Martin and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 577

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N1999/890

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      JOHN MARTIN      
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Senior Member Ettinger    

Date13 July 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") sets aside the decision of the Australian Postal Corporation, the Respondent, dated 30 May 1996 which was affirmed by the Reconsideration Section of the Australian Postal Corporation dated 21 August 1996 to deny liability in respect of the Applicant's claim for compensation for his right shoulder injury. In substitution therefor, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant was incapacitated for work due to a compensable injury for the period 23 June 1997 until 21 July 1997. The Tribunal remits the matter to the Respondent for calculation of the amount of  compensation.  Costs to be calculated pursuant to the Tribunal's Practice Direction.
  ..............................................
  Ms G Ettinger     
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
 Workers compensation – aggravation or acceleration of a degenerative disease – period of  incapacity

LEGISLATION

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – s 4(1), 4(9), 14, 16, 19, 24 & 27

CASES

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

REASONS FOR DECISION

13 July 2000            Senior Member Ettinger               

BACKGROUND

  1. The appeal of the Applicant, Mr John Martin, in the proceedings before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") was by way of remittal from the Federal Court of Australia to which he had appealed as a result of a decision made on 19 December 1997 by Senior Member Allen of this Tribunal.  A cross-appeal was lodged by the Australian Postal Corporation, the Respondent, in these proceedings.

  2. The Federal Court stated its task as follows:

    "In this appeal and cross-appeal so called, from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal in respect of a claim made by the applicant for compensation under the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998, two broad issues arise. One, the subject of the appeal, is whether the Tribunal erred in law when it found the applicant's disabilities had not, "except whilst [he was] undergoing surgery on his right shoulder and recuperation from surgery", resulted in "any inability to work" (as to which see s 4(9) of the Act). The other, the subject of the cross-appeal is whether the Tribunal erred in law when it found the applicant had suffered permanent impairment for which he was entitled to compensation under secs 24 and 27 of the  Act."

  3. The decision of Burchett J which was handed down on 14 May 1999 found as follows: "… the appeal should be allowed with costs, and the cross-appeal should be dismissed with costs."

  4. The decision under review by the Tribunal then was the decision made by the Respondent, Australian Postal Corporation, dated 30 May 1996 to disallow the Applicant's claim in respect of a right shoulder injury pursuant to section 14(1) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the SRC Act") as affirmed by the Reconsideration Section of the Australian Postal Corporation dated 21 August 1996.

  5. Senior…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martin and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 577
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Martin v Australian Postal Corporation, the primary dispute revolved around whether the applicant, Martin, was entitled to workers' compensation for a shoulder injury that allegedly worsened due to his employment activities. The case was adjudicated by the Workers Compensation Tribunal of New South Wales. The applicant contended that his employment duties, particularly those involving overhead lifting, aggravated his pre-existing shoulder condition. Conversely, the respondent, Australian Postal Corporation, argued that Martin's shoulder condition was degenerative in nature and not influenced by his work activities.

The key legal issues before the tribunal were whether Martin's shoulder condition was a result of his employment activities or if it was a pre-existing degenerative condition that merely progressed naturally. Additionally, the tribunal needed to determine the period during which Martin was incapacitated due to his injury and whether any of his work activities contributed to the aggravation of his condition. The medical evidence provided by Dr. Brooks, an orthopaedic surgeon, was central to the tribunal's analysis. Dr. Brooks concluded that while Martin's condition was degenerative, there was no clear evidence that his employment activities had exacerbated it.

The tribunal found that Martin was indeed incapacitated for work from 23 June 1997 until 21 July 1997, a period that included his surgery and recovery. The tribunal accepted that Martin had a compensable injury that warranted compensation. However, it was noted that the condition was degenerative and not accelerated by his work duties. The tribunal overturned the respondent's previous decision to deny liability for the compensation claim and directed the respondent to calculate the appropriate compensation amount, including medical expenses. The tribunal also recognised that Martin had been awarded a 10% permanent impairment for his shoulder condition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

When this was put to Mr Martin, he replied that an able bodied person would have had the banner up much sooner. When questioned about any pain he might have suffered while putting the banner up, Mr Martin said that his protest was more important to him than a bit of discomfort. EVIDENCE OF DR R BROOKS ORTHOPAEDIC SURGEON Dr Brooks, whose reports of 7 April 1997, 27 November 1997 (Appeal Book 232) and 31 March 2000 (Exhibit R7) and 27 April 2000 (Exhibit R6) were before the Tribunal, gave oral evidence. He had also seen the video surveillance evidence of the Applicant, and reported on it at Exhibit R6. Dr Brooks, in his report dated 7 April 1997, diagnosed Mr Martin as:"experiencing an impingement syndrome of the right shoulder with associated calcific tendonitis. He is also developing degenerative change in the gleno-humeral joint itself. These conditions are not post-traumatic in nature, but are of a constitutional basis. Calcific tendonitis is typically of spontaneous onset, and is not caused by isolated traumatic events ….On the balance of probabilities these conditions are of a constitutional basis and have progressed in a natural manner, and have not been influenced by Mr Martin's employment. It is unlikely that his current shoulder condition would be any different had the three motorcycle accidents he described not in fact occurred." Dr Brooks, commenting on his view of the video evidence, said that it depicted more overhead activity than Mr Martin had demonstrated at physical examination. He said that he observed Mr Martin moving without restriction on the video, and that he used his arm freely and in vigorous activity to put up the banner. Dr Brooks opined that Mr Martin could carry out the work activities shown in the brochure (Exhibit R5), with the exception of motorcycle riding. He said that physically Mr Martin would be able to ride a motorcycle but that there was a slight safety risk in case of sudden shoulder pain, and it was therefore to be avoided. Dr Brooks said that the sorting of mail using pigeon holes/frames was suitable for the Applicant. Dr Brooks opined that Mr Martin could work provided he did not have to do lifting of more than 15 kilograms. I noted, however, that in his report at Exhibit R7, he had reported the lifting should be restricted to five kilograms. When asked whether Mr Martin could do repetitive or constant work above the shoulder, Dr Brooks answered: "Well, I think it if were mixed in with work below shoulder height, some amount of overhead work with light objects would be reasonable, but no, I wouldn't recommend that it be constant overhead work." Dr Brooks was also questioned about whether Mr Martin's work capacity had changed between April 1997 and November 1997. He replied that there had been a report of some improvement and a revision in diagnosis. Dr Brooks said that the additional diagnosis after Mr Martin's operation was now glenohumeral arthritis and therefore the advice regarding what work he could do differed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

From the evidence before me, I find that the Applicant was totally incapacitated for work for the period from 23 June 1997 until 21 July 1997 being the period from the date of the arthroscopic acromioplasty performed by Professor Murrell on his shoulder and his post operative recovery period until 21 July 1997 when he recommenced his employment with the Illawarra Area Health Service.DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Australian Postal Corporation dated 30 May 1996 which was affirmed by the Reconsideration Section of the Australian Postal Corporation dated 21 August 1996 to deny liability in respect of the Applicant's claim for compensation for his right shoulder injury. In substitution therefor, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant was incapacitated for work due to a compensable injury for the period 23 June 1997 until 21 July 1997 whilst he was undergoing surgery and recuperation. The Tribunal remits the matter to the Respondent for calculation of the amount of compensation including medical expenses pursuant to section 16 of the SRC Act. The Tribunal recognises that there was a finding which has not been disturbed with regard to a compensable condition for which a 10% permanent impairment pursuant to sections 24 and 27 of the SRC Act has been awarded. Costs to be calculated pursuant to the Tribunal's Practice Direction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.