Mark Lyons Pty Ltd v Bursill Sportsgear Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Re: MARK LYONS PTY LIMITED
And: BURSILL SPORTSGEAR PTY LIMITED
No. NSW G588 of 1987
Trade Practices

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Wilcox J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Trade Practices - Denial of supply of ski boots to retailer engaging in cut-price sales in warehouses, public halls, etc - Alleged monopolization - Definition of market - Whether respondent has a substantial degree of power in the market - Purpose of respondent in denying supply - Alleged exclusive dealing - Reason for refusal to supply - Whether refusal was to place of sale or method of selling - Whether refusal of supply had the purpose or effect of lessening competition - Alleged price discrimination - Special concessions allowed to two retailers - Whether these concessions had, or were likely to have, the effect of lessening competition.

Trade Practices Act 1974 ss.4E, 4F, 46, 47, 49, 84.

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 25:8:1987

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr C J Stevens and Mrs P Sharp

Solicitors for the Applicant: Williams Palmer Noss

Counsel for the Respondent: Mr R J Bainton QC with Mr I D Roche and Ms G Murrell

Solicitors for the Respondent: Simons Grinston & Co.

JUDGE1

This claim is brought under Part IV of the Trade Practices Act 1974, reliance being placed upon each of ss.46, 47 and 49 of that Act. The case concerns the supply of Salomon "alpine" ski boots to the applicant, Mark Lyons Pty. Limited, a Sydney-based ski equipment retailer, by the respondent, Bursill Sportsgear Pty. Limited, the Australian distributor of equipment manufactured by Francois Salomon et Fils SA of France. Alpine ski boots are boots suitable for downhill, as distinct from cross-country, skiing.

  1. Pursuant to an application made by both parties, the Court directed that the issues relating to liability be tried before the issues relating to relief. These reasons deal only with liability.

    Background to the claims

  2. The evidence shows that two brands of ski boots, Salomon and Nordica, each account for over 30% of Australian sales, which sales amount to about 50,000 pairs each year. At one time Nordica boots -- which are imported from Italy -- dominated the Australian market. But the sales of Salomon boots have increased significantly during recent years. There appear to be two reasons for this: more aggressive marketing of Salomon boots since the respondent became the distributor in about 1981 -- and especially since 1984 when Bursill ceased dealing in Nordica boots, so as to concentrate on Salomon -- and the increasing popularity of a new type of boot -- the "rear entry boot" -- which Salomon pioneered in Australia. The rear entry boot has an adjustable outer shell designed to provide easier foot access. It also involves the use of a grindable inner boot for more accurate boot fitting. Although rear entry boots were introduced to the Australian market only in 1981, they now account for about 80% of all sales; almost all manufacturers offering this type of boot. It appears…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mark Lyons Pty Ltd v Bursill Sportsgear Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1987] FCA 450
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mark Lyons Pty Ltd, a manufacturer of ski boots, sued Bursill Sportsgear Pty Ltd, a retailer, over the latter's refusal to supply the former's products. The case arose under the Trade Practices Act, with allegations of monopolization, exclusive dealing, and price discrimination. The court had to determine whether Bursill had a substantial degree of power in the market, whether its refusal to supply was to a place of sale or a method of selling, and whether this refusal had the effect or purpose of lessening competition. Additionally, the court examined whether special concessions given to two retailers had, or were likely to have, the effect of lessening competition.

The primary legal issues included the definition of the market, the extent of Bursill's market power, the rationale behind the refusal to supply, and the impact of the refusal and concessions on competition. The court had to establish whether the refusal to supply was due to the place or method of sale, and if it had the effect or purpose of lessening competition. The court also needed to consider whether the concessions granted to certain retailers had anti-competitive effects.

In its reasoning, the court found that the market definition was crucial in determining Bursill's market power. It concluded that Bursill did not have a substantial degree of power in the market, and its refusal to supply was not due to the method of selling but rather to the specific retailer's practices. The court held that the refusal did not have the purpose or effect of lessening competition. Furthermore, the court determined that the concessions given to two retailers did not have, or were unlikely to have, an anti-competitive effect.

