by 4.00 pm on Friday, 6 September 2024.

2.The appellants are to file and serve Part A…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and C... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1024
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involved an application by Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd and Dominique Grubisa (appellants) for a stay of the civil penalty, consumer redress and costs orders made by the primary judge. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) opposed the stay application. The court was required to decide whether the consumer redress orders should be stayed pending the determination of the appeal. The appellants argued that without a stay, the appeal would be rendered nugatory due to their financial position. The ACCC argued that the interim stay should be discharged because of the prejudice to consumers and the lack of arguable grounds of appeal. The court considered the balance of convenience and competing rights of the parties.

The court found that if the consumer redress orders were not stayed, the appeal would likely be rendered nugatory. The financial evidence demonstrated that Master Wealth was unlikely to be able to comply with the consumer redress orders. The court concluded that the balance of convenience favoured a stay of the consumer redress orders as there was no serious prospect that Master Wealth would be able to meet the consumer redress orders, and third parties would likely have to fund the appeal. The court therefore made orders staying the consumer redress orders pending the determination of the appeal. The court also made orders regarding the prosecution of the appeal, including deadlines for the filing of appeal documents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellants are to submit a draft index to Part A of the appeal book to a Registrar for approval, by 4.00 pm on Friday, 6 September 2024.

2. The appellants are to file and serve Part A of the appeal book within 14 days of being notified of a Registrar’s approval of the Part A index.

3. If the parties are notified that the Full Court requires Part B of the appeal book to be prepared, the appellants are to file and serve Part B of the appeal book, no later than 30 business days before the hearing.

4. The appellants are to file an outline of submissions (of no more than ten pages), and a chronology, by 4.00 pm on Monday, 30 September 2024.

5. The respondent is to file an outline of submissions (of no more than ten pages), and a chronology, by 4.00 pm on Monday, 14 October 2024.

6. The appellants are to file any submissions in reply (of no more than five pages) by 4.00 pm on Monday, 28 October 2024.

7. The appellants are to file and serve Part C of the appeal book, by 5 business days before the hearing.

8. The appellants are to serve on the respondent a list of authorities and legislation to which they intend to refer, by 5 business days before the hearing.

9. The respondent is to file a list of authorities and legislation to which it intends to refer, by 4 business days before the hearing.

10. The appellants are to file and serve an eBook of authorities being a jointly consolidated version of all the authorities, legislation and explanatory and other material proposed to be relied on at the hearing by all parties, by 4 business days before the hearing.

11. All parts of the appeal book and lists of authorities and legislation be provided to the Court in electronic form in accordance with the format(s) specified in paragraph 4.3 of the eBooks Practice Note.

