CATCHWORDS – FISHERIES – Southern Shark Fishery – fishing permits –Individual Transferable Quota – whether ITQ should be varied – verification of catch history on which ITQ based – whether daily catch and log books sufficient without reference to sale or dealings with catch – decision affirmed regarding verification but varied to reflect the increased quota otherwise calculated by AFMA.
Fisheries (Fish Processors) Regulations 1991 (SA) rr. 7, 8 and 9
Fisheries Act 1952
Fisheries Act 1982 (SA) ss. 5 and 54
Fisheries Administration Act 1991 ss. 7 and 9
Fisheries Management Act 1991 ss. 3, 4, 5, 17, 21, 32, 32(1A), 32(1B), 38, 39, 61, 71, 72, 95 and 165
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 ss. 6 and 262A
Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 s. 3-10(1)
Migration Act 1958 s. 499
Australian Fisheries Management Authority v Graham (2003) 127 FCR 436
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Re Fischer and Australian Fisheries Management Authority (2002) 71 ALD 665
Re Howard and Australian Fisheries and Management Authority [2005] AATA 360
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2005] AATA 914
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) S2002/18
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re ARTHUR MARKELLOS
Applicant
AndAUSTRALIAN FISHERIES MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal: Deputy President S A Forgie
Date: 19 September 2005
Place: Adelaide
Decision:The Tribunal:
1.varies the decision made by a delegate of the respondent on 20 December 2001 so that the Individual Transferable Quota appearing as a condition to the applicant’s Southern Shark Fishery Permit No. 26363 takes account of an increase in the applicant’s catch history of 4,549 units of gummy shark and 103 units of school shark;
2.remits the matter to the respondent to assess the applicant’s Individual Transferable Quota appearing as a condition to the applicant’s Southern Shark Fishery Permit No. 26363 to take account of an increase in the applicant’s catch history of 4,549 units of gummy shark and 103 units of school shark; and
3.otherwise affirms the decision under review.
S A FORGIE
Deputy President
REASONS FOR DECISION
Mr Arthur Markellos holds a permit entitling him to fish for school shark and gummy shark in the Southern Shark Fishery (“SSF”). Following a reviewable decision made by a delegate of the Australian Fisheries Management Authority (“AFMA”) on 20 December 2001, a condition was attached to his permit setting a quota limiting the trunked weight of school and gummy shark that Mr Markellos may catch: 971kg of school shark and 17,438kg of gummy shark. The condition was attached to his permit issued on 17 January 2002 for the period starting on that date and ending on 31 December 2002. AFMA says that it has calculated Mr Markellos’s quota on the basis of the catch history shown in his catch returns and log books where that catch history was verified by other records. More recently, it has conceded that it had omitted to have regard to some records of the Fish Factory, which verified a further portion of his catch…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Markellos and Australian Fisheries Management Authority and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] AATA 914
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
- The primary issue is whether the quota should be varied. This raises two subsidiary issues: whether there are cogent reasons for not requiring Mr Markellos's catch history to be verified by documents such as sales dockets, and whether his catch history can be sufficiently verified in any event.
- The Tribunal examined Mr Markellos's evidence and submissions, along with the documentary evidence provided by AFMA and Mr Markellos. The Tribunal considered the reliability of the information used by AFMA in developing its policy and regulating the fishery, emphasizing the importance of accurate information for sustainable ecological development and maximizing economic efficiency.
- The Tribunal decided that without more, daily catch records and log books are insufficient to verify a catch history. The decision was varied to reflect the increased quota as a result of Mr Markellos's catch history that has been verified by reference to other documents but not otherwise. The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review otherwise.
This case highlights the importance of accurate and verifiable information in the management of fisheries, ensuring that policies are developed and applied in a manner that supports sustainable ecological development and economic efficiency while maintaining fairness and accountability.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was originally decided by a delegate of AFMA on 20 December 2001, who set the ITQ for Markellos's SSF permit. Markellos requested a review of this decision, which was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on 27 and 28 May 2004, and further evidence was heard on 10 to 12 August 2004. The Tribunal delivered its decision on 19 September 2005, varying the ITQ to account for the additional catch history verified by the Fish Factory records.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the quota attached as a condition to Markellos’s SSF permit should be varied.
2. If so, whether there are cogent reasons justifying a departure from the requirement that Markellos’s catch history be verified by reference to documents such as sales dockets.
3. If the catch history verification requirement stands, whether Markellos is able to sufficiently verify his catch history.
Held
1. The quota attached as a condition to Markellos’s SSF permit should be varied to account for an increase in his catch history of 4,549 units of gummy shark and 103 units of school shark.
2. There are not cogent reasons justifying a departure from the requirement that Markellos’s catch history be verified by reference to documents such as sales dockets.
3. Markellos is not able to sufficiently verify his catch history based on his own records without external documentation.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of Markellos, who challenged the quota set by the Australian Fisheries Management Authority (AFMA) on his Southern Shark Fishery (SSF) permit. The Tribunal began by examining AFMA's policy on the verification of catch history used to determine Individual Transferable Quotas (ITQ). AFMA's policy requires verification through primary documents such as sales dockets, invoices, receipts, and supporting financial records to substantiate claims about the catch. This approach ensures the accuracy and reliability of the information used to allocate ITQs, which is crucial for managing the fishery effectively and equitably.
The Tribunal found that Markellos's own records, including his daily catch books and Daily Logs, were not sufficiently reliable to verify his catch history. Although Markellos argued that his records were accurate and based on his experience, the Tribunal concluded that his records were estimates at best and lacked the necessary detail to establish the weight and species composition of his catch. Additionally, the Tribunal noted that Markellos did not keep the required records for his business transactions, as mandated by both Commonwealth and State laws.
Despite the increase in Markellos's quota due to additional verified records from the Fish Factory, the Tribunal held that his other claims for additional catch history could not be substantiated without proper documentation. The Tribunal highlighted that Markellos's sales to the general public and other processors did not provide sufficient evidence to verify his claimed catch history. Furthermore, the Tribunal emphasized that AFMA's verification policy is designed to ensure accuracy and fairness in the allocation of ITQs, and it must be strictly adhered to, even in cases where fishermen argue that the policy is unduly burdensome.
In conclusion, the Tribunal varied the decision to increase Markellos's quota to reflect the verified catch history but upheld the requirement for catch history verification through external documentation. This decision ensures that AFMA's policy for managing the SSF remains fair and effective, protecting the sustainability of the fishery and the interests of all stakeholders involved.