Marsden v Fels

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Marsden v Fels & Anor [2020] QDC 307

PARTIES:

SYDNEY FRANK MARSDEN

(Plaintiff)

v

ROSS GREGORY FELS
(First Defendant)

PATRICIA BETTY FELS

(Second Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

D929/17

DIVISION:

Brisbane

PROCEEDING:

Civil

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

3 December 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 and 27 October 2020

JUDGE:

Richards DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The first and second defendants pay to the plaintiff the sum of $226,428.93; and

2.   The first and second defendants pay to the plaintiff interest from 15 March 2017 in the sum of $44,034.69; and

3.   The first and second defendants pay the plaintiffs costs of and incidental to this proceeding as assessed unless otherwise agreed.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – RECOVERY OF COSTS – REPAYMENT – where the plaintiff won a substantial sum of money - where the plaintiff advanced money to the first defendant for the repayment of the second defendants mortgage – where the plaintiff requests repayment of the money advanced to the first defendant on the basis the money was a loan – where the first defendant contends the payment of money from the plaintiff was a gift

EQUITY – PRINCIPLES – UNJUST ENRICHMENT – whether there is a case of unjust enrichment in relation to the second defendant - where the second defendant did not request the loan be advanced from the plaintiff – where the payment of the money was a benefit that was provided to the second defendant in a personal capacity – where the plaintiff paid the money to the first defendant to assist the second defendant on the promise that it would be repaid – where the money advanced by the plaintiff allowed the first defendant to receive an interest free loan minus establishment fees – where the money advanced by the plaintiff allowed the second defendant to retain her home in circumstances where she would have otherwise been evicted   

CASES:

Hightime Investments Pty Ltd v Adamus Resources Ltd [2012] WASC 295

COUNSEL:

Mr R J Oliver and Ms Shepherd for the plaintiff.
First defendant appeared on his own behalf.

Second defendant appeared on her own behalf.

SOLICITORS:

Bartels Lawyers for the plaintiff

  1. The plaintiff has claimed the sum of $226,428.93 from the first defendant and/or the second defendant as monies loaned to them between 21 February 2014 and 27 March 2014.  He also claims interest pursuant to the Civil Proceedings Act 2011. 

    BACKGROUND

  2. The second defendant is the daughter of the first defendant.  She had financial difficulties and owned a home under mortgage at 13 Talganda Street, Woodridge.  Action was taken by the mortgagee when she fell behind in her payments and on 14 December 2012 a judgment sum in the amount of $126,403.59 was awarded in favour of Permanent Custodians Limited against the second defendant, together with costs. 

  3. The first defendant decided to try to buy the home from his daughter for the outstanding sum owed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marsden v Fels and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QDC 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Marsden v Fels, Sydney Marsden claimed that Ross Fels and Patricia Fels should repay him $226,428.93, plus interest, on the basis that the money was a loan. The defendants argued that the money was a gift. The plaintiff claimed that he advanced money to the first defendant for the repayment of the second defendant’s mortgage, which allowed her to retain her home. The defendants contended that the payment of money from the plaintiff was a gift. The court was required to determine whether the money advanced by the plaintiff was a loan or a gift, and if it was a loan, whether there was a case of unjust enrichment in relation to the second defendant. The court found that the plaintiff had shown that the money paid by him to Permanent Custodians was paid on behalf of the second defendant by way of a loan to and at the request of the first defendant. The second defendant had received the benefit of those funds to the detriment of the plaintiff. The court ordered the first and second defendants to pay the plaintiff the sum of $226,428.93 together with interest calculated from 15 March 2017 at $44,034.69, making the total sum payable by the first and second defendants $270,463.62. The first and second defendants were also ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs of and incidental to this proceeding as assessed unless otherwise agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first and second defendants pay to the plaintiff the sum of $226,428.93; and

2. The first and second defendants pay to the plaintiff interest from 15 March 2017 in the sum of $44,034.69; and

3. The first and second defendants pay the plaintiffs costs of and incidental to this proceeding as assessed unless otherwise agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff has claimed the sum of $226,428.93 from the first defendant and/or the second defendant as monies loaned to them between 21 February 2014 and 27 March 2014. He also claims interest pursuant to the Civil Proceedings Act 2011. BACKGROUND The second defendant is the daughter of the first defendant. She had financial difficulties and owned a home under mortgage at 13 Talganda Street, Woodridge. Action was taken by the mortgagee when she fell behind in her payments and on 14 December 2012 a judgment sum in the amount of $126,403.59 was awarded in favour of Permanent Custodians Limited against the second defendant, together with costs. The first defendant decided to try to buy the home from his daughter for the outstanding sum owed to the mortgagee. They obtained finance in the sum of $190,000.00 through RAMS home loans with the intention of purchasing 13 Talganda Street, Woodridge by paying off her debts. Unfortunately, that sale was unable to be advanced without a release of the mortgage and the release of the mortgage was not possible without the prior payment of the outstanding amount of money. The plaintiff, Sydney Marsden was in a relationship with Denise Schnitzerling. The first defendant Ross Fels was married to June Fels. June and Denise had been friends for over 40 years. They lived close to each other and they often socialized. The night before Father’s Day in September 2013, Frank Marsden and Denise Schnitzerling were at the Waterford Hotel when they won over $2m in Keno. The original intention was to keep the win anonymous but Ross and June read about the win in the paper and realized that the article was about their friends. June rang Denise and after some cajoling she admitted that they had won the money. They went to see them soon after and because of their friendship, offered to give them $50,000.00. They accepted the gift but wanted it paid in cash instalments. The evidence differs as to why it was paid in instalments but not much turns on the reason. It was common ground that whatever was given to them was paid in cash. The plaintiff says three cash payments were made, two of $20,000.000 and one of $10,000.00 by December 2013. The first defendant says that there were three payments of $10,000.00 made and $20,000.00 was retained by the plaintiff.THE MONEYThe Plaintiff’s evidence The plaintiff’s case is that in December 2013 the first defendant mentioned to Mr Marsden and Ms Schnitzerling that Patricia, their daughter, had some problems with her house and asked if he would be able to loan them approximately $48,000 to stop the house being repossessed. Mr Marsden assumed that it was for arrears of mortgage payments and possibly some costs. The first defendant said that he would give them a proof of debt and draw up a method of repayment and Mr Marsden was satisfied with that arrangement. There were some further discussions about them trying to obtain a loan through a financial company such as RAMS but in late February Mr Marsden said that Mr Fels told him that he had to go to court the next day to try to stop the eviction and would they still be able to lend him $48,000.00? Mr Marsden indicated that he would organise a bank cheque but Mr Fels told him to wait because he would not know the full amount until they got to court.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Both defendants benefitted from the plaintiffs generosity. The first defendant was given an interest free loan and was saved the expense of establishment fees. The second defendant was able to retain her home in circumstances where she would have surely been evicted. Conclusion I find that the plaintiff has shown that the money paid by him to the Permanent Custodians totalling $226,428.93 was paid on behalf of the second defendant by way of loan to and at the request of the first defendant. The second defendant has received the benefit of those funds to the detriment of the plaintiff. The first and second defendants are ordered to pay to the plaintiff the sum of $226,428.93 together with interest calculated from 15 March 2017 at $44,034.69. The total sum payable by the first and second defendants being $270,463.62. The first and second defendants are ordered to pay the plaintiffs costs of and incidental to this hearing as assessed unless otherwise agreed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established