Marputu Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Element 25 Limited & Another

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

NATIONAL NATIVE TITLE TRIBUNAL

Marputu Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Element 25 Limited & Another [2020] NNTTA 58 (28 September 2020)

Application No:

WO2019/1133

IN THE MATTER of the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth)

- and -

IN THE MATTER of an inquiry into an expedited procedure objection application

Marputu Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC (WCD2017/011)

(native title party)

- and -

Element 25 Limited

(grantee party)

- and -

State of Western Australia

(Government party)

DETERMINATION THAT THE ACT IS AN ACT NOT ATTRACTING THE EXPEDITED PROCEDURE

Tribunal:

The Hon J.A. Dowsett, AM, QC

Place:

Brisbane

Date:

28 September 2020

Catchwords:

Native title – future act – proposed grant of exploration licence – expedited procedure objection application – whether act likely to interfere with sites or areas of particular significance – expedited procedure – the act is not an act attracting the expedited procedure

Legislation:

Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) ss 5, 16, 17, 18

Mining Act 1978 (WA) ss 63, 66

Mining Regulations 1981 (WA) reg 20

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 25, 29, 30A, 31, 32, 237

Rights in Water and Irrigation Act 1914 (WA) ss 5C, 6, 17

Cases:

Andy Campbell v Western Australia [2012] NNTTA 48

Atkins on behalf of the Gingirana People v State of Western Australia [2017] FCA 1465

Bull v Attorney General (NSW) (1913) 17 CLR 370; [1913] HCA 60

FMG Pilbara Pty Ltd v Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corporation (2014) 227 FCR 182; [2014] FCA 1335

Kanak v National Native Title Tribunal (1995) 61 FCR 103; [1995] FCA 1624

Kevin Walley v Western Australia [2001] NNTTA 78

Khoury v Government Insurance Office (NSW) (1984) 165 CLR 622; [1984] HCA 55

Little v The State of Western Australia [2001] FCA 1706

Valerie Tambling and Others v N.T. Gold Pty Ltd [2002] NNTTA 209

Ward v Western Australia (1996) 69 FCR 208; [1996] FCA 1452

Western Australia v Ward (1996) 70 FCR 265; [1996] FCA 993

Representative of the native title party:

Felicity Noonan and Patrick Smith, Central Desert Native Title Services 

Representative of the grantee party: Michael Giles, Element 25 Limited
Representatives of the Government party:

Zachary Clifford, State Solicitor’s Office

Michael McMahon, Department of Mines, Industry Regulation and Safety

REASONS FOR DETERMINATION

INTRODUCTION

  1. Pursuant to the Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) (the “Native Title Act”), Marputu Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC (the “Native Title Party”) holds native title rights and interests in land and waters on trust for the Gingirana People.  The land and waters in question (the “Gingirana determination area”) lie south-east of Newman and north-east of Peak Hill, and in the Meekatharra and Wiluna shire areas.