12. The parties have liberty to apply on 3 days’ notice.

13. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

These are my written reasons for declining to discharge the stay of the consumer redress orders. B. BACKGROUND On 15 December 2022, the ACCC commenced proceedings NSD 1104 of 2022 against Master Wealth and Dominique Grubisa, for making false or misleading representations in contravention of the Australian Consumer Law in Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). On 9 April 2024, following a hearing on liability, the primary judge made declarations that Master Wealth had made false or misleading representations in contravention of the Australian Consumer Law and that Ms Grubisa was involved in those contraventions, and published reasons for judgment: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 344 (Liability Judgment or LJ). On 23 April 2024, the primary judge made timetabling orders and listed the matter for hearing on 4 July 2024 to determine the remaining question of relief. On the same day, the appellants filed an application for leave to appeal the Liability Judgment, together with an interlocutory application seeking a stay of the proceedings pending the hearing of the application for leave to appeal and/or the appeal (initial stay application). On 13 May 2024, I heard the initial stay application and at the conclusion of the hearing made orders dismissing the application on the basis that the initial stay application was premature given the question of relief had yet to be determined. On 19 July 2024, the primary judge made orders for relief, and published reasons for judgment: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd (Penalty) [2024] FCA 795 (Relief Judgment or RJ). On 26 July 2024, the appellants filed an interlocutory application seeking a stay of the 19 July 2024 orders pending the hearing of the appeal (stay application) and an affidavit in support of the stay application of Ms Grubisa. On 31 July 2024, I commenced hearing the stay application. At that stage the grounds of appeal were set forth in a draft notice of appeal annexed to an affidavit of the appellants’ solicitor affirmed on 22 April 2024 (draft notice of appeal). None of the grounds in the draft notice of appeal sought to impugn the orders made by the primary judge on 19 July 2024. At the hearing on 31 July 2024, the appellants advanced the stay application on the basis that because of the financial position of Master Wealth, unless there was a stay of the 19 July 2024 orders, the orders would have the effect of rendering the appeal that the appellants otherwise sought to advance in the draft notice of appeal nugatory. The appellants relied on an affidavit of Ms Grubisa sworn on 30 July 2024 in which she addressed the current financial position of Master Wealth. The ACCC advised the Court that it would consent to a stay of the civil penalty orders and the costs orders if the appellants agreed to provide security for its costs of the appeal and undertook to prosecute the appeal with expedition. The ACCC, however, opposed any stay of the consumer redress orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 19 July 2024, the primary judge made orders for relief, and published reasons for judgment: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Master Wealth Control Pty Ltd (Penalty) [2024] FCA 795 (Relief Judgment or RJ). On 26 July 2024, the appellants filed an interlocutory application seeking a stay of the 19 July 2024 orders pending the hearing of the appeal (stay application) and an affidavit in support of the stay application of Ms Grubisa. On 31 July 2024, I commenced hearing the stay application. At that stage the grounds of appeal were set forth in a draft notice of appeal annexed to an affidavit of the appellants’ solicitor affirmed on 22 April 2024 (draft notice of appeal). None of the grounds in the draft notice of appeal sought to impugn the orders made by the primary judge on 19 July 2024. At the hearing on 31 July 2024, the appellants advanced the stay application on the basis that because of the financial position of Master Wealth, unless there was a stay of the 19 July 2024 orders, the orders would have the effect of rendering the appeal that the appellants otherwise sought to advance in the draft notice of appeal nugatory. The appellants relied on an affidavit of Ms Grubisa sworn on 30 July 2024 in which she addressed the current financial position of Master Wealth. The ACCC advised the Court that it would consent to a stay of the civil penalty orders and the costs orders if the appellants agreed to provide security for its costs of the appeal and undertook to prosecute the appeal with expedition. The ACCC, however, opposed any stay of the consumer redress orders. The consumer redress orders were in the following terms:7.Pursuant to section 239 of the ACL, DG Institute offer redress to each student who enrolled in the MWC program in the period April 2017 to November 2022 (the MWC students) in accordance with orders 8 to 10 below.8.DG Institute must within 14 days of the date of this order, cause to be sent a notice in the form of Schedule 1 to the MWC students:(a) where DG Institute has an email address for the student, by email;(b) where DG Institute has a postal address but not an email address, or DG Institute receives an “undeliverable” message for the email address and has a postal address, by ordinary prepaid mail;(c) where DG Institute has neither a valid email address nor a postal address, by whatever means (if any) DG Institute can use to send the notice.9.DG Institute must at its own expense within 14 days of the date of this order, publish or cause to be published a link to a notice substantially in the form of Schedule 1 for a period of 45 days and must not delete or modify the publication or post during that period:(a) on the home page of the website with the URL Institute Website);(b)on the Facebook page with the URL align="left">(c) the Facebook page with the URL the Instagram account with the name “dominiquegrubisa” or the URL and(e) the LinkedIn account with the URL Institute must, within 56 days of the date of this order, provide a refund (in an amount equal to the course registration fee paid by that student plus interest at the prejudgment interest rate set out in the Court’s practice note (GPN-INT) from the date the student paid the course registration fee to the date the refund is provided) to each MWC student who has provided DG Institute with the student’s bank account details, by depositing the refund in the student’s nominated bank account.11.By 63 days of the date of this order, the proper officer of DG Institute provide to the Applicant an affidavit detailing the respective steps it has taken to comply with orders 7 to 10 above, including:(a) details of the dates on which payments were made;(b) the recipients of the payments and the amounts paid;(c) for any students who have not been provided a refund, the steps taken to provide such a refund and the reasons why the refund has not been provided.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The ACCC submitted that the proposition that the course fees paid by students represented the loss or damage which had been suffered or likely to be suffered was a proposition which was accepted, and in fact, advanced, by Master Wealth to the primary judge. The ACCC submitted that in those circumstances it is not open for the appellants to challenge that proposition in a ground of appeal before a Full Court. E. CONSIDERATION I was satisfied that if the consumer redress orders were not stayed pending the determination of the appeal, the appeal would have been rendered nugatory. Ms Grubisa gave unchallenged evidence in her affidavit that:(a)on at least one approach, if the consumer redress orders were required to be paid in full, Master Wealth would be required to provide a refund in the order of some $14.7 million to its former students;(b)Master Wealth’s accountant had prepared a profit and loss statement and a balance sheet for Master Wealth as at 30 June 2024 that recorded a loss of $65,006.65 for that financial year, and a balance sheet as at 30 June 2024 with negative equity of $667,134.08; and (c)the primary judge had referred in the Relief Judgment at [4] to a balance sheet for Master Wealth as at 31 March 2024, which showed net assets in a negative amount of $484,555.00. On the financial information before the Court, there is no serious prospect that Master Wealth would be able to comply with the consumer redress orders, in any material amount, let alone in the sum of $14.7 million. It is possible that in the future, a liquidator might be able to commence proceedings to seek to claw back or recover funds, but on the financial statements of Master Wealth before the Court, Master Wealth has not disclosed any material ability to meet the consumer redress orders. There were references during the hearing to a company of which the former husband of Ms Grubisa was apparently a director. There was insufficient evidence, however, to form any view on the material before the Court, that that company would be either in a position to, willing to or would otherwise be under any obligation or liability to, remit funds to Master Wealth to enable it to satisfy any of the consumer redress orders. In my view, for the foregoing reasons, it is reasonably apparent that if the present stay of the consumer redress orders is discharged, it is likely that a liquidator will be appointed to Master Wealth and the appeal sought to be advanced by the appellants will be rendered nugatory. I am also satisfied that the balance of convenience favours a stay of the consumer redress orders. The specific prejudice that the ACCC identified was a delay in students receiving the benefit of the consumer redress orders and the diversion of financial resources that could otherwise be utilised to compensate students to paying the legal costs of the appellants in advancing their appeal. In many cases this would be a material consideration. In this case, however, the parlous financial position of Master Wealth demonstrates that this consideration carries more limited weight. The financial evidence before the Court does not provide any plausible basis that Master Wealth would be able to provide compensation to students, in whole or in material part, pursuant to the consumer redress orders. Further, the financial evidence does not suggest that Master Wealth is able to fund the proceedings or satisfy the order for security for costs from its own resources. On the material before the Court, it would appear that third parties will have to fund the provision of the security for costs and the appellants’ legal costs of prosecuting the appeal.