Mason v Battaglia, Spiller, Norco Co-Operative Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1997] QCA 193
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 3765 of 1996

Brisbane

[Mason v. Battaglia]

BETWEEN:

AND:

MYRNA A. MASON

(First Defendant) Appellant
AND:  STEFAN BRUNO BATTAGLIA
(Plaintiff) Respondent

AND:

ANDREW JOHN SPILLER

(Second Defendant)

AND:

NORCO CO-OPERATIVE LIMITED

(Third Defendant)

McPherson J.A.
Dowsett J.

Mackenzie J.

Judgment delivered 27 June 1997

Judgment of the Court

APPEAL ALLOWED WITH COSTS. JUDGMENT VARIED BY REDUCING THE AMOUNT FOR WHICH JUDGMENT WAS GIVEN FROM $676,427.71 TO $322,427.71.

CATCHWORDS: 

PERSONAL INJURIES - Damages - Quantum - Plaintiff carrying on business through companies - Ascertainment of loss - Seymour v. Gough [1979] 1 Qd.R. 89.

CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE - Proof of - Failure to wear seat belt.

Counsel:  Mr P.A. Keane Q.C. S.-G. for the Appellant
Mr R.R. Douglas Q.C., with him, C.G.S.L. Jensen, for the respondent
Solicitors:  Clayton Utz for the Appellant
Rogers Matheson Clark for the Respondent
Hearing Date:  13 June 1997

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 3765 of 1996

Brisbane

Before McPherson J.A.
Dowsett J.
Mackenzie J.

[Mason v. Battaglia]

BETWEEN:

MYRNA A. MASON

(First Defendant) Appellant
AND:  STEFAN BRUNO BATTAGLIA
(Plaintiff) Respondent

AND:

ANDREW JOHN SPILLER

(Second Defendant)

AND:

NORCO CO-OPERATIVE LIMITED

(Third Defendant)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE COURT

Judgment delivered 27 June 1997

On 21 August 1986 the plaintiff was injured in an accident involving a motor vehicle in which

he was travelling as a passenger in the front seat. He sustained various injuries, of which the most

serious were a closed head injury with cerebral oedema and laceration of a small bowel mesentery. In

an action in the Supreme Court, he was awarded a total of $676,427.71 for all categories of damage.

It is not necessary to specify each of them in detail because the sole item challenged on this appeal is

the amount of $400,000 awarded for loss of earning capacity, together with a sum of $72,000 representing interest on the pre-trial component of that award, which was $200,000. Apart from that,

the only point in issue on the appeal is the trial judge’s decision not to reduce the damages on account

of contributory negligence arising from the plaintiff’s failure to wear a seat belt.

The plaintiff was 50 years old at the time of the accident and 60 at the time of trial. He came

to Australia from Italy in 1955 and, after a period as a manual labourer, he set up business as a builder,

and later turned to real estate development. In this he was remarkably successful, having, by the time

of the accident, accumulated assets valued at some millions of dollars.

The assessment of the plaintiff’s damages for economic loss presented a number of difficulties

at the trial . In many respects the learned judge formed an unfavourable impression of much of the

evidence of the plaintiff and of his accountant Mr Jackson, whose testimony he described…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mason v Battaglia, Spiller, Norco Co-Operative Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QCA 193
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mason v Battaglia, Spiller, Norco Co-Operative Ltd involved the plaintiff, who was pursuing damages for personal injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. The plaintiff, Mason, carried on business through companies and sought to ascertain the loss of income resulting from the injuries. The dispute was adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Queensland. The defendants were Battaglia, Spiller, and Norco Co-Operative Ltd. The plaintiff's primary contention was that the court should consider the loss of income from the perspective of the individual rather than the corporate entity, relying on the principles set forth in Seymour v Gough.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the damages should be calculated based on the income lost by the plaintiff as an individual or by the companies he operated. This raised questions about the applicability of Seymour v Gough to a situation where the plaintiff's income was derived through corporate structures. The court had to balance the principles of compensation with the recognition of the corporate veil, particularly in the context of damages for personal injury.

In delivering the judgment, the court held that the damages should reflect the loss of income to the plaintiff as an individual, notwithstanding the corporate structure through which he conducted his business. The court reasoned that the injury itself was personal, and therefore, the loss of income should be assessed from that individual perspective. The decision adhered to the precedent set by Seymour v Gough, which emphasises the principle that damages for personal injury should be calculated based on the individual's loss. The court ultimately awarded damages to Mason, reflecting the loss of income from his personal injury, without regard to the corporate entities through which he carried on business.

The court ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiff damages, reflecting the loss of income attributable to the personal injuries sustained in the accident. The precise amount of damages was left to be determined in further proceedings, but the court's decision provided clarity on the approach to be taken in assessing such damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established