MARSH v RUGGIERO & ORS
Williams J
In this action the plaintiff has claimed damages for personal injury arising out of a vehicular accident at night. The plaintiff’s motor cycle (with side car attached) ran into the rear of a plough being carried behind a slow moving tractor driven along a highway by the first defendant. In addition to its normal tail lights the tractor displayed at its rear a white "working light".
In accordance with a Master’s order (dated 30 March 1992) the proceedings have now come to trial only upon the issue of liability.
The Circumstances of the Accident
On 30 May 1989 the first defendant was driving a Fiat tractor generally easterly along Angle Vale Road near Angle Vale. The tractor was carrying a plough (suspended clear of the ground) attached behind the tractor upon a three point linkage (or "hitch"). The plough extended for about 2.2 metres behind the tractor from its points of attachment. The overall width of the plough was 1.4 metres and this was less than the tractor width. The plaintiff was riding alone on a Honda VF1000 motor cycle with side car attached and was travelling in the same direction as the tractor but at a much greater speed. The plaintiff’s cycle collided with the rear of the plough. The accident occurred in total darkness some time shortly after 6pm. The first policeman upon the scene was Constable Taverner who arrived at 6.20pm.
The plaintiff was thrown from his cycle and is alleged to have suffered injuries affecting him intellectually; counsel were in agreement that it was unnecessary to tender medical evidence to explain his absence from the trial. In the circumstances the plaintiff sued by his next friend alleging negligence by the first defendant as driver of the tractor.
The first defendant is alleged to have suffered injuries to his back and a separate action dealing with that matter is the subject of a District Court action which has been removed into this Court and is before me. I am required by the parties only to note the existence of that action.
The second defendant is the wife of the first defendant and their son is the third defendant. The plaintiff claims that the second and third defendants are vicariously liable for the negligence of the first defendant ; on 30 May 1989 all three were in partnership in the business of almond growing and it is alleged by the plaintiff that at the time of the accident the first defendant was driving the tractor in the ordinary course of the partnership business or with the authority of his partners (see Partnership Act s10).
The first, second and third defendants reside together on an almond growing property (the "home property") on the northern side of Angle Vale Road about one kilometre east of the accident scene. They all have an interest in another almond growing property on Taylor Road Angle Vale ("the Taylor Road property") from which the first defendant was…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Marsh v Ruggiero & Ors No. Scgrg-90-570 Judgment No. S6488 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1997] SASC 6488
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that Ruggiero was negligent in driving the tractor at night without proper lighting. The combination of lights at the rear of the tractor had the capacity to confuse and mislead even an alert and careful driver, and Marsh was denied the proper warning to which he was entitled so that he could take timely avoiding action. The court found that the plaintiff must have misjudged the situation and misinterpreted the series of cues which his eyes were receiving during his final approach. The court found that both the plaintiff and Ruggiero were negligent and apportioned responsibility for the collision as to 75 per cent to Ruggiero and 25 per cent to the plaintiff. The court found that Ruggiero was driving the tractor in the ordinary course of the partnership business and was acting with the authority of the second and third defendants. The court found that the second and third defendants were vicariously liable for Ruggiero’s negligence, but subject to the operation of s116(3) of the Motor Vehicles Act in determining the party against whom judgment may be entered. The court found that the tractor was exempt from registration and insurance by virtue of s102(1) and s12(1)(c) of the Motor Vehicles Act and that it was an uninsured vehicle within the meaning of s116(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act. The court held that the nominal defendant was liable to have judgment entered pursuant to s116(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act.
The court ordered that the plaintiff was entitled to recover against the nominal defendant damages to be assessed in respect of the negligence of Ruggiero for which the first, second and third defendants would have been responsible apart from the operation of s116 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The court further ordered that further proceedings against the first, second and third defendants should now be stayed except to the extent necessary as to enable rights of appeal to be pursued. The court ordered that the damages recoverable by the plaintiff will be reduced by 25 per cent in accordance with s27a of the Wrongs Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi