Marpet Enterprises v Eurobodalla Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
Reported Decision: 108 LGERA 432

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Marpet Enterprises v Eurobodalla Shire Council [2000] NSWLEC 159
PARTIES:

APPLICANT:
Marpet Enterprises

RESPONDENT:
Eurobodalla Shire Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10092 of 2000
CORAM: Bignold J
KEY ISSUES: Question of Law :- Proposed brothel development. Whether it satisfies locational constraints of LEP. Meaning of "adjacent to" or "within view of". Whether LEP provision is a development standard.
LEGISLATION CITED: State Environmental Planning Policy No 1 - Development Standards
CASES CITED:
DATES OF HEARING: 28/04/00
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
07/20/2000
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:
APPLICANT:
Mr M L Brabazon, Barrister
SOLICITORS
Pappas J
RESPONDENT:
Mr D Baird, Solicitor
SOLICITORS
Price Waterhouse Coopers Legal

JUDGMENT:


IN THE LAND AND Matter No . 10092 of 2000


ENVIRONMENT COURT OF Coram : Bignold J.


NEW SOUTH WALES 20 July 2000

MARPET ENTERPRISES

Applicants

v

EUROBODALLA SHIRE COUNCIL

Respondent

JUDGMENT



Bignold J:

A. INTRODUCTION

1. The parties seek the determination by the Court of a preliminary question of law that has been raised by the Council in pending Class 1 proceedings involving an appeal against the Council’s refusal of the Applicant’s development application to adapt part of existing warehouse premises situate on land being lot 41 Deposited Plan 713567, known as No 6, Kylie Crescent, Bateman’s Bay (the development site) for use as a brothel.

2. The question of law is as follows:

      Is the proposed development prohibited development by virtue of cl 31(1)(b) of the Eurobodalla Urban Local Environmental Plan 1999 (the LEP)?

3. Clause 31 of the LEP is in the following terms:

            31 What controls apply to brothels in the 4a Industrial zone?

(1) In relation to the location of brothels in the 4a Industrial zone:


(a) development for the purpose of a brothel must not be located within 50 metres of land zoned for residential use, and


(b) development for the purpose of a brothel must not be located on property adjacent to, adjoining, or within view of, any church, place of worship, community facility, cultural facility, educational establishment, child care centre, hospital, medical centre, public open space, recreational area or any place frequented by children for any reason, or residence unless that residence is ancillary to the brothel.


(2) Before granting consent to development for the purpose of a brothel, the Council must consider the following:


(a) the distance between the premises and any church, place of worship, community facility, cultural facility, educational establishment, child care centre, hospital, medical centre, public open space, recreational area or any place frequented by children for any reason, or residence, and


(b) whether the operation of the brothel could cause a disturbance in the neighbourhood, taking into account the location of any other brothels operating in the neighbourhood, and


(c) where the building is used for multiple purposes, whether access to the brothel is by a separate entrance and whether common circulation areas are to be used, and


(d) whether sufficient on-site parking can be provided, and


(e) whether the operation of the brothel…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marpet Enterprises v Eurobodalla Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWLEC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Marpet Enterprises v Eurobodalla Shire Council involved a dispute over the legality of a proposed brothel development in the Eurobodalla Urban Local Environmental Plan 1999 (LEP) in Bateman's Bay, New South Wales. The applicant, Marpet Enterprises, sought to adapt part of an existing warehouse for use as a brothel. The Eurobodalla Shire Council refused the development application on the basis that the proposed brothel would infringe the locational constraints specified in clause 31(1)(b) of the LEP. The applicant appealed to the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, which was tasked with determining a preliminary question of law regarding the interpretation of the LEP provision.

The key legal issues revolved around whether the proposed development violated the LEP's locational constraints for brothels, specifically if it was adjacent to or within view of places frequented by children. The applicant argued for a purposive interpretation of the LEP, suggesting that the clause aimed to reduce offensiveness rather than impose absolute prohibitions. In contrast, the Council argued for a literal interpretation, asserting that the clause clearly prohibited the development if it was within view or adjacent to specified places.

Bignold J, in the Court's judgment, found that the proposed brothel was indeed in violation of clause 31(1)(b) of the LEP. The Court held that the terms "adjacent to" and "within view of" should be interpreted in their ordinary and natural meanings, influenced by contextual considerations. The Court found that the property where the proposed brothel was to be located was adjacent to and within view of places frequented by children, specifically the Bay Roller World and several residential areas. The Court also considered the possibility that the LEP provision might constitute a "development standard" under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act, which could be subject to dispensational relief under State Environmental Planning Policy No 1 - Development Standards. However, due to insufficient argument on this point, the Court reserved the question for further consideration.

Ultimately, the Court ruled that the proposed development was prohibited by clause 31(1)(b) of the LEP but noted that the matter could be subject to dispensational relief under the relevant policy. The Court also granted liberty to restore on three days' notice to allow for further argument on the issue of dispensational relief.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established