Martino and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

Martino and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2021] AATA 1867 (13 May 2021)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:          2018/6101

Re:John Martino

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:The Hon. Matthew Groom, Senior Member

Date:13 May 2021

Place:Melbourne

The decision under review is set aside and substituted for a new decision that the appropriate rate of pension to be applied to the applicant:

(a)in respect of the period from 12 March 2013 to 30 July 2014 is the temporary special rate backdated to 12 December 2012;

(b)in respect of the period from 31 July 2014 to 29 November 2015 is the intermediate rate;

(c)in respect of the period from 30 November 2015 for the balance of the assessment period is the temporary special rate; and

(d)prospectively from the date of this decision for a period of 18 months is the temporary special rate but subject to a further review to be undertaken before the conclusion of that period.

................................[sgd]........................................

The Hon. Matthew Groom, Senior Member

Catchwords

VETERANS’ ENTITLEMENTS – application for special rate of pension – veteran medically discharged due to accident – consideration of veterans’ capacity for work during the assessment period – consideration of medical evidence on state of veterans’ accepted condition at different times during assessment period – eligibility for special or intermediate rate of pension met for specific periods – consideration of evidence of permanency of condition – condition not permanent –  decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth)

Cases

Leigh and Repatriation Commission [2006] FCA 395

McDonald v Director General of Social Security (1984) 6 ALD 6

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Matthew Groom, Senior Member

13 May 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. This matter involves a review of a decision of the Veterans Review Board (the “VRB”) made on 13 August 2018 which assessed the applicant’s pension at the intermediate rate of pension with effect from 13 August 2018.

  2. The applicant’s L5-S1 lumbar disc degeneration condition (the “lower back condition”) had previously been accepted as a defence caused condition with entitlement to a pension under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (the “Act”).

  3. On 12 March 2013, the applicant made an additional claim for major depressive disorder and an application for an increase in his pension.

  4. On 8 August 2013, the applicant’s major depressive disorder with associated anxiety was accepted by the Department as defence caused and his pension was increased to the temporary special rate from 12 December 2012 to 2 May 2014 and then at 80% of the general rate.

  5. On 17 September 2013, the applicant made an application for review of the Department’s decision to the VRB. The hearing of that matter was adjourned pending further medical evidence.

  6. On 13 August 2018, the VRB assessed the applicant’s pension at the intermediate rate in accordance with section 23 of the Act.

  7. On 22 October 2018, the applicant made an application for review of the VRB’s decision which is the matter presently before this Tribunal.

    BACKGROUND

  8. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martino and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 1867
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Veterans Review Board regarding the applicant's entitlement to a special rate of pension. The applicant, who sustained a significant lower back injury during his military service, sought a review of the pension rate applied to him, arguing his capacity for remunerative work had been severely limited by his defence-caused conditions.

The Tribunal was required to determine the applicant's capacity for remunerative work during the assessment period, specifically whether he was unable to undertake work for 20 hours or more per week (intermediate rate) or for more than eight hours per week (special rate). Further, if the latter applied, the Tribunal had to consider whether the defence-caused conditions giving rise to that incapacity were permanent or temporary, to determine eligibility for the special or temporary special rate, and what pension rate should apply prospectively.

The Tribunal considered the applicant's evidence regarding his ongoing pain, rehabilitation, and sporadic work efforts following surgery in 2012. It noted the applicant's contention that his work capacity had consistently been less than eight hours per week since his surgery. Applying the relevant provisions of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986, the Tribunal found that the applicant's circumstances warranted different pension rates for distinct periods.

The Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a new decision. It determined that the temporary special rate should apply from 12 December 2012 to 30 July 2014, the intermediate rate from 31 July 2014 to 29 November 2015, and the temporary special rate from 30 November 2015 onwards. Prospectively, the temporary special rate was to apply for 18 months, subject to a further review before the conclusion of that period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 22 October 2018, the applicant made an application for review of the VRB’s decision which is the matter presently before this Tribunal.BACKGROUND The applicant is approximately 53 years of age and previously worked as a cadet officer at the Duntroon Royal Military College between 21 January 1991 and 22 October 1991. During his time at the college, the applicant suffered a significant lower back injury as a consequence of a fall, which subsequently lead to his medical discharge. As a consequence of his injury the applicant has experienced ongoing pain in his lower back as well as shooting pain through his left leg. The applicant is well educated. Following his discharge from service the applicant obtained a Bachelor of Arts with Honours at Monash University. The applicant then commenced a PhD in Classical History and Archaeology, however, before completing his PhD the applicant transferred to a Diploma of Education at the University of Melbourne. The applicant undertook work experience as part of that course and also worked part-time to help with family finances. Before graduating with his Diploma, the applicant returned to his PhD which he then completed in around 2006. The applicant found this period of his life particularly stressful and suffered significant sleep disruption and mood issues throughout this period and following. Between 2006 and 2012, the applicant established a commercial writing business which, among other things, included writing screenplays. He ceased his work in that capacity on 15 February 2012 as a consequence of a further deterioration in his lower back condition. The applicant’s evidence was that he had been working 15 to 20 hours per week during that period. As a result of the deterioration in the applicant’s lower back condition, in around February 2012 the applicant was assessed by his GP and then referred to a neurosurgeon, Mr Paul D’Urso, for a further assessment. The applicant subsequently underwent surgery involving an instrumented interbody fusion and rhizolysis procedure on 11 October 2012 which was performed by Mr Paul D’Urso. The applicant gave evidence that his initial recovery from surgery was slow and involved a program of rehabilitation including regular hydrotherapy, Pilates and remedial massage. The applicant gave evidence that following his recovery from surgery he undertook sporadic work involving very limited weekly hours which included some writing, research as well as a small number of public speaking engagements. In 2015, the applicant was engaged by Toyota Australia to write a history of Toyota’s manufacturing in Australia. The contract ran for approximately six months and required the applicant to undertake a trip to Japan for the purpose of conducting interviews. Following the completion of his work in Japan, the applicant then travelled to Europe to attend a wedding. The applicant claims that in late 2015, following his return from Europe, he suffered a further serious deterioration in his lower back condition and that the condition has continued to deteriorate further since that time continuing to significantly constrain his ongoing work capacity.RELEVANT LAW

