Martincevic v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Martincevic v Commonwealth of Australia [2007] FCA 453

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Judicial review – Where applicant discharged from Australian Army – Where decision reviewable under Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act, but no ground of review made out

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)
Defence Act 1903 (Cth)
Defence (Personnel) Regulations 2002 (Cth)

Anthony Martincevic v Commonwealth of Australia [2006] FCA 1514 Cited
The Commonwealth v Welsh (1947) 74 CLR 245 Cited
Marks v The Commonwealth (1964) 111 CLR 549 Cited

ANTHONY MARTINCEVIC v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA, CHIEF OF ARMY AND ANTHONY JOHN EGAN
QUD 440 OF 2006

SPENDER J
28 MARCH 2007
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD 440 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

ANTHONY MARTINCEVIC
Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
First Respondent

CHIEF OF ARMY
Second Respondent

ANTHONY JOHN EGAN
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

SPENDER J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 MARCH 2007

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD 440 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

ANTHONY MARTINCEVIC
Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
First Respondent

CHIEF OF ARMY
Second Respondent

ANTHONY JOHN EGAN
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

SPENDER J

DATE:

28 MARCH 2007

PLACE:

BRISBANE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is an application for judicial review, filed on 3 November 2006, seeking a review of a decision of Lieutenant Colonel Anthony John Egan, (‘the third respondent’), a delegate of the second respondent, made on 9 August 2006, to terminate Mr Martincevic’s (‘the applicant’) service with the Australian Defence Force (‘the decision’), the termination to be effective from 17 November 2006. 

  2. On 13 November 2006, Kiefel J heard an interlocutory application to suspend the operation of the decision pending the hearing of the substantive application. On 15 November 2006, pursuant to s 15 of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) (‘the ADJR Act’), her Honour granted a stay of the decision until the determination of the substantive proceedings, or earlier: Anthony Martincevic v Commonwealth of Australia [2006] FCA 1514.

  3. On 13 November 2006 an Amended Application for an Order of Review was filed.  That document is as follows:

    ‘1.Application to review the decision of the First, Second, and/or Third Respondent that the Applicant’s service with the Australian Defence Force be terminated on 17th November, 2006.

    2.Further or alternatively, application to review the conduct of the First, Second, and/or Third Respondent which it has engaged in namely purporting to terminate the Applicant’s service with the Australian Defence Force without investigating his Application for Redress of Grievance with respect to the Notice of Termination.

    3.Further or alternatively, application to review the conduct in which the First Respondent, Second Respondent and/or Third Respondent proposes to engage in, namely to terminate the Applicant’s service with the Australian Defence Force on 17th November, 2006.

    4.Alternatively, application to review the failure of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martincevic v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 453
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Martincevic v Commonwealth of Australia, the applicant, Martincevic, sought judicial review of the decision to terminate his service with the Australian Defence Force. The decision was made by the third respondent and was effective from 7 November 2006. The applicant contested the decision on several grounds, including an alleged breach of natural justice, an improper exercise of power, and an error of law. The applicant also argued that the decision-makers failed to investigate his Application for Redress of Grievance and did not consider a medical report from a consultant psychiatrist.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the decision to terminate the applicant's service was lawful and whether the decision-makers properly considered the applicant's Application for Redress of Grievance and the relevant medical evidence. The court had to determine if there was a breach of natural justice, an improper exercise of statutory power, or an error of law in the decision-making process.

The court found that the decision to terminate the applicant's service was made in accordance with the applicable policies and procedures. The court gave significant weight to the various reports and assessments that indicated the applicant was unfit for further military service. The court held that the decision-makers appropriately considered the applicant's response to the Notice of Termination and found no merit in the argument that there was a breach of natural justice or an improper exercise of power. Additionally, the court concluded that there was no error of law and that the decision-makers had correctly applied the relevant medical policies and procedures.

