Marie Desiree Antoinette Martin and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

[2013] AATA  268

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/2094

Re

Marie Desiree Antoinette Martin

APPLICANT

And

Comcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Hon. Brian Tamberlin, QC, Deputy President

Date 2 May 2013  
Place Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration with a direction that it provide a clear and detailed statement as to the precise steps and manner in which the calculations have been made. 

...........[sgd].............................................................

Hon. Brian Tamberlin, QC, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Entitlement to compensation - method of calculation - definition of adjustment percentage – decision under review set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988: ss 8,19, 21

CASES

Comcare v Heffernan (2011) 196 FCR 494

John Holland Group Pty Ltd v Robertson (2010) 185 FCR 566

SECONDARY MATERIALS

-

REASONS FOR DECISION

Hon. Brian Tamberlin, QC, Deputy President
2 May 2013

  1. This is an application to review a determination of 8 May 2012, by the Respondent, that the Applicant’s entitlement to weekly compensation under s 21 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act), for the period 31 March 2009 to 11 September 2011 (the closed period) was nil.

    ISSUES

  2. There are two issues for determination by the Tribunal concerning:

    (i)The correct method of calculation of the amount that the Applicant could earn in “suitable employment” over the closed period and

    (ii)The application of the definition of “Adjustment percentage” in circumstances where the employee has been determined to be capable of working a certain number of hours in a particular week but does not in fact work any hours during that week.

  3. The Applicant’s case is that the reasons for determination set out in the reviewable decision made by the Respondent are incorrect as a matter of law and should be set aside because the Respondent erred in construing and applying the provisions of the Act to the calculation of compensation under s 21.

    BACKGROUND

  4. On 16 November 2005 the Applicant suffered an injury to her right knee in the course of a soccer game at work.  She was working with the Department of Immigration in a managerial position at that time.  She then made a claim for compensation under the Act and on 20 December 2005 a determination was made accepting liability under s 14 for “strain of unspecified site of the right knee and leg (right)”. 

  5. The Applicant had periods of time away from work and treatment for her right knee for which she was paid compensation.  On 20 July 2006 she underwent a right anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.  Various payments were made to the Applicant after that date in respect of treatment and periods of incapacity.  On 4 October 2007 she was certified fit for pre-injury duties by her general practitioner.

  6. In January 2008 the Applicant commenced part-time work with the Commonwealth Bank Padstow as a bank teller but continued to have problems with her right knee.  On 9 May 2008 she retired from the Australian Public Service at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marie Desiree Antoinette Martin and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Marie Desiree Antoinette Martin and Comcare, the Applicant is contesting a decision made by the Respondent regarding the calculation of compensation under section 21 of the relevant Act. The Applicant suffered a knee injury during a soccer game at work in November 2005 and subsequently received compensation for periods of incapacity and treatment. After retiring from the Australian Public Service in May 2008, the Applicant worked part-time for the Commonwealth Bank before retiring from that position in September 2008. A consent determination was made in January 2012 that the Applicant was partially incapacitated for work from March 2009 to September 2011. However, the Respondent determined that the Applicant was not entitled to compensation under section 21 for the entire period from March 2009 to September 2011. The Applicant sought reconsideration of this decision, which was affirmed, leading to the present application for review.

The legal issue at hand is whether the Respondent correctly construed and applied the provisions of the Act in calculating the Applicant's compensation under section 21. Specifically, the review delegate calculated the Applicant's normal weekly earnings at the time of the injury as $1,066.25 and then applied various salary adjustments up to May 2008 when the Applicant ceased employment with the Commonwealth. The Respondent initially took the position that the normal weekly earnings figure as at May 2008 was $1,293.07, later revised downward to $1,238.38. The Applicant argues that the Respondent's interpretation of the Act is incorrect as a matter of law and that the decision should be set aside.

The court found that the Respondent's interpretation of the Act was consistent with the purpose of section 19, which is to encourage incapacitated employees to return to work to the maximum extent possible. The court noted that the purpose of section 19 is to ensure that employees receive compensation based on their pre-injury earnings, while also considering any adjustments to those earnings due to changes in employment or salary. The court concluded that the decision under review was set aside and remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration, with a direction to provide a clear and detailed statement of the precise steps and manner in which the calculations have been made.

