Martino and Australian Taxation Office

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

CATCHWORDS – CUSTOMS AND EXCISE – tobacco producer licences – cancellation of licences – whether brother of applicant an associate of the applicant – whether associate is a fit and proper person – whether cancellation of licences necessary to protect the revenue – whether alternative market to sell produced tobacco – decision affirmed.

Excise Act 1901 ss. 28, 29, 30, 32, 35, 39B, 39G, 39H, 39L, 44, 60, 61, 61A, 61C, 116 and 117; Parts III and IV
Taxation Laws Amendment (Excise Arrangements) Act 2001 ss. 4 and 6
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 s. 995-1
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 ss. 6 and 318; Part X
Crimes Act 1914 s. 19B
Customs (Prohibited Imports) Regulations 1956
Air Navigation Regulations 1947
Broadcasting Act 1942 ss. 83, 83A, 86AA and 88
Excise Tariff Act 1921
Excise Regulations 1925 rr. 3, 4, 5, 6 and 39A
Customs Act 1901 s. 60

Civiti and Secretary, Tax Agents' Board of Victoria 90 ATC 2039
Stasos v Tax Agents' Board (1990) 21 ALD 437
Re Dowling and Secretary to Department of Health (1985) 8 ALD 171
Re Taylor and Department of Transport (1978) 1 ALD 312
Hughes and Vale Pty Ltd and Anor v State of New South Wales and Ors [No.2] (1955) 93 CLR 127
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond and Others (1990) 94 ALR 11
Stephens v Abrahams (1902) 27 VLR 753
Parker v Churchill (1986) 9 FCR 334
State Drug Crime Commission of NSW v Chapman (1987) 12 NSWLR 447
F.H. Faulding and Co. Limited v Collector of Customs, Federal Court, 23 August, 1991, G50/1990
Repatriation Commission v Smith (1987) 15 FCR 327

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 1242

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL     )          
  )          V2002/595
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION     )          

ReFRANCESCO MARTINO

Applicant

AndAUSTRALIAN TAXATION OFFICE

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal:                   Miss S A Forgie (Deputy President)
Date:  29 November, 2002
Place:  Melbourne

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the objection decision of the respondent dated 15 April, 2001.

S A FORGIE
  Deputy President

REASONS FOR DECISION

On 7 June, 2002, the applicant, Francesco Martino, applied for review of an objection decision made by a delegate of the respondent, the Commissioner of Taxation ("Commissioner") dated 15 April, 2001.  That objection decision disallowed an objection made on 12 February, 2002 to an earlier decision dated 14 January, 2002 cancelling producers licences numbered 1S015286 and 1S015499 issued to F & F Martino ("the partnership") ("the licences").  Each licence is a producer licence granted under Part IV of the Excise Act 1901 ("the Act") authorising the partnership to produce tobacco seed, tobacco plant or tobacco leaf. 

  1. At the hearing, Mr Martino was represented by Mr Traczyk of counsel and later by his solicitor, Mr Primerano, and the Commissioner by Mr Lorkin of counsel. The documents lodged pursuant to s. 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("T documents") were admitted in evidence together with a bundle of shipping documents, statements of Mr John Moore (General Manager of Tobacco Co-operative of Victoria Limited ("TCV")), Mr Robert…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martino and Australian Taxation Office and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 1242
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was an appeal by Francesco Martino against the cancellation of his tobacco producer licences by the Commissioner of Taxation. The Commissioner had cancelled the licences after finding that Mr Martino was an associate of Giuseppe Martino, who was not a fit and proper person. The Commissioner also found that there was no market for Mr Martino's tobacco and that the cancellation of the licences was necessary for the protection of the revenue. The Tribunal was required to consider whether the Commissioner was entitled to cancel Mr Martino's producer licence. The first main issue was whether Mr Martino was an associate of Giuseppe Martino and whether Giuseppe Martino was a fit and proper person. The second issue was whether the cancellation of the licence was necessary for the protection of the revenue. The Tribunal found that Mr Martino was an associate of Giuseppe Martino, who was not a fit and proper person. The Tribunal also found that the cancellation of the licences was necessary for the protection of the revenue as there was no market for Mr Martino's tobacco. The Tribunal affirmed the objection decision of the respondent dated 15 April, 2001.

Background

Background to the litigation

Francesco Martino has been a tobacco producer in Victoria since 1969, working on his 30-acre farm and an additional ten acres leased from a neighbour. He produces tobacco with his family and sometimes with the assistance of farm labourers. Since the de-regulation of the tobacco industry in 1994, Martino has sold his tobacco through the Tobacco Leaf Marketing Board, now known as the Tobacco Co-operative of Victoria (TCV). The TCV arranges the sale of tobacco leaf to its customers, which are Philip Morris Limited and British American Tobacco Australia Limited (BATA). Martino's brother, Giuseppe Martino, was previously a tobacco farmer but was no longer in the industry. In April 2000, Giuseppe visited Martino's farm and informed him that he intended to sell some tobacco, which he had purchased for $500 per bale. Giuseppe did not succeed in selling the tobacco and, along with Martino, was intercepted by the police. Both were subsequently charged under the Excise Act 1901. On June 26, 2001, Bongiorno J in the Supreme Court of Victoria found Martino in breach of the Act and ordered him to be discharged without conviction upon entering a recognizance of $100. In July 2001, BATA and Philip Morris informed the TCV that they would not purchase tobacco from any grower involved in the illegal sale of tobacco, including Martino. The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) visited Martino's farm in July 2001, advising him of the changes to the Act and the ATO's rating of producers according to their risk to the tax revenue. Martino was rated as high risk due to his recent conviction and the low yield of his farm. On December 12, 2001, a delegate of the Commissioner suspended Martino and his wife's licences, and on January 14, 2002, the licences were cancelled. Martino applied for review of the cancellation decision, which was subsequently affirmed by the Tribunal.

Francesco Martino applied for review of an objection decision made by a delegate of the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) dated April 15, 2001. The objection decision disallowed an objection made on February 12, 2002, to an earlier decision dated January 14, 2002, cancelling producers licences numbered 1S015286 and 1S015499 issued to F & F Martino. The matter was heard before Miss S A Forgie (Deputy President) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on November 6 and 11, 2002, in Melbourne. The Tribunal affirmed the objection decision of the ATO dated April 15, 2001.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Martino is an associate of Mr Giuseppe Martino under s. 39G(1)(f) of the Excise Act 1901.
2. Whether Mr Giuseppe Martino is a fit and proper person under s. 39G(1)(f)(i) of the Excise Act 1901.
3. Whether the cancellation of Mr Martino's producer licence is necessary to protect the revenue under s. 39G(1)(m) of the Excise Act 1901.

Held
1. The court held that Mr Martino is an associate of Mr Giuseppe Martino under s. 39G(1)(f) of the Excise Act 1901.
2. The court held that Mr Giuseppe Martino is not a fit and proper person under s. 39G(1)(f)(i) of the Excise Act 1901.
3. The court held that the cancellation of Mr Martino's producer licence is necessary to protect the revenue under s. 39G(1)(m) of the Excise Act 1901.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the definition of "associate" under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 and concluded that Mr Martino is an associate of Mr Giuseppe Martino, as Mr Giuseppe Martino is Mr Martino's brother. The court held that Mr Giuseppe Martino is not a fit and proper person based on his conviction for illegal sale of tobacco. The court then examined the meaning of "protect the revenue" and determined that the cancellation of Mr Martino's licence was necessary to ensure that the Commonwealth receives all the excise duty that is payable in respect of tobacco grown on Mr Martino's farm and to prevent the marketing of tobacco illegally in Australia. The court found that there is no market in Australia or overseas for Mr Martino's tobacco, and thus, the suspension of his licence is necessary for the protection of the revenue. The court concluded that there is no reasonable likelihood of Mr Martino finding a market for his tobacco in the near future, and therefore, the cancellation of his licences is the appropriate course of action.