The court dismissed the application, finding that the decision to terminate the applicant's service was lawful and that there were no grounds for judicial intervention.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 8 August 2006, the third respondent made the decision to discharge the applicant, to be effective on 7 November 2006. A four page document, styled ‘STATEMENT OF REASONS FOR THE TERMINATION OF SERVICE DECISION 8233008 PTE A. MARTINCEVIC’, is signed by the third respondent. Relevantly, this document says:‘Weighting and conclusions drawn from the evidence8.In reaching the decision to order your discharge very high weight was afforded to the contents of the TN. The TN proposed that your service should be terminated.9.Very high weight was afforded to the MECRB determination, reference E, which confirmed your medical classification of MEC 403 and that you are not expected to regain fitness for deployment in the long term.10.Very high weight was afforded to the contents of the JHSA Summary, reference F, which determined that your prognonis is that you are likely to continue to struggle with your current circumstances.11.Very high weight was afforded to the Workplace Disability Report, which stated that you have poor trade skills and an inability to cope with stress. You have little motivation for work and an unwillingness to follow procedure and have difficulty in adjusting to change. You have a history of failing your BFA, require close supervision and considerable financial difficulties. As a result of continual threats of self-harm, your unit has considered you permanently undeployable and in the interests of your safety and the safety of others you are not to carry weapons or attend range practice.12.The recommendation from your CO that you should be discharged was weighted very high. Your CO reviewed your response and could not find justification to support your retention.13.Very high weight was afforded to the medical employment policies at references, C, D, I and J, which describe the medical employment profile to sustain a deployable profile.14.Very high weight was afforded to the psychological and psychiatric reports. Your CO initially referred you for assessment after demonstrating difficulty coping with stress and poor interpersonal relations during Exercise Crocodile 1999. On 17 Mar 06 Dr Detering confirmed your diagnosis that you suffered from a mental illness.15.Initially Dr Chalk noted that there was no clinical diagnosis, however, you have a long history of not coping, integrity issues and marginal work ethics. Dr Chalk did diagnose that you suffer from situational crisis with avoidance personality traits. You have been presenting to Dr Chalk every two weeks and therefore Dr Chalk knows you well to confirm your medical classification of MEC 403.16.High weight was afforded to your health statement. You state that there are no restrictions that prohibit you from conducting your normal duties and ask to be posted from 7 CSSB where you feel harassed.17.Low weight was afforded to your response to the TN. In your response you argue that the MECRB process was being improperly used as a continuing harassment by 7 CSSB. I noted that your response was very similar to your ROG. Your response did not contain any new medical evidence and therefore carried little weight. You requested and was granted an extension to submit new medical evidence but failed to provide any new evidence. Dr Chalk has stated that you asked him to provide additional assessment for which he did and the diagnosis remained the same, that is, MEC 403.Conclusion18.I am satisfied on the available evidence that you are unfit for further military service, I am legally bound to terminate your service. I therefore determine you are to be discharged IAW DPR 87(1)(c) ‘Medically Unfit’ IAW policy provisions and the principles of natural justice.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

SPENDER J
On 13 November 2006 an Amended Application for an Order of Review was filed. That document is as follows:‘1.Application to review the decision of the First, Second, and/or Third Respondent that the Applicant’s service with the Australian Defence Force be terminated on 17th November, 2006.2.Further or alternatively, application to review the conduct of the First, Second, and/or Third Respondent which it has engaged in namely purporting to terminate the Applicant’s service with the Australian Defence Force without investigating his Application for Redress of Grievance with respect to the Notice of Termination.3.Further or alternatively, application to review the conduct in which the First Respondent, Second Respondent and/or Third Respondent proposes to engage in, namely to terminate the Applicant’s service with the Australian Defence Force on 17th November, 2006.4.Alternatively, application to review the failure of the First Respondent, Second Respondent and/or Third Respondent to investigate the Applicant’s Redress of Grievance with respect to the issue of the Notice of Termination.4A.Alternatively, application to review the failure of the First Respondent, Second Respondent, Third Respondent in failing to take into account a medical report of Profession Whiteford, consultant psychiatrist, dated 10 August 2006 in proposing to terminate the Applicant’s service with the Australian Defence Force on 17 November 2006.5.The Applicant is aggrieved by the decision, conduct, proposed conduct or failure because he is a member of the Defence Force, the subject of the proposed termination and in those circumstances is “an aggrieved person” within the meaning of that term contained in Section 3(4) of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977.Review of Decision6.The grounds of the application are that contrary to s 5(1)(a) of the Act, there has been:-(a) a breach of the rules of natural justice;(b) contrary to s 5(1)(e) of the Act, the making of the decision was an improper exercise of the power confirmed by the enactment in pursuance of which it was purported to be made;(c) contrary to s 5(1)(f) of the Act, the decision involved an error of law.Application for Review of Conduct7.Contrary to:(a) s 6(1)(a) a breach of the rules of natural justice has occurred;(b) s 6(1) of the Act, the making of the proposed decision would be an improper exercise of the power conferred by the enactment;(c) s 6(1)(f) of the Act, an error of law has been, is being or is likely to be committed.8.Contrary to s 7(1) of the Act, a decision with respect to the Applicant’s Application for Redress of Grievance has not been made.9.The Applicant claims:(a) pursuant to s 16(1)(a) of the Act, an order quashing or setting aside the decision to terminate the Applicant’s service from the Australian Defence Force;(b) an order directing that the Applicant’s Application for Redress of Grievance be investigated and determined prior to the issue of any Termination Notice;(c) pursuant to s 16(2)(b) of the Act, an order that the First and/or Second Respondents be restrained from terminating the service of the Applicant;(d) pursuant to s 16(3) of the Act, an order directing that the Applicant’s Application for Redress of Grievance be investigated and determined prior to the issuing of any Notice of Termination. Further Orders9A.In the Alternative the Applicant seeks the orders set out in paragraph 9 herein pursuant to section 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903.’

