OFFICIAL NOTICE
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Application : No. 695877 in the name of Marshalltown Trowel Company
Title: A Plastic Molded Trowel Handle having Fingerguard and Palm Grip
Action: Opposition under Section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 by Neill Tools Limited
Decision: Issued .
Abstract
The invention defined by the claims possess an inventive step. Although it was established that the use of overmolding forms part of common general knowledge, it was not established that it was obvious to make an overmolded two-part handle for a trowel with differing co-efficients of friction.
The claims were directed to a manner of manufacture. The opponent argued that claim 1 was a mere collocation, was directed to a new use of a known substance and otherwise lacked inventive merit. Although there were some merit in the opponent's argument about claim 1 being a mere collocation, there was also some evidence to indicate that the invention gave rise to a synergistic effect. On balance, the opponent's argument was not persuasive.
However, in the context of manner of manufacture, "known" means publicly available; Ramset Fasteners (Aust) Pty Ltd v Advanced Building Systems Pty Ltd (1996) 34 IPR 256 at 272. There was no evidence that demonstrated that both a trowel with a two-part handle and a trowel with a finger guard are known.
The opponent also argued that hard plastics materials and softer plastics were known and their properties would make them suitable for use as the outer grip member, the inner core and the finger guard. There was no evidence filed that suggested the trowel was known. The opponent also argued that it would be obvious to combine these new uses together, however there was no evidence to support this contention.
In relation to inventive merit, there was nothing on the face of the specification itself, which suggested that the present invention would have been obvious to a person skilled in the art.
Costs were awarded against Neill Tools Limited.
PATENTS ACT 1990
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Re:Patent Application No. 695877 by Marshalltown Trowel Company and opposition thereto by Neill Tools Limited under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990.
BACKGROUND
Patent Application 10039/97 filed on 6 January 1997 is a divisional application of 57516/94 that was filed on 2 March 1994. The latter application has a priority date of 2 March 1993 based upon US basic application 25622. The current application was advertised as accepted on 27 August 1998 and given serial number 695877. Neill Tools Limited (Neill Tools) opposed the application on 26 November 1998.
On 24 July 1998, a further patent application No. 78426/98 to the current patent application was filed. It was advertised as accepted on 25 May 2000 and given serial number 720190.
Evidence in support was served 25 November 1999. No evidence in answer was served.
A hearing on the matter was set down in Canberra on 29 May 2000. Greg Gurr, Patent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Marshalltown Trowel Company v Neill Tools Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] APO 61
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Background
Background to the litigation
The patent application in question is a divisional application with a priority date of 2 March 1993. Neill Tools Limited opposed the patent application on 26 November 1998. A hearing was set for 29 May 2000 in Canberra, where Greg Gurr, patent attorney of Spruson & Ferguson, represented the applicant and Benjamin Fitzpatrick of Counsel, assisted by Mark A. Wakeham, patent attorney of Carter Smith & Beadle, represented the opponent. The decision was issued by G.M. Cox, Delegate of the Commissioner of Patents, on the same day as the hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the invention defined by the claims possesses an inventive step.
2. Whether the invention defined by the claims is directed to a manner of manufacture.
Held
1. The invention defined by the claims possesses an inventive step.
2. The invention defined by the claims is directed to a manner of manufacture.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the inventive step and the manner of manufacture of the invention, a plastic molded trowel handle having a fingerguard and palm grip, in opposition to the argument by Neill Tools Limited that the invention lacked inventive step and was not a manner of manufacture. Regarding the inventive step, the court found that the use of overmolding to create a two-part handle with differing coefficients of friction was not part of common general knowledge and therefore not obvious. The court also found that the specific construction of the finger guard as part of the invention was not an obvious solution, thus contributing to the inventive step. Concerning the manner of manufacture, the court held that the claims defined a combination with a working interrelationship between the various parts of the handle, and not a mere collocation. The court further found that there was no evidence to suggest that either the two-part handle or the finger guard were known features of trowels, and thus the invention was directed to a manner of manufacture. The court awarded costs against Neill Tools Limited as the opposition was unsuccessful on both grounds.