  2. On 11 April 2019 Element 25 Limited (the “Proposed Grantee”) applied to the Department of Mines, Industry Regulation and Safety of the Government of Western Australia (the “State”) for the grant of exploration licence E52/3706 (the “proposed tenement”) pursuant to the Mining Act 1978 (WA) (the “Mining Act”).  On 2…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marputu Aboriginal Corporation RNTBC v Element 25 Limited &... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NNTTA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Gingirana People hold native title rights and interests in land and waters south-east of Newman and north-east of Peak Hill. Element 25 Limited has applied for the grant of an exploration licence (the proposed tenement) to explore for manganese and copper. The State of Western Australia gave notice of its intention to grant the proposed tenement. The Gingirana People objected to the proposed grant. The Tribunal was required to decide whether the proposed grant is an act attracting the expedited procedure. The proposed tenement is irregular in shape, and overlaps the Gingirana, Ngarlawangga and Nyiyaparli determination areas. Ilgarari Creek, which is said to be of particular significance to the Gingirana People, flows through the proposed tenement. The proposed grantee intends to conduct exploration activities including geological mapping, rock chip sampling and auger soil sampling. The Native Title Party submitted that the proposed grant is likely to interfere with areas or sites of particular significance, as required by s 237(b) of the Native Title Act. The Native Title Party contended that the proposed grant will interfere with areas or sites of particular significance, as contemplated by s 237(b). The Native Title Party submitted that the proposed grant is likely to interfere with areas or sites of particular significance, as required by s 237(b). The State contended that the proposed grant is not likely to interfere with areas or sites of particular significance in accordance with the Native Title Party’s traditions in relation to the land or waters concerned. The Proposed Grantee contended that the proposed grant will not interfere with areas or sites of particular significance in accordance with the Native Title Party’s traditions. I held that the proposed grant is not likely to interfere with areas or sites of particular significance, in accordance with the Native Title Party’s traditions. I held that Ilgarari Creek, its bed, banks and waters, within the boundaries of the proposed tenement, are of particular significance in accordance with the native title holders’ traditions, particularly by virtue of its association with the two tjukurrpa. The Native Title Party submitted that the State offers no evidence in support of its submission that I should accept that the Proposed Grantee will comply with all relevant statutes, regulations and conditions. The Native Title Party asserted that the State effectively contends that the Tribunal may only determine that the expedited procedure does not apply if the “exact location of the relevant sites/areas” is demonstrated. The Native Title Party disagreed with this assertion. I am not sure that the State went so far. I consider that aspects of the Native Title Party’s evidence lack necessary detail. Given that s 237(b) focusses on areas or sites of particular significance, it seems reasonable to expect that there should be at least some general indication as to their respective locations, why they are of particular significance and as to why adverse consequences may occur if the proposed grant is made. The Native Title Party submits that the Proposed Grantee has not fully excluded the possibility that it will access the creek. The Native Title Party submits that the State has failed to “engage with [5.22(f)] of [the Native Title Party’s] contentions”. I generally agree with the State’s contentions in this regard. This matter has been unduly complicated by the Native Title Party’s attempts to identify areas and sites outside of the proposed tenement which, it asserts, may suffer interference as the result of actions by the Proposed Grantee inside the proposed tenement. There are also suggestions that unidentified areas or sites in the proposed tenement, but not in proximity to the creek, might suffer such interference. I shall deal with these unidentified sites below. However, I note that the evidence unequivocally focusses on the creek. I hold that Ilgarari Creek, its bed, banks and waters, within the boundaries of the proposed tenement, are of particular significance in accordance with the native title holders’ traditions, particularly by virtue of its association with the two tjukurrpa. The Native Title Party submits that there are other, unidentified areas or sites within the proposed tenement, apart from those in, or near to the creek. No such site is identified. Lake Disappointment and Yanneri Lake may well be places of significance to the Gingirana People, but the former is more than 300kms from the proposed tenement and well outside the Gingirana determination area. The physical links between the proposed tenement and the lake appear to be, over a considerable part of that distance, unidentified creeks and waterholes. There is no basis in the evidence for inferring the risk of any harm to those features or Lake Disappointment as the result of any conduct pursuant to the proposed grant within the proposed tenement. Yanneri Lake is much closer to the proposed tenement, but still 70-80km to the east. Again, I see no basis for inferring interference as a result of actions within the proposed tenement either to the lake, or any connecting watercourses. I generally accept the various undertakings and assurances given by the Proposed Grantee in its contentions. However that is not an end of the matter. I note that the Proposed Grantee’s exploration for manganese will be “near surface”, but the exploration for copper will be deeper. The manganese exploration will be closely associated with known manganese deposits, about 3km north of the proposed tenement. Although it is not entirely clear, it seems that the copper exploration will be located further south. Although I accept that the Proposed Grantee has no present plans to explore Ilgarari Creek within the proposed tenement, it may nonetheless choose to do so. That there is an identified manganese deposit in such close proximity to the proposed tenement suggests the strong possibility of benefit in doing so. The absence of details concerning proposed exploration activities in later years of the proposed tenement raises concern as to the possibility of exploration, in or near the creek. I conclude that it is not unlikely that there will be interference with areas or sites within the proposed tenement, which areas or sites are of particular significance in accordance with the native title holders’ traditions, particularly Ilgarari Creek and associated pools and “sit down” places within that tenement. I hold that the expedited procedure does not apply to the proposed grant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.