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SPENDER J

The Defence Act 1903 (Cth) s 9A lays the statutory foundation, and provides:‘9A Administration of Defence Force(1)Subject to section 8, the Secretary and the Chief of the Defence Force shall jointly have the administration of the Defence Force except with respect to:(a) matters falling within the command of the Defence Force by the Chief of the Defence Force or the command of an arm of the Defence Force by the service chief of that arm of the Defence Force; or(b) any other matter specified by the Minister.(2)Instructions issued by or with the authority of the Secretary and the Chief of the Defence Force in pursuance of the powers vested in them jointly by virtue of subsection (1) shall be known as Defence Instructions (General).(3)The powers vested in the Secretary and the Chief of the Defence Force by virtue of subsection (1) extend to authorizing a service chief of an arm of the Defence Force to administer, in accordance with that authority, matters relating to that arm of the Defence Force, and instructions or orders issued or made by or with the authority of a service chief in relation to the administration of an arm of the Defence Force shall be known as:(a) in the case of the Navy—Defence Instructions (Navy);(b) in the case of the Army—Defence Instructions (Army); and(c) in the case of the Air Force—Defence Instructions (Air Force).(4)Where Defence Instructions (Navy), Defence Instructions (Army) or Defence Instructions (Air Force) are inconsistent with Defence Instructions (General), the Defence Instructions (General) prevail and the Defence Instructions (Navy), the Defence Instructions (Army) or the Defence Instructions (Air Force), as the case may be, shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be of no effect.(5)Evidence of Defence Instructions (General), Defence Instructions (Navy), Defence Instructions (Army) or Defence Instructions (Air Force) may be given in any proceedings in or before a Court, a service tribunal, the Defence Force Discipline Appeal Tribunal, or any other tribunal, by the production of a document purporting to be a copy thereof.(6)Defence Instructions (General), Defence Instructions (Navy), Defence Instructions (Army) or Defence Instructions (Air Force) may make provision in relation to a matter by applying, adopting or incorporating, with or without modification, any matter contained in an instrument or other writing, whether as in force at a particular time, or as amended and in force from time to time.’ Regulations 75 and 76 of the Defence Regulations 1952 (Cth) provide:‘75 Making of complaint(1)Subject to this Part, where a member considers that he or she has a grievance concerning any matter relating to his or her service, the member may make a complaint to his or her commanding officer.(2)A complaint shall be in writing.76 Referral of complaint(1)Subject to subregulation (2), if a member is not satisfied with the decision of a commanding officer on a complaint, the member may refer the complaint:(a) in the case of a member of the Navy — to the Chief of Navy; or(b) in the case of a member of the Army — to the Chief of Army; or(c) in the case of a member of the Air Force — to the Chief of Air Force.(2)If:(a)the complaint relates to service by the member:(i) in a unit or an organisation that is responsible directly to Headquarters Australian Defence Force and comprises personnel drawn from more than one arm of the Defence Force; or(ii) in Headquarters Australian Defence Force; and(b)the complaint is not connected only with the member’s own arm of the Defence Force;the complaint must be referred to the Vice Chief of the Defence Force.’