Martin (a pseudonym) v The Queen

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCR 2022 0049

JOSHUA MARTIN (a pseudonym)[1] Applicant
v
THE QUEEN Respondent

[1]To prevent any risk of prejudice in the proper administration of justice, this judgment has been anonymised by the adoption of a pseudonym in place of the name of the applicant.

---

JUDGES: PRIEST, KYROU and T FORREST JJA
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 20 May 2022 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 20 May 2022
DATE OF REASONS: 26 May 2022
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2022] VSCA 97
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: DPP v [Martin (a pseudonym)] (Unreported, County Court of Victoria, Judge Chambers, 5 April 2022)

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Interlocutory appeal – Applicant charged with rape and related offences – Forensic procedure – Trial judge refused to exclude evidence obtained through forensic procedure – Whether applicant gave informed consent – Whether trial judge reversed the onus of proof on issue of informed consent – Whether police officer obtained consent to forensic procedure using language likely to be understood by applicant – Appeal allowed – Crimes Act 1958 ss 464, 464R, 464S and 464ZE.

---

Counsel

Applicant: Mr T Marsh
Respondent: Mr J Dickie

Solicitors

Applicant: SLKQ Lawyers
Respondent: Ms A Hogan, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions

PRIEST JA
KYROU JA
T FORREST JA:

The applicant is charged with violent sexual offences  

  1. During the early evening of 3 December 2019, ‘MN’, a 25-year-old female student, was listening to music as she walked along a trail adjacent to a creek in a northern Melbourne suburb.  At about 7.00 pm, she was confronted by a man – the prosecution case is that it was the applicant, a complete stranger to MN[2] – who subjected her to a protracted and violent sexual attack.

    [2]As it presently stands, in the Defence Response to Summary of Prosecution Opening required by s 184 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009, the applicant ‘does not dispute that he was the person that the Complainant encountered on the [creek trail] in the evening of 3 December 2019’.  During pre-trial argument, however, counsel for the applicant informed the trial judge that if the DNA evidence is excluded, the applicant may seek to file an amended Defence Response, requiring the prosecution to prove that the applicant ‘was the person who was identified as the perpetrator or the offender by the complainant’.

  2. Police arrested the applicant in the early hours of the next day, and charged him with multiple rapes and a number of other sexual and violent offences against MN.[3]  He now faces trial on indictment in the County Court.

    [3]Police also charged him with an unconnected attempted armed robbery, allegedly committed at about 1.00 am on 4 December 2019.

  3. In essence, the prosecution case is that, having encountered her on the trail, the applicant dragged MN to the creek and held her head under the water (charge 1 – reckless  conduct endangering life); strangled her (charge 2 – reckless conduct endangering serious injury); vaginally raped her with his penis (charges 3, 5…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Martin (a pseudonym) v The Queen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSCA 97
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Martin applied for an interlocutory appeal to the Victorian Court of Appeal, challenging the refusal of the trial judge to exclude evidence obtained from a forensic procedure. The evidence was obtained without Martin’s informed consent and was sought to be excluded under the Crimes Act 1958. Martin claimed that the police officer who obtained his consent to the procedure used language that he could not understand. The central issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the trial judge erred in not excluding the forensic evidence, considering whether Martin gave informed consent and whether the police officer used language that Martin could understand.

The Court of Appeal considered whether the trial judge correctly assessed whether Martin gave informed consent and whether this consent was obtained in accordance with the Crimes Act. The Court noted that s 464ZE(1) of the Crimes Act renders evidence obtained from a forensic procedure inadmissible if the suspect did not give their informed consent, unless certain exceptions apply. The Court held that the trial judge erred in concluding that Martin gave informed consent. The Court found that the police officer did not use language that Martin could understand, and therefore, Martin could not have given informed consent. The Court further held that the trial judge reversed the onus of proof on the issue of informed consent by requiring Martin to prove that he did not give informed consent. This was an error of law as the onus should have been on the prosecution to prove that Martin gave informed consent.

The Court of Appeal allowed Martin’s appeal, quashed the decision of the trial judge, and remitted the matter back to the County Court for further proceedings. The Court further directed that the evidence obtained from the forensic procedure be excluded from the prosecution case unless the prosecution could prove that Martin gave informed consent or that an exception under s 464ZE applied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Importantly, s 464ZE(1) renders evidence that is obtained as a result of a forensic procedure that was not conducted in accordance with ss 464R and 464S – which requires the suspect to give his or her ‘informed consent’ to the procedure (absent an order of the Magistrates’ Court or authorisation of a senior police officer) – to be inadmissible as part of the prosecution case in proceedings against that person for an offence, subject to succeeding provisions of the section that justify the reception of the evidence notwithstanding that it is ‘otherwise inadmissible’. Hence, s 464ZE relevantly provides:464ZE Evidence relating to forensic procedures or DNA profile samples(1) Subject to subsection (4) … , evidence obtained as a result of … a forensic procedure conducted on a person … is inadmissible as part of the prosecution case in proceedings against that person for any offence if—(a) the requirements of sections 464R to 464ZA … have not been complied with; ……(2A) In determining whether the circumstances justify the reception of evidence otherwise inadmissible by reason of subsection (1)(a) or (1)(ab), the court may have regard to the following—(a) the probative value of the evidence, including whether equivalent evidence or evidence of equivalent probative value could have been obtained by other means;(b) the reasons given for the failure to comply with a provision referred to in subsection (1)(a) or (1)(ab);(c) the gravity of that failure and whether it deprived the person of a significant protection under this Subdivision;(d) whether that failure was intentional or reckless;(e) the nature of the requirement that was not complied with;(f) the nature of the offence alleged against the person and the subject-matter of the proceedings;(g) whether the reception of the evidence would seriously undermine the protection given to persons under this Subdivision;(h) any other matters the court considers relevant.(3) The probative value of the evidence does not by itself justify the reception of the evidence.(4) If the taking of a DNA profile sample or the conduct of a forensic procedure is recorded by audiovisual recording, the recording is inadmissible as evidence except—(a) to establish or rebut an allegation that unreasonable force was used to enable the sample to be taken or the procedure to be conducted; or(b) to determine the admissibility of a confession or admission or other evidence adverse to the accused where the accused alleges that the evidence was induced or obtained by the use of unreasonable force.(5) If evidence obtained as a result of a DNA profile sample taken from a person or a forensic procedure conducted on a person would be admissible in proceedings against that person for an offence, that evidence is admissible in proceedings against that person for a relevant offence within the meaning of section 464ZG.(6) Evidence obtained as a result of a physical examination conducted in good faith on a person for the purposes of medical or dental treatment is admissible in proceedings against that person for an offence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established