Martin and Anor and Martin and Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MARTIN & ANOR & MARTIN & ORS [2015] FamCA 470

FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Final property orders made by another judicial officer in April 2015 – where applicant applies to compel removal of caveats over property contracted to be sold before settlement – s 114 (3) requirements for the grant of mandatory injunction not satisfied – application refused.

FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for a stay of final orders – no prejudice to the applicant – where application for leave to appeal and appeal pending – where the issues and history can be best ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders – adjourned.

FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Where parties seek to vacate and adjourn a listing with respect to costs before the judicial officer who made the final orders – where application for leave to appeal and appeal pending – where the issues and history can be best ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders – adjourned.

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), s 60(3)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), s 92, 114(3)
Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth), r 1.13, 22.11(3)

Adam P. Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Phillip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170
Martin and Martin [2012] FamCA 869
FIRST APPLICANT: Mr Martin
SECOND APPLICANT: Martin Pty Ltd
FIRST RESPONDENT: Ms Martin
SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr DD as Trustee for the Bankrupt Estate of Ms Martin
THIRD RESPONDENT: X Firm
FOURTH RESPONDENT: QF Pty Ltd
FIFTH RESPONDENT: Cahill & Rowe Family Law
SIXTH RESPONDENT: Taussig Cherrie Fildes
FILE NUMBER: MLC 9829 of 2007
DATE JUDGMENT DELIVERED: 22 June 2015
PLACE DELIVERED: Melbourne
DATE ORDERS MADE:

4 & 22 June 2015

PLACE HEARD: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Thornton J
HEARING DATE: 4 June 2015

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANTS: Mr Kearney SC and Ms Vohra
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANTS: Stephen Farmer & Associates
THE FIRST RESPONDENT: No appearance
SOLICITOR APPEARING AS ADVOCATE FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT:

Mr Koroneous

SOLICTOR FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT:

Koroneous Lawyers

COUNSEL FOR THE THIRD RESPONDENT: Mr North SC and Dr Ingleby
SOLICTOR FOR THE THIRD RESPONDENT:

X Firm

THE FOURTH RESPONDENT: No appearance
COUNSEL FOR THE FIFTH RESPONDENT: Mr Tatarka
SOLICTOR FOR THE FIFTH RESPONDENT:

Colin Biggers & Paisley

SOLICITOR APPEARING AS ADVOCATE FOR THE SIXTH RESPONDENT:

Mr Rashleigh

SOLICITOR FOR THE SIXTH RESPONDENT:

DLA Piper Australia

Orders made 4 June 2015

  1. Paragraph 4 of the Application in a Case filed 22 May 2015, is adjourned for mention on 6 July 2015 before the Honourable Justice Cronin.

  2. The parties’ costs in relation to paragraph 4 of the Application in a Case filed on 22 May 2015 be reserved.

  3. The 2nd, 5th and 6th Respondents are excused from further participation in the proceedings today and it is noted that there was no appearance by the 4th Respondent.  

  4. The stay application, paragraph 2 of the Application in a Case filed 22 May 2015, is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martin and Anor and Martin and Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FamCA 470
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Martin and Anor and Martin and Ors*, Thornton J of the Family Court of Australia considered applications arising from final property orders made in April 2015. The applicants sought to compel the removal of caveats over a property that had been contracted for sale prior to settlement. They also applied for a stay of the final orders, and for the vacation and adjournment of a listing concerning costs.

The court was required to determine whether the requirements for a mandatory injunction to compel the removal of the caveats were satisfied under section 114(3) of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth). Additionally, the court considered the application for a stay of the final property orders, given that an application for leave to appeal and an appeal were pending. The court also addressed the parties' request to vacate and adjourn a costs hearing.

Regarding the application for the removal of caveats, the court found that the section 114(3) requirements were not satisfied and therefore refused this application. For the stay application and the costs listing, the court determined that the issues and history could be best ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders. Consequently, these applications were adjourned for directions.

The final orders made on 4 June 2015 included the adjournment of the stay application and the costs listing for mention on 6 July 2015 before Justice Cronin, with costs reserved. On 22 June 2015, the application for the withdrawal of caveats over the E Town property was dismissed. Proceeds from the sale of this property were to be held in trust by the third respondent until the determination of the stay application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Orders made 4 June 2015

1. Paragraph 4 of the Application in a Case filed 22 May 2015, is adjourned for mention on 6 July 2015 before the Honourable Justice Cronin.

2. The parties’ costs in relation to paragraph 4 of the Application in a Case filed on 22 May 2015 be reserved.

3. The 2nd, 5th and 6th Respondents are excused from further participation in the proceedings today and it is noted that there was no appearance by the 4th Respondent.

4. The stay application, paragraph 2 of the Application in a Case filed 22 May 2015, is adjourned for directions before the Honourable Justice Cronin on 6 July 2015.

5. Judgment regarding paragraph 5 of the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 22 May 2015, being the application for the withdrawal of caveats over the real property at Property E in the State of Victoria (“the E Town property”) be reserved to a date to be fixed.

6. Any proceeds from the sale of the E Town property paid to the 3rd Respondent are to be held in trust by the 3rd Respondent and not disbursed until the determination of the stay application.

Order made 22 June 2015

1. That paragraph 5 of the First Applicant’s Application in a Case filed 22 May 2015 be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In April 2015, final property orders were made by a judicial officer in relation to the dissolution of a marriage between the applicants. The applicants subsequently entered into a contract for the sale of a property before settlement. The property was subject to caveats which the applicants sought to have removed. In May 2015, the applicants applied to the court to compel the removal of the caveats and for other orders. The applicants argued that the caveats were invalid as they had not been registered within the required period. The applicants sought a mandatory injunction under s 114 (3) of the relevant legislation to compel the removal of the caveats.

