Mark Mercurius and Migration Agents Registration Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2012] AATA 889  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/2070

Re

Mark Mercurius

APPLICANT

And

Migration Agents Registration Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member J F Toohey

Date 18 December 2012
Place Sydney

Mr Mercurius' application for reinstatement is refused.

............[sgd]............................................................

Senior Member J F Toohey

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to reinstate application after dismissal for failure to appear at conferences – relevant considerations – no adequate explanation for failure to attend – application would have very limited prospect of success of reinstated – application for reinstatement refused

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s 42A

CASES

Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2002) 72 ALD 652

Re Manoli and Secretary, Department of Social Security (1994) 35 ALD 133

Re Oates and Secretary, Department of Social Security (1994) 37 ALD 241

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J F Toohey

18 December 2012

  1. This matter concerns an application by Mr Mark Mercurius for reinstatement of his application for review of a decision by the Migration Agents Registration Authority (MARA) to bar him from registration as a migration agent for five years. 

    BACKGROUND

  2. Mr Mercurius lodged his application for review on 23 May 2012.  By letter dated 24 May 2012, the Tribunal wrote to him at the post office box address in Winston Hills, New South Wales, which he provided in his application advising that his matter had been listed for a conference on 12 July 2012.

  3. On 9 July 2012, the Tribunal received a letter from Mr Mercurius advising that he was suffering from coronary heart disease and other conditions, and asking that the conference be adjourned.  In support of his request he submitted a medical report, medical certificate and evidence of recent admissions to hospital. 

  4. On 10 July and 16 August 2012, the Tribunal sent notices to Mr Mercurius’ post office box address advising that the conference had been rescheduled for 22 August 2012.  On 20 August 2012, the Tribunal sent a reminder by SMS to the phone number he had provided in his application.

  5. Mr Mercurius did not appear at the rescheduled conference and did not contact the Tribunal to explain his absence or to ask for the conference to be rescheduled. 

  6. On 23 August 2012, the Tribunal wrote to Mr Mercurius at his post office box address advising that the conference has been rescheduled to 20 September 2012.  The Tribunal asked him to confirm that he, or someone on his behalf, would be available, and advised that he was required to notify the Tribunal in writing of any new contact details.  The letter further advised that failure to make himself available for the conference could result in Mr Mercuruis’ application for review being dismissed.

  7. Mr Mercurius did not appear at the rescheduled conference on 20 September 2012. On 25 September 2012, the Tribunal dismissed his application under s 42A(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 (the AAT Act) for failure to appear on two occasions. By letter of the same date, sent to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mark Mercurius and Migration Agents Registration Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 889
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Mark Mercurius, who applied for a review of a decision by the Migration Agents Registration Authority (MARA) to bar him from registration as a migration agent for five years. The dispute arose when Mercurius' application for review was dismissed for his failure to attend two rescheduled conferences. Mercurius subsequently applied for the reinstatement of his application. The tribunal was required to decide whether Mercurius had provided an adequate explanation for his non-attendance at the conferences and whether his application for reinstatement had a prospect of success.

The tribunal considered the explanations provided by Mercurius for his non-attendance at the conferences. Mercurius claimed that he did not receive the Tribunal's letters notifying him of the rescheduled conferences. However, the tribunal found his explanations implausible, as the MARA had confirmed receipt of the letters and none were returned to the tribunal. Mercurius also claimed that the MARA had failed to send him and the tribunal documents relevant to his application for review, but this did not explain his failure to receive the tribunal's letters. The tribunal concluded that Mercurius had not provided an adequate explanation for his non-attendance at the conferences. Furthermore, the tribunal found that Mercurius' application for reinstatement would have very limited prospect of success, given the MARA's detailed consideration of 22 complaints against him.

The tribunal refused Mercurius' application for reinstatement of his application for review. The tribunal found that Mercurius had not provided an adequate explanation for his failure to attend the conferences and that his application for reinstatement would have very limited prospect of success. Consequently, the tribunal dismissed Mercurius' application for reinstatement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This matter concerns an application by Mr Mark Mercurius for reinstatement of his application for review of a decision by the Migration Agents Registration Authority (MARA) to bar him from registration as a migration agent for five years. BACKGROUND Mr Mercurius lodged his application for review on 23 May 2012. By letter dated 24 May 2012, the Tribunal wrote to him at the post office box address in Winston Hills, New South Wales, which he provided in his application advising that his matter had been listed for a conference on 12 July 2012. On 9 July 2012, the Tribunal received a letter from Mr Mercurius advising that he was suffering from coronary heart disease and other conditions, and asking that the conference be adjourned. In support of his request he submitted a medical report, medical certificate and evidence of recent admissions to hospital. On 10 July and 16 August 2012, the Tribunal sent notices to Mr Mercurius’ post office box address advising that the conference had been rescheduled for 22 August 2012. On 20 August 2012, the Tribunal sent a reminder by SMS to the phone number he had provided in his application. Mr Mercurius did not appear at the rescheduled conference and did not contact the Tribunal to explain his absence or to ask for the conference to be rescheduled. On 23 August 2012, the Tribunal wrote to Mr Mercurius at his post office box address advising that the conference has been rescheduled to 20 September 2012. The Tribunal asked him to confirm that he, or someone on his behalf, would be available, and advised that he was required to notify the Tribunal in writing of any new contact details. The letter further advised that failure to make himself available for the conference could result in Mr Mercuruis’ application for review being dismissed. Mr Mercurius did not appear at the rescheduled conference on 20 September 2012. On 25 September 2012, the Tribunal dismissed his application under s 42A(2) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act1975 (the AAT Act) for failure to appear on two occasions. By letter of the same date, sent to his post office box address, the Tribunal notified Mr Mercurius of its decision. On 3 October 2012, Mr Mercurius telephoned the Tribunal and, later that day, sent a fax confirming his call. According to the fax, he had rung earlier in the day:to find out the outcome of any arrangement for the conference as in August I been advised that the conference been adjourned and the AAT will send a letter to confirm the date and time for the new conference [sic]. He wrote that he had not received any letter confirming the date of the rescheduled conference, and he asked that it be rescheduled. The fax indicated it was written from an address in South Australia but did not indicate whether that address should be used for future correspondence. On 4 October 2012, the Tribunal wrote to Mr Mercurius at his post office box address advising that it was seeking the respondent’s views about reinstating his application, after which it would conduct a preliminary hearing at which he could appear in person or be represented. MR MERCURIUS’ EVIDENCE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 4 October 2012, the Tribunal wrote to Mr Mercurius at his post office box address advising that it was seeking the respondent’s views about reinstating his application, after which it would conduct a preliminary hearing at which he could appear in person or be represented. MR MERCURIUS’ EVIDENCE At a hearing by telephone on 27 November 2012, Mr Mercurius gave various explanations for his failure to attend the conferences. In particular, he said, he did not receive the Tribunal’s listing notices notifying him of the date and time of the conferences in August and September 2012. Mr Mercurius told the Tribunal that he had to move with his family from Sydney to Adelaide earlier this year after receiving telephone threats. He said he moved to Adelaide permanently in August 2012 but has continued to return to Sydney. He confirmed that he has retained the Winston Hills post office box nominated in his application for review and where the Tribunal has been sending correspondence. He claimed, however, that he did not receive the Tribunal’s letters dated 10 July and 16 August 2012 notifying him of the conference on 22 August 2012, and nor did he receive the Tribunal’s letter dated 23 August 2012 notifying him of the rescheduled conference on 20 September 2012. Mr Mercuruis’ evidence about his movements between New South Wales and South Australia, and why he did not receive the Tribunal’s notices, was not easy to follow. It is notable that the MARA’s 81 page decision considered 22 complaints against Mr Mercurius by clients, by the Refugee Review Tribunal in relation to applicants before it, and by the Department for Immigration and Citizenship. It referred throughout to Mr Mercurius’ repeated failures to respond to correspondence and telephone calls, including from the MARA and from his own clients. The MARA has confirmed that it received all of the Tribunal’s letters. It is implausible, in my view, that three letters all made their way to the MARA but failed to reach Mr Mercurius’ post office box. I note that none of the letters was returned by the post office to the Tribunal, which suggests that he in fact did receive them. He did not dispute receiving the Tribunal’s first letter about the conference scheduled for 12 July 2012. Moreover, when Mr Mercurius contacted the Tribunal on 3 October 2012, he said he was waiting to hear about the rescheduled August conference. He has not explained how, if he did not receive the listing notice for that conference, he knew a conference had been listed for that date. Either he did not receive the letter as he claims, or he did not know about the conference. Mr Mercurius also said that the MARA had failed to send him and the Tribunal documents relevant to his application for review. It is not clear precisely what documents he is referring to, but any delay would not explain why he did not receive the Tribunal’s letters. Mr Mercurius has been a solicitor in the past and was a registered migration agent for 13 years. He would be well aware of the importance of advising an agency such as the Tribunal of any change of address or telephone number. When asked about this at the hearing, he said he did not do so because he had kept his Winston Hills post office box. He then said he had notified the Tribunal of his change of address as soon as he moved – which he had already said was in August. There is no record of any advice from him of change of address around that time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established