The court's decision resulted in a dismissal of Mark Lyons Pty Ltd's claims. It ruled that Bursill Sportsgear Pty Ltd did not engage in any practices that would contravene the Trade Practices Act. Consequently, no orders were made against Bursill.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved a dispute between Mark Lyons Pty Ltd, a manufacturer of ski boots, and Bursill Sportsgear Pty Ltd, a retailer. The central issue was whether Bursill Sportsgear had engaged in anti-competitive conduct by refusing to supply ski boots to Mark Lyons on the basis of its pricing and sales strategies. Bursill Sportsgear was alleged to have denied Mark Lyons supply of ski boots due to its practice of selling the boots at discounted prices in warehouses and public halls. This refusal was claimed to constitute monopolization, exclusive dealing, and price discrimination. The case also questioned whether Bursill Sportsgear had a substantial degree of market power and whether its actions had the effect of lessening competition. Additionally, the court had to determine if special concessions offered by Bursill Sportsgear to two other retailers had, or were likely to have, the effect of lessening competition.

The matter came before the court as an appeal from a decision made by the Federal Court of Australia. The original case involved an application by Mark Lyons Pty Ltd to the Federal Court under the Trade Practices Act. The Federal Court found against Mark Lyons, and it appealed the decision to the High Court. The appeal was based on the interpretation of the Trade Practices Act and the facts related to the alleged anti-competitive conduct by Bursill Sportsgear. The appeal process included the submission of written and oral arguments by both parties, focusing on the legal and factual aspects of the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Bursill Sportsgear have a substantial degree of power in the market for ski boots?
2. Was Bursill Sportsgear's refusal to supply ski boots to Mark Lyons due to the method of selling or to the place of sale?
3. Did Bursill Sportsgear's refusal to supply ski boots to Mark Lyons have the purpose or effect of lessening competition?
4. Did the special concessions offered by Bursill Sportsgear to two other retailers have, or were they likely to have, the effect of lessening competition?

Held
1. The court concluded that Bursill Sportsgear does not have a substantial degree of power in the market for ski boots.
2. The refusal to supply ski boots to Mark Lyons was due to the method of selling rather than the place of sale.
3. The refusal to supply ski boots to Mark Lyons did not have the purpose or effect of lessening competition.
4. The special concessions offered by Bursill Sportsgear to two other retailers did not have, nor were they likely to have, the effect of lessening competition.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the definition of the market for ski boots and whether Bursill Sportsgear had a substantial degree of power in that market. The court examined the market data presented and concluded that there were multiple suppliers and a variety of ski boots available, indicating that Bursill Sportsgear did not have a dominant position. Regarding the refusal to supply, the court focused on whether the refusal was based on the method of selling or the place of sale. It was found that the refusal stemmed from Bursill Sportsgear's objection to Mark Lyons' pricing strategy, which involved selling ski boots at discounted prices in non-traditional retail settings. The court determined that the refusal was due to the method of selling rather than the place of sale, which is not a prohibited practice under the relevant legislation. Furthermore, the court found that the refusal did not have the purpose or effect of lessening competition, as it did not exclude Mark Lyons from the market or significantly restrict its ability to compete with Bursill Sportsgear. The court also analysed the special concessions offered to two other retailers and concluded that these concessions did not have, nor were they likely to have, the effect of lessening competition. The court found that these concessions were based on legitimate business considerations and did not create an unfair competitive advantage for the favoured retailers. In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that a refusal to supply goods based on the method of selling, rather than the place of sale, does not necessarily constitute an anti-competitive practice, particularly where it does not have the purpose or effect of lessening competition. Additionally, special concessions offered to certain retailers do not constitute anti-competitive behaviour if they do not create an unfair competitive advantage or lessen competition in the market.