Mason v Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read
10 CLR 655

WALTER GEORGE MASON

THE COMMONWEALTH Civil Service Act 1884 (N.S.W.), (48 Vict., No. 24), secs. 2, 8, 48, 55-The Constitution

(63 &64 Vict., c. 12), sec. 34-Superannuation allowance - Period of com- putation-Officer-Telegraph line repairer -- Contribution to superannuation account-Position of similar class, character or importance.

In 1873 the plaintiff had been appointed by the Governor in Council to the office of a telegraph line repairer in the service of the Government of New South Wales, and he held this office in January 1885, when the Civil Service Act 1884 came into force. By sec. 2 of this Act "officer" is defined as a person holding office other than those mentioned in secs. 7 and 8. By sec. 48 an officer who has served 15 years is entitled to a superannuation allowance, and by sec. 53 a deduction may be made from each officer's salary to a super- annuation account. By sec. 55 any officer who held any office at the com- mencement of the Act is entitled to a superannuation allowance, subject to an abatement, although he has not contributed during his past service to the superannuation account. In the Civil Service list of 1885 the plaintiff was erroneously classified under sec. 7 of the Act, and no deduction to the superannuation account was made from his salary. No objection to this classification was made by the plaintiff. In 1889 the plaintiff was appointed a post and telegraph master, and was then classified as an officer, and from this time deductions to the superannuation account were regularly made from his salary.

Held, that the plaintiff was an officer within the meaning of sec. 2 from the time of his appointment in 1873, and upon his retirement was entitled to a superannuation allowance calculated from that date.

The words occupying positions of similar class character or importance," in sec. 8, qualify the words 'persons employed in the printing and telegraph offices, dredge and marine service" as well as the words " other persons"

10 CLR 656

immediately preceding, and the nature of the plaintiff's duties and the mode of his appointment showed that his office was not of such a kind as to fall

ACTION by the plaintiff against the Commonwealth for super- annuation allowance. By consent of the parties the case was remitted to the Full Court by O'Connor J. upon a statement of facts agreed upon by the parties, the Full Court to have power to draw all inferences of fact necessary for their decision, and to enter judgment in accordance with their view of the rights of the parties.

The statement of facts agreed upon by the parties was as follows

1. On 9th November 1873 the plaintiff was appointed telegraph line repairer at Gundagai at a salary of £120 per annum.

2. On 7th September 1877 the plaintiff was appointed tele- graph stationmaster and line repairer at Pooncairn at a salary of £180 per annum.

3. On 8th June 1880 the plaintiff, at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mason v Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1910] HCA 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, a former telegraph line repairer and later post and telegraph master, brought an action against the Commonwealth seeking a superannuation allowance calculated from his initial appointment in 1873. The dispute centred on whether his entire period of service should be included in the calculation, or only the period from 1889 when he was formally classified as an "officer" and deductions for superannuation began. The case was remitted to the Full Court by consent, with the court empowered to draw inferences of fact and enter judgment accordingly.

The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff qualified as an "officer" under the Civil Service Act 1884 (N.S.W.) from the commencement of the Act in 1885, and if so, whether his service prior to 1885 should be included in the calculation of his superannuation allowance. Specifically, the court had to determine if the plaintiff's position as a telegraph line repairer fell within the exclusions of sections 7 or 8 of the Act, which would have prevented him from being classified as an "officer" for the purposes of superannuation.

The court reasoned that the plaintiff was an "officer" within the meaning of the Civil Service Act 1884 from his initial appointment in 1873. Despite his erroneous classification under section 7 of the Act in the 1885 Civil Service List, and the subsequent absence of superannuation deductions from his salary until 1889, the court found no evidence that his position was of a class, character, or importance that would exclude him under section 8. The nature of his duties, his appointment by the Governor in Council, and the lack of similar rules and regulations in his department to those mentioned in section 7, all supported his classification as an officer. Consequently, the court held that the plaintiff was entitled to have his entire service, from 1873 to his retirement, included in the calculation of his superannuation allowance, subject to any abatements provided for by section 55 of the Act for periods where contributions were not made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.