Marsden v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Marsden v State of Queensland & Ors [2019] QCAT 183

PARTIES: KYLIE MARSDEN

(applicant)

v

STATE OF QUEENSLAND
JO SOOTHILL
STEVE WILDING

(respondents)

APPLICATION NO/S:

ADL082-17

MATTER TYPE:

Anti-discrimination matters

DELIVERED ON:

10 July 2019

HEARING DATES:

9 April 2019; 10 April 2019; 11 April 2019

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Kanowski

ORDER:

The complaint by Kylie Marsden is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS – DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION – DIRECT DISCRIMINATION – where teacher has impairments – whether treated less favourably on the basis of impairment – whether exemption applies

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld), s 10, s 108

Thorne v Toowoomba Regional Council & Tytherleigh [2016] QCAT 212

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondents:

C Hartigan instructed by Crown Law

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. Ms Marsden is a high school teacher. She alleges unlawful discrimination under the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) (‘Anti-Discrimination Act’).

  2. In particular, Ms Marsden alleges discrimination on the basis of impairments. She says she was discriminated against by her employer, which is the State of Queensland through the Department of Education, as well as by Ms Soothill who is the Principal of the school at which she teaches, and by Mr Wilding, a Deputy Principal at the school.

  3. The impairments mainly relate to conditions of diabetes and a broken patella (knee cap), but there is also reference to some ongoing effects of earlier back injuries. It is undisputed that Ms Marsden has been diabetic since childhood, and that she broke her patella in a fall at school on 5 February 2016. She was off work for some months as a result of that injury.

  4. For reasons that will be explained under a later heading, the relevant period in this proceeding for any unlawful discrimination is the period of 12 months ending on


    10 October 2016. 

  5. There are two main aspects to Ms Marsden’s complaint. One relates to the school not assigning her any Home Economics classes, even though she is qualified to teach Home Economics and wants to teach it. Ms Marsden submits that there is an ‘impairment component’ to this aspect: the school, she says, excluded her from teaching Home Economics because it claimed that for health reasons she could not wear the closed-in shoes required in the kitchen. Ms Marsden also argues that the school failed to take her diabetes into account in its subject allocation decisions and some other actions. The other main aspect relates to how Ms Marsden’s graduated return to work, after the patella injury, was handled by the school.

    The complaint and the Tribunal proceeding

  6. The complaints process under the Anti-Discrimination Act at the relevant time first involved a complaint to the Anti-Discrimination Commission Queensland, with the possibility of later referral of the complaint by the Commission to the Tribunal.

  7. Ms Marsden lodged her complaint with the Commission on 10 October 2016. The complaint covered events over several years, and so the Commission had to consider the effect of section 138 of the Anti-Discrimination Act. That…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marsden v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 183
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Marsden v State of Queensland, the court addressed a dispute between the teacher, Ms Marsden, and the State of Queensland regarding alleged discrimination based on her impairments. Ms Marsden, a university-trained teacher with a history of impairments including diabetes, a patella injury, and a back injury, alleged that she was treated less favourably in her employment due to her impairments. Specifically, she claimed that she was not allocated Home Economics classes despite expressing her preference for teaching this subject. Instead, she was given on-the-job training in other subjects, which she found less comfortable and not in line with her strengths.

The court was tasked with determining whether Ms Marsden was treated less favourably on the basis of her impairments and whether any applicable exemptions under the Anti-Discrimination Act applied to the situation. The court considered the broad definitions of 'impairment' and the 'area of work' under the Act, which include various forms of bodily function loss and the denial or limitation of access to opportunities for promotion or benefits, as well as unfavourable treatment in connection with work. The court also had to assess the relevance of the events and submissions provided by both parties, focusing only on the pertinent portions in reaching its decision.

In its reasoning, the court concluded that Ms Marsden had not established unlawful discrimination. Despite the fact that Ms Marsden expressed her preference for teaching Home Economics, the court found that the changes in the curriculum and the requirement for her to update her trade certificates for teaching Hospitality were legitimate reasons for the allocation of her teaching load. The court determined that the State of Queensland did not act in a discriminatory manner towards Ms Marsden based on her impairments, and therefore dismissed her complaint.

The final order of the court was that the complaint by Kylie Marsden is dismissed. This outcome reflects the court's determination that while Ms Marsden's preferences and concerns about her teaching load were valid, they did not constitute unlawful discrimination under the Anti-Discrimination Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

The complaint by Kylie Marsden is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the end of the three-day hearing, there was no time left for the parties to make oral closing submissions, so I made directions for the filing of written submissions. The following were filed:(a)closing submissions by Ms Marsden (50 pages) – I will refer to these as Ms Marsden’s initial closing submissions;(b)closing submissions by Ms Hartigan for the respondents (24 pages); and(c)closing submissions in reply by Ms Marsden (106 pages) – I will refer to these as Ms Marsden’s final closing submissions.Background It is undisputed that Ms Marsden is university-trained in the teaching of Home Economics and Health and Physical Education, and that for many years Home Economics formed part of her teaching load. However, she has not taught Home Economics for several years. According to Ms Marsden’s complaint, the previous Principal, Mrs Elena Itsikson, did not allocate her any Home Economics classes after she (Ms Marsden) resumed work in April 2011 after a period of injury leave. Ms Marsden says, and I accept, that she wanted to keep a Home Economics teaching load, and that she made this known to the school authorities year after year, to no avail. She was given on-the-job training in other subject areas including English and Humanities. (Humanities is sometimes referred to as Social Science in the material). Ms Marsden’s position is that she would feel much more comfortable teaching Home Economics than these other subjects, particularly Humanities. She feels that her strengths lie in the more practical and familiar area of Home Economics. Ms Soothill became Principal in October 2015. Mr Wilding has been a Deputy Principal at the school for many years, and he figures in the complaint because he was the assigned return to work coordinator for Ms Marsden following her patella injury.It is undisputed that from some time prior to 2016, senior Home Economics had been replaced with Hospitality subjects, and that as from 2015 at least, Ms Marsden would have to update her trade certificates before she could teach Hospitality. Home Economics is still offered in the lower grades, and there is no dispute that Ms Marsden remains qualified to teach that subject. The nature of unlawful discrimination under the Anti-Discrimination Act Relevantly, the Anti-Discrimination Act prohibits discrimination[1] ‘on the basis of’[2] particular attributes, including impairment,[3] in the area of work.[4] However, a number of exemptions can apply.[5][1]Anti-Discrimination Act, s 6(2).[2]Ibid, s 7.[3]Ibid, s 7(h).[4]Ibid, s 15. [5]Ibid, s 6(2). ‘Impairment’ is quite broadly defined,[6] and there is no dispute that it would cover losses of bodily function associated with diabetes, a patella injury or a back injury. Discrimination on the basis of an attribute includes discrimination on the basis of characteristics and attributes associated in various ways with the attribute.[7][6]Ibid, Schedule. [7]Ibid, s 8. The area of work is also broadly captured.[8] Discrimination on the basis of impairment (or any of the other grounds) is prohibited, for example, in denying or limiting access to opportunities for promotion or other benefit, or in treating a worker unfavourably in any way in connection with work.[8]Ibid, s 15.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Marsden also points out that parts of the affidavit material for the respondents address events after 10 October 2016. I might add that so do parts of Ms Marsden’s material, including her closing submissions. It is not practical in a hearing, where spare time is scarce, to take the considerable time that would be involved in striking out irrelevant portions of affidavits. The more sensible approach is the one I have taken, which involves relying on only the relevant portions in reaching my decision.Conclusion Ms Marsden has failed to establish unlawful discrimination. Accordingly, her complaint must be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.