Martincic v The State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   MARTINCIC -v- THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2019] WASCA 134

CORAM:   MAZZA JA

BEECH JA

JENKINS J

HEARD:   20 AUGUST 2019

DELIVERED          :   30 AUGUST 2019

FILE NO/S:   CACR 146 of 2018

BETWEEN:   ANNABELLE MARTINCIC

Appellant

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   GETHING DCJ

File Number             :   IND 870 of 2017


Catchwords:

Criminal law and procedure - 185 counts of stealing - Whether judge's summary of the defence case was inadequate so as to give rise to a miscarriage of justice - Whether judge erred in failing to leave a defence of honest claim of right on all counts

Legislation:

Criminal Code (WA), s 22

Result:

Leave to appeal on grounds 1 and 2 granted
Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : S B Watters
Respondent : R G Wilson

Solicitors:

Appellant : Patti Chong Lawyer
Respondent : The Director Of Public Prosecutions (WA)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Dobson v The Queen (Unreported, WACCA, Library No 8213, 11 April 1990)

Harwood v The State of Western Australia [2016] WASCA 8

Hayman v Cartwright [2018] WASCA 116; (2018) 53 WAR 137

Huggins v The State of Western Australia [2018] WASCA 61

Ilich v The Queen [1987] HCA 1; (1987) 162 CLR 110

Interim Advance Corporation Pty Ltd v Fazio [2008] WASCA 140

Kingdon v The State of Western Australia [2012] WASCA 74; (2012) 223 A Crim R 449

McKell v The Queen [2019] HCA 5; (2019) 93 ALJR 309

MLS v The State of Western Australia [2018] WASCA 56

Nudd v The Queen [2006] HCA 9; (2006) 80 ALJR 614

R v Baden-Clay [2016] HCA 35; (2016) 258 CLR 308

R v Pollard [1968] QWN 13

R v Prosser (1993) 70 A Crim R 391

R v Waine [2005] QCA 312; [2006] 1 Qd R 458

Ruthsalz v The State of Western Australia [2018] WASCA 178

Walden v Hensler [1987] HCA 54; (1987) 163 CLR 561

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:

Introduction

  1. The appellant was convicted of 185 counts of stealing, contrary to s 378 of the Criminal Code (WA). Each count alleged that, on various dates between January 2014 and April 2016, the appellant stole a specified sum of money the property of M3 Building and Construction Pty Ltd (M3). The total amount involved exceeded $1.1 million. The State case was that this occurred by the appellant transferring the specified sum from M3's bank account to one of four bank accounts which were linked with her or her de facto partner, Mr Stewart Martincic.

  2. The appellant appeals her convictions on two grounds.  Both grounds allege that the trial judge made an error that occasioned a miscarriage of justice.  The first ground contends that the trial judge failed to adequately direct the jury as to the defence case.  The second ground contends…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martincic v The State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASCA 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Martincic v The State of Western Australia was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The defendant, Martincic, was charged with 185 counts of stealing and contested the charges on the basis of an honest claim of right under section 22 of the Criminal Code. Martincic argued that the trial judge's summary of the defence case was inadequate, leading to a miscarriage of justice, and that the judge had erred in failing to leave the defence of honest claim of right on all counts. The primary legal issues revolved around whether the trial judge correctly assessed the evidence to determine if there was a need to leave the defence of honest claim of right to the jury.

The court examined the evidence presented and concluded that section 22 of the Code applies if there is any evidence, typically from the accused, that raises a defence. If, at the conclusion of the evidence, there is any evidence that could lead a reasonable jury, properly instructed, to have a reasonable doubt about whether the State had negated the defence, the trial judge must leave the defence to the jury. The court found that the judge's decision not to leave the defence to the jury was incorrect, as it was based on the defence counsel's agreement that there was no s 22 issue, rather than on the evidence presented at trial. Furthermore, the court held that a claim for the purposes of s 22 need only be honest and does not have to be reasonable or legally recognised.

The court allowed the appeal on grounds 1 and 2, finding that the judge's failure to leave the defence of honest claim of right on all counts constituted an error. The appeal was dismissed, however, as the court determined that the error did not result in a miscarriage of justice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to appeal on grounds 1 and 2 granted

Appeal dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 22 of the Code only applies if there is evidence, usually if not invariably from the accused, that raises a 'defence' under s 22.[86] If, at the close of the evidence, there is evidence which, taken at its highest in favour of the accused, could lead a reasonable jury, properly instructed, to have a reasonable doubt as to whether the State had negatived a defence under s 22, the trial judge must leave the defence to the jury even if counsel has not put the defence, and even if counsel has expressly abandoned it.[87] Thus, the fact that defence counsel agreed with the judge that there was no s 22 issue in relation to seven of the eight groups[88] does not determine whether the defence should have been left to the jury. That question depends upon the evidence at trial, not the approach taken by defence counsel.[86] Interim Advance Corporation [80].[87] Hayman v Cartwright [2018] WASCA 116; (2018) 53 WAR 137 [68] and cases there cited.[88] ts 446. A claim, for the purposes of s 22 of the Code, need only be honest. It does not have to be reasonable or one that is recognised in law.[89][89] Walden v Hensler [1987] HCA 54; (1987) 163 CLR 561, 568 - 569; Harwood [118] and cases there cited; Interim Advance Corporation [79]. To come within s 22 of the Code, the claim of right must be as to an entitlement 'in or with respect to property'.[90] Section 22 is not restricted to a claim to a beneficial interest in the property.[91] The claim of right must be one that, if correct, would legally entitle the person to do to the property that which he or she did.[92] In R v Waine, in a passage cited with approval in Interim Advance Corporation,[93] Keane JA said as follows:[94]It has been said that the clearest example of the operation of s. 22(2) of the Criminal Code is the case where a person does an act with respect to property in the honest but mistaken belief that he or she is the owner of the property (R v Walsh [1984] 2 Qd R 407). But it is also clearly established on the authorities that an honest claim of right may be made, not only as a claim to a proprietary or possessory right in property, but also as a claim to be entitled to act in respect of property. What is important is the honest belief that one is legally entitled to do to the property that which one is doing. That belief as to entitlement may come equally from the consent of the owner, or from a person believed to be the owner, as well as from a mistaken belief as to one's own title (Mitchell v Norman; Ex parte Norman [1965] Qd R 587 at 594 ‑ 595; Walden v Hensler at 568; R v Williams [1988] 1 Qd R 289 at 295; R v Jeffrey & Daley [2002] QCA 429 at [21] ‑ [23]; (2002) 136 A Crim R 7 at 12 ‑ 13). (bolded emphasis in original)[90] Walden v Hensler (592); Harwood [118]; Interim Advance Corporation [76].[91] R v Waine [2005] QCA 312; [2006] 1 Qd R 458 [29].[92] Interim Advance Corporation [78]; Harwood [119]; both citing R v Waine [25].[93] Interim Advance Corporation [78].[94] R v Waine [25].