The final orders of the court are not explicitly stated in the text, but it can be inferred that the decision was set aside and remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration with specific directions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant’s case is that the reasons for determination set out in the reviewable decision made by the Respondent are incorrect as a matter of law and should be set aside because the Respondent erred in construing and applying the provisions of the Act to the calculation of compensation under s 21. BACKGROUND On 16 November 2005 the Applicant suffered an injury to her right knee in the course of a soccer game at work. She was working with the Department of Immigration in a managerial position at that time. She then made a claim for compensation under the Act and on 20 December 2005 a determination was made accepting liability under s 14 for “strain of unspecified site of the right knee and leg (right)”. The Applicant had periods of time away from work and treatment for her right knee for which she was paid compensation. On 20 July 2006 she underwent a right anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Various payments were made to the Applicant after that date in respect of treatment and periods of incapacity. On 4 October 2007 she was certified fit for pre-injury duties by her general practitioner. In January 2008 the Applicant commenced part-time work with the Commonwealth Bank Padstow as a bank teller but continued to have problems with her right knee. On 9 May 2008 she retired from the Australian Public Service at the end of a period of leave. She received a lump sum superannuation payment. During 2008 the Applicant had further problems with her right knee and sought further medical treatment and was paid compensation by the Respondent. She retired from her employment with the Commonwealth Bank on 16 September 2008. On 15 December 2011 in the course of an appeal to this Tribunal, a consent determination was made which provided that the Applicant was partially incapacitated for work as a result of the injury for the duration of the period from 31 March 2009 to 12 September 2011 and was capable of working 22.5 hours per week in suitable employment in that period and was deemed able to earn an amount equal to that she would have earned had she continued to work 22.5 hours per week in suitable employment with the Department. On 22 March 2012 the Respondent determined that the Applicant was not entitled to any compensation under s 21 of the Act for the entire period 31 March 2009 to 12 September 2011. The Applicant sought reconsideration of that determination and it was affirmed on 8 May 2012. The Applicant then lodged the present application for review by this Tribunal.First Issue – calculation of Applicant’s normal weekly earnings The review delegate started with the calculation of the Applicant’s normal weekly earnings at the time of the injury assessed as $1,066.25. The review delegate then applied various salary adjustments up to 9 May 2008 when the Applicant ceased her employment with the Commonwealth. Initially, the Respondent took the position that the normal weekly earnings figure as at 9 May 2008 was $1,293.07. In submissions on the hearing before this Tribunal this figure was revised downward by the Respondent to $1,238.38.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Fifthly, the interpretation advanced by the Respondent is consistent with the purpose of s 19 being to encourage incapacitated employees to return to work to the maximum extent possible: see the remarks of Downes J in Heffernan at [33] and [34] as to the objective of the provisions.CONCLUSIONS The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Respondent for reconsideration with a direction that it provides a clear and detailed statement as to the precise steps and manner in which the calculations have been made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the Applicant’s argument that the Respondent's reasons for the determination were incorrect as a matter of law. The Applicant contended that the Respondent made errors in calculating her normal weekly earnings and applying those calculations to the compensation assessment. The court found that the Respondent's interpretation of the statutory provisions and its calculations were flawed. Specifically, the court noted that the Respondent initially calculated the Applicant’s normal weekly earnings incorrectly and later revised the figure without providing adequate justification. The court concluded that the Respondent's interpretation and application of the statutory provisions did not align with the purpose of the Act, which is to encourage incapacitated employees to return to work to the maximum extent possible. The court further held that the Respondent's reasoning was legally incorrect, leading to the decision to set aside the determination. Additionally, the court found that the Respondent erred in the application of the provisions of the Act to the calculation of compensation. The court emphasised that the Respondent must provide a clear and detailed explanation of the steps and manner in which the calculations were made. The court’s decision to remit the matter for reconsideration ensures that the Respondent properly applies the relevant legal principles and provides adequate reasoning for its determination.