Administrative Appeals Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2011] AATA 566
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No 2010/0822
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re PETER MARSHALL Applicant
And
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENCE
Respondent
And
ANTHONY HEATH
Joined Party
DECISION
Tribunal Mr JW Constance, Deputy President
Mr S Webb, MemberDate17 August 2011
PlaceCanberra
Decision The decision under review is set aside and in place thereof we decide that:
1. under section 42C(3) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), in respect of documents 1 to 20 and uncontroversial parts of document 21, it is appropriate to give effect to the terms that have been agreed and reduced to writing by the parties without dealing with those matters at hearing; and
2. under section 43 of the AAT Act, in respect of the contested exemptions in document 21:
a. the exemptions pressed by Defence in respect of paragraphs 17, 19, 41, 42, 47, 57, 72 and 74 and related headings in document 21 are correct subject only to the following exceptions which are not exempt:
i. paragraph 17, page 4 – line 5: the last three words; line 6: the first 3 words and the last 2 words;
ii. paragraph 47, page 11 – line 4: the last 7 words immediately following the word ‘said’; line 5: the first 9 words in line 5 immediately preceding the word ‘but’;
iii. paragraph 74, page 16 - the first sentence of the first dot point excluding the second and fourth words;
iv. paragraph 74, page 16 - the last line of the second dot point excluding the third and sixth words;
v. paragraph 74, page 16, fifth dot point – lines 6 to 11 inclusive except for: the 2 words immediately following the word ‘tenderer’ in line 6, the 10th word in line 6, the 7th word in line 8, the words between ‘with’ and ‘and’ in line 8, the words between ‘ascertain’ and ‘willingness’ in line 10, the word between ‘for’ and ‘to’ in line 10, the word between ‘assist’ and ‘with’ in line 10, and the last 11 words immediately following the word ‘contract’ in line 11;
vi. paragraph 74, page 17, seventh dot point – lines 4 and 5 inclusive except for the 6th, 11th and 12th words in line 4, and the 1st and 2nd words in line 5; and
b. the exemptions pressed by the joined party in respect of additional parts of paragraph 74 that are not otherwise exempt are not made out.
.
........................[sgd]….......................
Mr JW Constance, Deputy President
23. So to the detail of the claimed exemptions under this head. On balance, considering section 40(2), we are satisfied that the public interest is not served by the disclosure of information of this kind. We are satisfied that the exemptions claimed under section 40(1)(a) and (b) in respect of paragraphs 19, 41, 42, 47, 57, 72 and 74 and related headings in document 21 are well…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MARSHALL and DEPARTMENT OF DEFENCE and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] AATA 566
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the AAT was the interpretation of "personal information" as it related to the exemptions claimed by Defence and the joined party. The court had to assess whether the exemptions were justified under the provisions of the Freedom of Information Act 1982, particularly sections 4, 40, 41, 43, 61, and 64, as well as the Freedom of Information Amendment (Reform) Act 2010. The AAT also needed to consider the public interest in disclosure and weigh this against the exemptions claimed.
The AAT found that the exemptions pressed by Defence in respect of certain paragraphs of document 21 were generally correct, but some parts were not exempt. The court identified specific words and phrases within these paragraphs that were not covered by the exemptions and thus should be disclosed. The AAT also ruled that the exemptions claimed by the joined party in respect of additional parts of paragraph 74 were not made out, as those parts did not constitute exempt information. Consequently, the AAT varied the original decision, specifying the parts of document 21 that should be disclosed.
The final orders of the AAT were to set aside the original decision and to give effect to the terms agreed upon by the parties for documents 1 to 20 and uncontroversial parts of document 21. For the contested exemptions in document 21, the AAT determined which parts were exempt and which were not, providing detailed line-by-line instructions for the disclosure of specific words and phrases.
Orders
Orders of the court
The decision under review is set aside and in place thereof we decide that:
1. under section 42C(3) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act), in respect of documents 1 to 20 and uncontroversial parts of document 21, it is appropriate to give effect to the terms that have been agreed and reduced to writing by the parties without dealing with those matters at hearing; and
2. under section 43 of the AAT Act, in respect of the contested exemptions in document 21:
a. the exemptions pressed by Defence in respect of paragraphs 17, 19, 41, 42, 47, 57, 72 and 74 and related headings in document 21 are correct subject only to the following exceptions which are not exempt:
i. paragraph 17, page 4 – line 5: the last three words; line 6: the first 3 words and the last 2 words;
ii. paragraph 47, page 11 – line 4: the last 7 words immediately following the word ‘said’; line 5: the first 9 words in line 5 immediately preceding the word ‘but’;
iii. paragraph 74, page 16 - the first sentence of the first dot point excluding the second and fourth words;
iv. paragraph 74, page 16 - the last line of the second dot point excluding the third and sixth words;
v. paragraph 74, page 16, fifth dot point – lines 6 to 11 inclusive except for: the 2 words immediately following the word ‘tenderer’ in line 6, the 10th word in line 6, the 7th word in line 8, the words between ‘with’ and ‘and’ in line 8, the words between ‘ascertain’ and ‘willingness’ in line 10, the word between ‘for’ and ‘to’ in line 10, the word between ‘assist’ and ‘with’ in line 10, and the last 11 words immediately following the word ‘contract’ in line 11;
vi. paragraph 74, page 17, seventh dot point – lines 4 and 5 inclusive except for the 6th, 11th and 12th words in line 4, and the 1st and 2nd words in line 5; and
b. the exemptions pressed by the joined party in respect of additional parts of paragraph 74 that are not otherwise exempt are not made out.
.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi