Martin v Whitsunday Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
State Reporting Bureau

Transcript of Proceedings

Copyright in this transcript is vested in the Crown. Copies thereof must not be made or sold without the written authority of the Director, State Reporting Bureau.

REVISED COPIES ISSUED State Reporting Bureau

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

Date: 8 / 3 / 01

JUDGE C F WALL QC

No 374 of 2000

MICHELLE MARTIN and REX KERGER and
EVELYN KERGER and GLENABBEY PARK PTY LTD
and TOM RIDEOUT and MARIE ABRAHAMS
and ADRIAN ABRAHAMS and FAY DWYER
and CHARLES DWYER and GEORGE TERRY WELLS
and BRIAN PRICE and JILLIAN PRICE And
FRANK COVINO and FILOMENA COVINO and
JOHN ROBERT WALFORD and JUDITH ANN WALFORD
and DEAN SCHUTZ and KAREN SCHUTZ and
KEVIN CURTIS and ANNE CURTIS and
KATE IRVING and JAMES GRAHAM BUTLER and

MAURICE LONG and JAN LONG and GREG BROWN and DOROTHY McALLISTER and ROBERT JEWELL and ELENOR JEWELL and JOHN DANIEL TANNOCH

Applicants

and
WHITSUNDAY SHIRE COUNCIL First Respondent
and
BILL SHARPE and SHARPE DEVELOPMENT
GROUP PTY LTD Second Respondent
TOWNSVILLE
..DATE 07/03/2001
JUDGMENT
07032001 T2-3/DLD M/T TSVDC8840 (Wall DCJ) 1

HIS HONOUR: In these proceedings, the applicants challenge the validity of the Council's approval of an application by the Second Respondent to change a condition of a development

approval under section 3.5.33 of the Integrated Planning Act.

The applicants contend that the Second Respondent's

application to the Council gave rise to assessable
development.

The relevant development approval is contained in a negotiated decision notice dated 15 December 1999. The approval was for a material change of use of premises for 49 units and a cafe at 6 Harper Street, Airlie Beach. Condition 1.1 required development to be undertaken in accordance with specified plans as modified by the approval. Condition 1.1(f) was as follows:

"1.1(f) The building shall be lowered in height by about
one metre, the maximum building height shall be as

follows:

(i) the eastern building RL43.6 metres AHD
(ii) the western building RL49.5 metres AHD."

On 28 January 2000 the Second Respondent made application to the Council "to modify the requirement imposed by the condition 1.1(f)" to increase the maximum height of each building. On 2 October 2000 the Council, acting under section 3.5.33 of the Integrated Planning Act, approved the application and changed condition 1.1(f) so that it now reads:

2  JUDGMENT

07032001 T2-3/DLD M/T TSVDC8840 (Wall DCJ) 1

"1.1(f) The maximum building height shall be as follows:

(i) the eastern building RL44.83 metres AHD (ii) the western building RL44.45 metres AHD in accordance with revised Elevation Plan GA09 North

Elevation."

The height changes do not involve any increase in floor area, storeys or the number of units in the approved development. The maximum building height is a reference to the highest point on the roof of each building. The effect, on average, is to slightly lower the height of the eastern building and increase the height of the western building by 1.1 metres. The change was necessitated by "structural engineering requirements". The effect of the increased…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martin v Whitsunday Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QPEC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Martin v Whitsunday Shire Council, the applicants challenged the validity of the Council's approval of an application by the Second Respondent to modify a condition of a development approval under section 3.5.33 of the Integrated Planning Act. The applicants argued that the proposed modification to the height of the buildings in the development constituted an assessable development. The applicants contended that the height changes increased the scale of the building and would prompt new or different objections, particularly concerning the loss of views from adjacent properties. The respondents argued that the changes did not constitute a material change in the intensity or scale of the use of the premises, and therefore did not result in an assessable development.

The legal issues before the court were whether the proposed modification to the height of the buildings constituted a material change in the intensity or scale of the use of the premises, and whether such a change would result in an assessable development under section 3.5.33 of the Integrated Planning Act. The court considered the relevant legislative provisions and case law, and determined that the issue of whether a change involves a "material change in the intensity or scale of the use of the premises" is a question of fact and degree, depending on the circumstances of each case. The court held that the proposed change did not materially change the intensity or scale of the development and did not result in an assessable development. The court found that the approach taken by the Council was not in error and dismissed the application.

The court concluded that the proposed change to the height of the buildings was not substantial enough to warrant categorisation of the change as assessable development. The court found that the development remained the same in all other respects, and the increase in height did not constitute a substantially different development. The court held that the approach taken by the Council in approving the modification to the height of the buildings was not in error and dismissed the application.