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, the Tribunal satisfied that the appropriate rate of pension to be applied to the applicant:(a)in respect of the period from 12 March 2013 to 30 July 2014 is the temporary special rate backdated to 12 December 2012 in accordance with section 25 of the Act;(b)in respect to the period from 31 July 2014 to 29 November 2015 is the intermediate rate; (c)in respect of the period from 30 November 2015 for the balance of the assessment period is the temporary special rate; and(d)and prospectively from the date of this decision for a period of 18 months is the temporary special rate but subject to a further review to be undertaken before the conclusion of that period.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and substituted for a new decision that the appropriate rate of pension to be applied to the applicant:(a)in respect of the period from 12 March 2013 to 30 July 2014 is the temporary special rate backdated to 12 December 2012;(b)in respect to the period from 31 July 2014 to 29 November 2015 is the intermediate rate; (c)in respect of the period from 30 November 2015 for the balance of the assessment period is the temporary special rate; and(d)prospectively from the date of this decision for a period of 18 months is the temporary special rate but subject to a further review to be undertaken before the conclusion of that period.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Therefore, given the concessions that have been made and accepted by the Tribunal, the residual issues for determination are:(a)whether and for what periods during the assessment period the applicant was, due to his defence caused conditions, not capable of undertaking remunerative work for 20 hours or more per week such that the intermediate rate should be applied to the applicant’s pension; and(b)whether and for what periods during the assessment period the applicant was, due to his defence caused conditions, not capable of undertaking remunerative work for periods aggregating more than eight hours per week; (c)in the event that the applicant is not capable of undertaking remunerative work for periods aggregating more than eight hours per week in any period during the assessment period due to his defence caused conditions, then whether the Tribunal is satisfied that the defence caused conditions giving rise to that incapacity can be considered to be permanent, such that the special rate should be applied, or temporary, such that the temporary special rate should be applied; and(d)what is the appropriate rate to be applied to the applicant’s pension prospectively from the date of the Tribunal’s decision.CONTENTIONS AND CONSIDERATION The applicant contends that following his surgery for his lower back condition in October 2012 he undertook a rehabilitation program, as proposed by his neurosurgeon Mr D’Urso, and that his condition gradually improved through 2013 to 2015 which allowed him to return to the workforce but with very constrained hours of up to eight hours per week. He contends that until the first quarter of 2014 his work incapacity from his condition was total. The applicant acknowledges that during 2014 and through to his overseas trips in 2015 his condition had improved to a degree. However, the applicant contends that, notwithstanding some improvement during this period, from the first quarter of 2014 onwards he continued to be limited in his work capacity due to his lower back condition to less than eight hours per week. The applicant claims that in late 2015, following his return from Europe, he suffered a significant and sudden deterioration in his lower back condition which caused him to suffer severe back spasms and heightened levels of nerve and back pain. The applicant claims that since that time his lower back condition has not recovered and that he continues to suffer very debilitating symptoms including extended periods of complete immobility, extended periods of sciatica and greatly increased spinal pain. He claims that this has continued to constrain his work capacity to less than eight hours per week. The applicant’s evidence was that as a consequence of the deterioration of his condition there have been ongoing discussions with his current neurosurgeon regarding further surgery. The applicant’s evidence was that for the entire period following his surgery in 2012 he has required ongoing rehabilitation in the form of regular hydrotherapy, Pilates and remedial massage, although he has ceased doing Pilates on the recommendation of his doctors. The applicant’s evidence was that through this period he has at various times taken anti-inflammatory medication for his condition as well as medication in the effective management of his pain. The applicant contends that at no time since his surgery has he had a capacity to work eight hours or more per week. He also contends that at no time since his initial back injury has he had a capacity to work in excess of 20 hours per week.