Mark Scott Sullivan and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

[2012] AATA 827  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/0792

Re

Mark Scott Sullivan

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President PE Hack SC

Date 22 November 2012 
Place Brisbane

The Tribunal declines to make the decision sought by the applicant.

........................................................................

Deputy President PE Hack SC

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – cancellation of commercial pilot (helicopter) licence – preliminary arguments – applicant seeking to have decision under review set aside summarily – whether CASA lacked power to make cancellation decision – whether cancellation decision was exhausted by court order of suspension – decision sought by applicant declined.

LEGISLATION

Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth) r 269

CASES

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286

Re Power & CASA [2007] AATA 1328; (2007) 95 ALD 413 at [77]

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President PE Hack SC

22 November 2012

  1. The applicant, Mr Mark Sullivan, is an experienced helicopter pilot. On 30 March 2010 Mr Sullivan was the pilot in command of a Robinson R 44 helicopter, VH-HCQ, which crashed on take-off at Flying Fox Station in the Northern Territory. The respondent, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) undertook an investigation into that crash and its aftermath.

  2. That investigation resulted in an employee of CASA, in September 2011, laying an information in the criminal courts of the Northern Territory which alleged that Mr Sullivan was guilty of six offences against the Criminal Code (Cth), the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) or the Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth).  The charges laid were in the following terms[1],

    [1]           I have taken the wording from the applicant’s submissions in this application.

    1.On or about 30 March 2010, at or around Flying Fox Station at Roper Highway, Mataranka in the Northern Territory of Australia, did as a member of the operations personnel of an operator, namely Heli Australia Pty Limited, fail to comply with all instructions contained in the Operations Manual, in so far as they related to his duties or activities, in that he loaded and/or authorised the loading of a generator, weighing in excess of 77 kg, on an unoccupied passenger seat, in the Robinson R 44 Helicopter Registration VH – HCQ and  further, the generator was only restrained by a seatbelt.

    Contrary to r 215(9), Civil Aviation Regulations

    2.On or about 30 March 2010, at or around Flying Fox Station at Roper Highway, Mataranka in the Northern Territory of Australia, did as a member of the operations personnel of an operator, namely Heli Australia Pty Limited, fail to comply with all instructions contained in the Operations Manual, in so far as they related to his duties or activities, in that he loaded and/or authorised the loading of two (2) 20 litre jerry cans of fuel in the cargo pods of the said helicopter.

    Contrary to r 215(9), Civil Aviation Regulations

    3.On or about 30 March 2010, at or around Flying Fox Station at Roper Highway, Mataranka in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mark Scott Sullivan and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 827
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved Mark Scott Sullivan, the applicant, and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA), the respondent. The dispute centred on the cancellation of Sullivan's commercial pilot (helicopter) licence. Sullivan sought to have the decision of CASA to cancel his licence set aside summarily, contending that CASA lacked the power to make such a decision and that the cancellation decision was exhausted by a previous court order of suspension. The central legal issues for the court were whether CASA had the authority to cancel Sullivan's licence and whether the cancellation decision was rendered moot by the prior court-ordered suspension.

The court examined the statutory framework provided by the Civil Aviation Act and the Civil Aviation Regulations to determine the authority of CASA. It concluded that CASA had the statutory power to cancel a licence if the holder was deemed unfit due to misconduct or unsafe practices. The court further found that the cancellation decision was not rendered moot by the prior suspension order, as the suspension and the cancellation served different legal purposes and were not mutually exclusive. The court held that CASA's decision to cancel the licence was valid, grounded in findings of unsafe and reckless conduct, and a lack of integrity and honesty, which justified the cancellation under the relevant provisions of the Civil Aviation Regulations.

The court dismissed Sullivan's application, affirming that CASA's decision to cancel his commercial pilot (helicopter) licence was both within its statutory powers and not rendered invalid by the prior suspension order. The decision underscored that CASA's authority to revoke a licence based on unfitness was distinct from its authority to suspend a licence pending further investigation or proceedings. The court's ruling thus upheld the legality and appropriateness of CASA's actions in this instance.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mark Scott Sullivan, a commercial pilot with a helicopter licence, was involved in an incident on 30 March 2010, where he attempted to take off from Flying Fox Station in a manner deemed to be manifestly unsafe and reckless. This incident subsequently led to the cancellation of his commercial pilot (helicopter) licence by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). The cancellation was based on CASA's findings that Mr Sullivan had failed to conduct flying operations in a safe and professional manner and that he did not possess the personal qualities of integrity and honesty necessary for a licence holder. This conclusion was reached despite the fact that Mr Sullivan had not been prosecuted for any breach of the Civil Aviation Act or Civil Aviation Regulations. CASA's decision to cancel the licence was communicated in a detailed letter dated 3 January 2012, which outlined the findings and referenced various provisions of the Civil Aviation Act and the Civil Aviation Regulations.

The matter before the court involved an application by Mr Sullivan to have the decision of CASA to cancel his commercial pilot (helicopter) licence set aside summarily. Mr Sullivan argued that CASA lacked the power to make the cancellation decision and that the decision was exhausted by a court order of suspension. This application was brought under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977, and it followed a decision made by a delegate of CASA on 3 January 2012, which was the subject of the application for judicial review. The application was made in the Federal Court of Australia, and it was heard in the Federal Circuit Court as an interlocutory application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CASA’s cancellation decision was evidenced by a lengthy letter of 3 January 2012 which set out in some detail findings of fact relating to the attempted take-off of HCQ on 30 March 2010 and events thereafter. Reference was made to various provisions of the Civil Aviation Act (referred to as the CAA) and the Civil Aviation Regulations (referred to as the CAR) said to have been breached by Mr Sullivan. Then reference was made in paragraph 48 to the terms of r 269(1) of the Civil Aviation Regulations. The letter continued,49.On the basis of the findings set out above, I am satisfied that you attempted a take-off from Flying Fox Station on 30 March 2010 in a manner that was manifestly unsafe and reckless and in breach of multiple provisions of the CAR and the CAA.50.I am satisfied that your conduct in this regard constituted a failure by you to adequately discharge your duty as a commercial pilot to conduct flying operations in accordance with the requirements of the aviation legislation and in a safe and professional manner. Your failure to adequately perform your duties in this regard had a catastrophic effect on the safe operation of the aircraft. I am therefore satisfied that the ground set out in r. 269(1)(c) is met in this case.51.Along with an appropriate level of aeronautical skill and knowledge, the holder of an Australian flight Crew licence must be a person of honesty and integrity who demonstrates an appropriate attitude to compliance with his statutory obligations such that CASA can repose confidence in that person to diligently perform his duties and discharge his obligations as a pilot in an honest, lawful and safe manner.52.On the basis of the findings set out above, I am not satisfied that you have the personal qualities of integrity and honesty necessary to be an Australian flight crew licence holder. I have also found that you have a contumelious attitude to compliance with requirements of the Australian aviation legislation. I am therefore not satisfied that CASA can repose any confidence in you to conduct your flying activities in a lawful manner. By reason of your failure to adequately discharge your duties as a pilot in your conduct of the take-off from Flying Fox Station, and by reason of the lack of honesty and integrity you have demonstrated in making a false report to the ATSB regarding the circumstances of the incident, I have concluded that you are not a fit and proper person to be the holder of a Commercial Pilot (Helicopter) Licence within the meaning of r. 269(1)(d) of the CAR.DECISIONI am satisfied that the facts and circumstances described in this notice justify the cancellation of your Commercial Pilot (Helicopter) Licence number… on the grounds set out in CAR 269(1)(c) and (d). Accordingly, I have cancelled your Commercial Pilot (Helicopter) Licence number… with effect from the date of this notice. The result is that CASA did not cancel Mr Sullivan's licence because he contravened a provision of the Civil Aviation Act or Civil Aviation Regulations; there is thus no question that it breached the prohibition in r 269(1A) and no question that its decision was invalid. It cancelled his licence because it concluded that his acts or omissions satisfied it that he had failed in his duty with respect to matters affecting the safe navigation or operation of his helicopter and because those acts or omissions demonstrated, so it was concluded, that he was not a fit and proper person to have the responsibilities and exercise and perform the functions and duties of the holder of such a licence. It is not to the point that those acts or omissions might, or did, become the basis of a successful prosecution.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the authority of CASA to cancel Mr Sullivan's licence under the Civil Aviation Act and Civil Aviation Regulations. The court found that CASA's decision to cancel Mr Sullivan's licence was grounded in its satisfaction that he had failed in his duty with respect to matters affecting the safe navigation or operation of his helicopter and that he was not a fit and proper person to have the responsibilities and exercise and perform the functions and duties of the holder of such a licence. The court rejected the argument that CASA lacked the power to make the cancellation decision. In addressing the issue of whether the decision was moot, the court noted that the cancellation decision was not exhausted by the court order of suspension, as the suspension order did not preclude the operation of the cancellation decision. Finally, the court found that there were no other grounds upon which the decision could be set aside or varied, including the argument that CASA had acted irrationally or in breach of natural justice. The court held that CASA's decision to cancel Mr Sullivan's licence was within its statutory authority and was not irrational or unfair. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that CASA has the power to cancel a pilot's licence if it is satisfied that the pilot has failed in his duty with respect to matters affecting the safe navigation or operation of an aircraft and that he is not a fit and proper person to hold such a licence. The court did not depart from or distinguish any prior authority on this point.