Mary Hanna v Singapore Airlines Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Reported Decision:

6 DCLR (NSW) 214

District Court


CITATION: Mary Hanna v Singapore Airlines Ltd [2007] NSWDC 288
HEARING DATE(S): 28 September 2007
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 28 September 2007
JURISDICTION: Civil
JUDGMENT OF: Neilson DCJ at 1
DECISION: Defendant's application granted; Action is dismissed; Plaintiff to pay defendant's costs; Exhibits to be returned
CATCHWORDS: Plaintiff claimed she developed "deep venous thrombosis" as a result of flying between Sydney and Cairo commencing on 21 June 2005 - Condition was in fact pedal oedema - Plaintiff had booked a seat in a "front row" aisle leading to an emergency exit - At check-in, computer of carrier malfunctioned and this seat not allocated to her but a seat in the very back aisle - Further request for a seat in the desired aisle refused as plaintiff suffering from a disability - Seating allocation alleged to constitute "an unexpected event external to the passenger which occurred ... in the course of the operation of embarking the aircraft" - Proceedings dismissed under UCPR 13.4 - Civil Aviation Carriers Liability Act 1959 (Cth) - Civil Aviation Regulations 1988, reg 254 (Cth) - Warsaw Convention 1929, article 17 - Kotsambasis v Singapore Airlines Ltd (1997) 42 NSWLR 110 - McCarthy v Northwest Airlines Inc 56F 3d 313 (Int Cir 1995) - Povey v Qantas Airways Ltd (2005) 223 CLR 189 - Re Deep Vein Thrombosis and Air Travel Group Litigation [2004] QB 234 (CA) - Olympic Airways v Husain (2004) 540 US 644
LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Aviation Carriers Liability Act 1959 (Cth)
CASES CITED: Kotsambasis v Singapore Airlines Ltd (1997) 42 NSWLR 110
McCarthy v Northwest Airlines Inc 56F 3d 313 (Int Cir 1995)
Povey v Qantas Airways Ltd (2005) 223 CLR 189
Re Deep Vein Thrombosis and Air Travel Group Litigation [2004] QB 234 (CA)
Olympic Airways v Husain (2004) 540 US 644
PARTIES: Mary Hanna (Plaintiff / Respondent)
Singapore Airlines Ltd (Defendant / Applicant)
FILE NUMBER(S): 2541/07
COUNSEL: D Elliott (Plaintiff / Respondent)
J Hogan-Doran (Defendant / Applicant)

JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: This is an application by the defendant that proceedings be dismissed pursuant to r 13.4 on the grounds that the statement of claim discloses no reasonable cause of action.

2 The plaintiff had booked a return economy air ticket to travel from Sydney to Egypt with the defendant Singapore Airlines. At the time of making her booking, the plaintiff specifically requested a seat in the emergency aisle so that she could elevate her feet, as she suffered from a pre-existing medical condition. She was advised by her travel agent that such a seat was available to her. On or about 20 June 2005 the travel agent confirmed that the plaintiff was seated in the front row in an emergency aisle.

3 Paragraph 5 of the statement of claim is in these terms:


      “On 21 June 2005 the plaintiff was due to fly out from Sydney. When she arrived at the airport and checked in she was told that there had been…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mary Hanna v Singapore Airlines Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWDC 288
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Mary Hanna, brought an action against Singapore Airlines Ltd, alleging that she developed deep venous thrombosis as a result of flying between Sydney and Cairo on 21 June 2005. The plaintiff had booked a seat in the front row aisle leading to an emergency exit. However, due to a malfunction of the airline's check-in computer, she was assigned a seat in the back aisle. The plaintiff further requested a seat in the desired aisle but was refused as she was suffering from a disability. Hanna argued that the seating allocation constituted an unexpected event external to the passenger which occurred in the course of the operation of embarking the aircraft. The defendant applied to dismiss the proceedings under UCPR 13.4, and the court considered the relevant statutory provisions and case law.

The court had to determine whether the plaintiff's condition, pedal oedema, could be considered a form of deep venous thrombosis and whether the airline's seating allocation was an unexpected event external to the passenger. The court also had to consider the effect of the Civil Aviation Carriers Liability Act 1959 (Cth), the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988, and the Warsaw Convention 1929 on the plaintiff's claim. The court examined relevant case law, including Kotsambasis v Singapore Airlines Ltd, McCarthy v Northwest Airlines Inc, Povey v Qantas Airways Ltd, and Olympic Airways v Husain. The court needed to determine whether the plaintiff's condition was a consequence of the airline's negligence or if it was an inherent risk of air travel.

The court found that the plaintiff's condition, pedal oedema, was not a form of deep venous thrombosis, and therefore the plaintiff's claim failed. The court held that the airline's seating allocation was not an unexpected event external to the passenger, as it was due to a malfunction of the airline's check-in computer, which was an internal process of the airline. The court also found that the plaintiff's claim was subject to the Civil Aviation Carriers Liability Act 1959 (Cth), which limits the liability of the carrier for personal injury to a certain amount. The court held that the plaintiff's claim was time-barred under the Act, and the plaintiff was unable to establish a causal link between the airline's actions and her injury. The court dismissed the proceedings and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs. The exhibits were to be returned to the defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Defendant's application granted; Action is dismissed; Plaintiff to pay defendant's costs; Exhibits to be returned

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established