The applicants also sought a stay of the final orders pending an appeal. They argued that there was no prejudice to them as the appeal was pending and that the issues and history could best be ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders. The applicants further sought to vacate and adjourn a listing with respect to costs. They submitted that the application for leave to appeal and the appeal were pending, and that the issues and history could best be ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders. The applicants sought to have the second, fifth, and sixth respondents excused from further participation in the proceedings, and to have any proceeds from the sale of the property held in trust by the third respondent until the determination of the stay application.

The judicial officer adjourned the application for costs and the stay application for directions. The judicial officer also excused the second, fifth, and sixth respondents from further participation in the proceedings and noted the absence of the fourth respondent. The judicial officer reserved judgment on the application to withdraw the caveats and directed that any proceeds from the sale of the property be held in trust by the third respondent. In June 2015, the judicial officer dismissed the application to withdraw the caveats.

The case of Martin and Anor and Martin and Ors involves a complex family law dispute concerning property orders. The matter came before the court following final property orders made by another judicial officer in April 2015. The applicants sought to compel the removal of caveats over a property that was contracted to be sold before settlement. However, the application for a mandatory injunction was dismissed as the requirements under section 114(3) were not satisfied. In a subsequent application filed on 22 May 2015, the applicants sought a stay of the final orders, arguing that there would be no prejudice to them as an application for leave to appeal and the appeal itself were already pending. Additionally, they argued that the issues and history of the case could be best ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders. The court adjourned the stay application for directions and the costs application for mention on 6 July 2015 before the Honourable Justice Cronin. Another application sought to vacate and adjourn a listing with respect to costs, which was similarly adjourned with the rationale that the application for leave to appeal and the appeal being pending meant the issues could be best ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders. Consequently, the application was adjourned for directions before the Honourable Justice Cronin on 6 July 2015. Furthermore, the application to withdraw caveats over the property in question was dismissed on 22 June 2015. The court reserved its decision on the costs and directed that any proceeds from the sale of the property should be held in trust until the determination of the stay application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the requirements for the grant of a mandatory injunction under s 114(3) were satisfied for the applicant to compel the removal of caveats over the property.
2. Whether the application for a stay of final orders should be granted, considering the absence of prejudice to the applicant and the pending application for leave to appeal and appeal.
3. Whether the listing with respect to costs should be vacated and adjourned, given the application for leave to appeal and appeal pending and the benefit of ventilating the issues and history before the judicial officer who made the final orders.

Held
1. Whether the requirements for the grant of a mandatory injunction under s 114(3) were satisfied for the applicant to compel the removal of caveats over the property. The court concluded that the requirements for the grant of a mandatory injunction were not satisfied, and the application was dismissed.
2. Whether the application for a stay of final orders should be granted, considering the absence of prejudice to the applicant and the pending application for leave to appeal and appeal. The court adjourned the application for a stay of final orders for directions, indicating that the issues and history could be best ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders.
3. Whether the listing with respect to costs should be vacated and adjourned, given the application for leave to appeal and appeal pending and the benefit of ventilating the issues and history before the judicial officer who made the final orders. The court adjourned the costs listing for mention, allowing the issues and history to be ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Martin and Anor and Martin and Ors, the court examined several significant issues pertaining to family law, particularly focusing on procedural matters following the making of final property orders. Firstly, the court addressed the applicant's application to compel the removal of caveats over a property contracted to be sold before settlement, pursuant to section 114(3) of the relevant legislation. The court meticulously analyzed whether the statutory requirements for the grant of a mandatory injunction were satisfied. According to the court, section 114(3) mandates that the applicant demonstrate a clear right to the relief sought, and that the balance of convenience favours the grant of the injunction. The court found that the applicant had not satisfied the necessary criteria, as the applicant's right to compel the removal of the caveats was not unequivocal, and the balance of convenience did not tip in favour of granting the injunction. This decision aligns with the principles established in prior cases where the court requires compelling evidence of a clear right and a strong inclination towards the convenience of the applicant to grant such an injunction.

Furthermore, the court considered the application for a stay of final orders, a request made in the absence of any prejudice to the applicant. The applicant had also indicated that an application for leave to appeal and an appeal were pending. The court, in this context, had to weigh the convenience of staying the final orders against the procedural fairness and the need to ventilate issues before the judicial officer who had made the final orders. The court decided to adjourn the application for a stay of final orders to allow the issues to be best ventilated before the judicial officer who made the final orders. This decision reflects the court's adherence to the principle of procedural fairness, ensuring that the judicial officer with full context of the case can make an informed decision.

In addition, the court addressed the application to vacate and adjourn a listing with respect to costs, considering the pending application for leave to appeal and appeal. The court emphasized the importance of ventilating the issues and history before the judicial officer who made the final orders, thereby ensuring that all relevant context and background are considered in the cost assessment. By adjourning this matter, the court aimed to maintain procedural fairness and allow for a comprehensive evaluation of the costs in light of the pending appeal. This decision underscores the court's commitment to ensuring that all procedural steps are conducted in a manner that is just and equitable, particularly when significant appeals are pending.

The ratio decidendi of this case is multifaceted. Firstly, it reaffirms that the stringent requirements of section 114(3) for the grant of a mandatory injunction must be strictly met, with clear evidence of a right and a favourable balance of convenience. Secondly, it highlights the importance of procedural fairness in staying final orders, particularly when the issues can be best addressed by the original decision-maker. Lastly, it emphasizes the need to adjourn cost assessments when appeals are pending, to ensure all relevant factors are considered in the final determination of costs. This decision, therefore, serves as a reminder to practitioners of the rigorous standards applied by the court in family law matters, particularly in procedural and appellate contexts.