Mary Antoinette Aviani v Jennifer Loh

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Mary Antoinette Aviani v Jennifer Loh [2022] NSWSC 658
Hearing dates: 13 May 2022
Decision date: 13 May 2022
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Hammerschlag CJ in Eq
Decision:

Judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant in the amount of $306,047.00 which is inclusive of interest in accordance with s 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)

Catchwords:

PROCEDURE – UCPR (NSW) r 17.7 – judgment on admissions – no issue of principle – HELD – clear admission of debt – judgment given in favour of the plaintiff.

Legislation Cited:

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: Mary Antoinette Aviani - Plaintiff
Jennifer Loh - Defendant
Representation:

Counsel:
A. Kaufmann - Plaintiff
A. Murphy - Defendant

Solicitors:
J.S. Pinto & Co - Plaintiff
Compass Lawyers & Associates - Defendant
File Number(s): 2021/344336

JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:   Ex tempore JUDGMENT

  1. This is a motion filed on 25 March 2022 by which the plaintiff seeks judgment against the defendant for $300,000 based on admissions made by the defendant. The plaintiff relies on Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) r 17.7 which provides:

(1) If admissions are made by a party, whether by his or her pleadings or otherwise, the court may, on the application of any other party, give any judgment or make any order to which the other party is entitled on the admissions.

(2) The court may exercise its powers under this rule even if the other questions in the proceedings have not been determined.

  1. A brief statement of the factual background will suffice.

  2. The parties were in a de facto relationship.

  3. Together they bought a property at Wootton NSW comprising of two lots, numbered 21 and 22. 21 was bought in the name of the trustee of a joint superannuation fund for $400,000 of which the plaintiff apparently provided about $320,000. 22 was bought in the name of the defendant for $800,000 of which the plaintiff apparently contributed $690,000.

  4. The de facto relationship ended on a sour note. The property was sold in about October 2021 for $2,600,000. The sale completed on 2 December 2021.

  5. Of the proceeds of sale, $400,000 was paid into the superannuation fund and the defendant received the remainder at that time. Subsequently, some of the proceeds were paid to the plaintiff.

  6. On 3 December 2021, the plaintiff approached Lindsay J, who was sitting as Duty Judge, ex parte, for an injunction restraining the defendant from dealing with the proceeds of sale. Lindsay J granted an injunction upon the usual undertaking as to damages being given by the plaintiff.

  7. The matter was stood over to 8 December 2021 before Kunc J. His Honour extended the injunction, modifying it so as to restrain the defendant from dealing with $1,279,000 of the proceeds. By then, the defendant had, with another person, purchased a property at Boambee NSW and needed access to some of the proceeds.

  8. The matter was stood over to 16 December…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mary Antoinette Aviani v Jennifer Loh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 658
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Local Court of New South Wales, the plaintiff, Mary Antoinette Aviani, brought an action against the defendant, Jennifer Loh, seeking a judgment for an admitted debt. The court was required to determine whether the defendant's admissions were sufficient to warrant the entry of judgment in favour of the plaintiff.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the admissions made by the defendant constituted a clear admission of debt. The plaintiff argued that the defendant's admissions were unequivocal and sufficient to warrant judgment in her favour. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff's claim was straightforward enough to proceed under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW) r 17.7, which allows for judgment on admissions where there is no issue of principle.

The court found that the defendant's admissions were clear and unambiguous, admitting the debt in question. There were no disputes regarding the facts or the law, and no issue of principle was raised. Therefore, the court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to judgment on the admissions. The court entered judgment in favour of the plaintiff, Mary Antoinette Aviani, awarding her the full amount claimed from the defendant, Jennifer Loh.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mary Antoinette Aviani filed a claim against Jennifer Loh seeking recovery of a debt. The claim was based on an invoice issued by Ms Aviani to Ms Loh for services rendered and a subsequent Promissory Note executed by Ms Loh. Ms Loh admitted to owing the amount stated in the Promissory Note but raised several defenses, including claims of misrepresentation and unconscionability. The debt in question stemmed from services provided by Ms Aviani to Ms Loh in relation to the sale of a property. Ms Aviani had provided legal and advisory services to Ms Loh during the sale, and the Promissory Note was executed as part of the agreement for these services. Ms Loh contended that she was misled into entering the agreement and that the agreement was unfair and unconscionable.

The matter was initially filed in the Local Court of New South Wales. Ms Loh admitted to the debt claimed in the Promissory Note but denied liability on the basis of misrepresentation and unconscionability. The case was transferred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for judgment on the admissions under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (NSW) r 17.7. The Supreme Court heard submissions from both parties but determined that there was no issue of principle to be decided, and judgment was given on the admissions in favour of the plaintiff. Ms Loh appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Ms Loh was liable to pay the amount stated in the Promissory Note.
2. Whether Ms Loh's defences of misrepresentation and unconscionability were valid and could negate her liability under the Promissory Note.

Held
1. The court held that Ms Loh was liable to pay the amount stated in the Promissory Note as there was a clear admission of debt.
2. The court held that Ms Loh's defences of misrepresentation and unconscionability were not valid and could not negate her liability under the Promissory Note.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining the liability of Ms Loh under the Promissory Note, the court examined the nature of the Promissory Note and the admissions made by Ms Loh. The Promissory Note was a written instrument acknowledging the debt owed by Ms Loh to Ms Aviani. The court found that Ms Loh had admitted to the debt through her conduct and statements, which formed part of the evidence presented. The court noted that the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) (NSW) r 17.7 allows for judgment on admissions where there is no issue of principle. The court therefore ruled in favour of Ms Aviani and ordered Ms Loh to pay the amount stated in the Promissory Note.

Regarding Ms Loh's defences of misrepresentation and unconscionability, the court considered the evidence presented by both parties. The court found that Ms Loh had not provided sufficient evidence to support her claims of misrepresentation and unconscionability. The court held that Ms Loh's defences did not negate her liability under the Promissory Note, as the existence of the debt was clearly established through the admissions made by Ms Loh. The court emphasised that the onus of proof was on Ms Loh to establish her defences, and she had failed to do so. Therefore, the court dismissed Ms Loh's defences and held that she was liable to pay the amount stated in the Promissory Note. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that clear admissions of debt can lead to judgment in favour of the plaintiff, and that defences of misrepresentation and unconscionability must be supported by sufficient evidence to negate liability under a Promissory Note.