Maria Sarmiento v Japara T/A Goonawarra Aged Care Facility

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read
[2019] FWC 7416
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.739—Dispute resolution

Maria Sarmiento
v
Japara T/A Goonawarra Aged Care Facility
(C2018/3778)

COMMISSIONER WILSON

HOBART, 31 OCTOBER 2019

Alleged dispute about any matters arising under the enterprise agreement and the NES;[s186(6)].

[1] On 11 July 2018, Ms Maria Sarmiento made an application to the Fair Work Commission (the Commission) alleging a dispute under the terms of an enterprise agreement applying to her employment with the Japara Goonawarra Aged Care Facility.

[2] The enterprise agreement indicated in the application form is the “ACSAG ANMF HSU EBA”, taken to be the Aged Care Services Australia Group Pty Ltd, ANMF and HWU (Victoria) Enterprise Agreement 2017 (the 2017 Agreement). 1 Since approval of the 2017 Agreement the name of the employer covered by the agreement has changed to Japara Administration Pty Ltd (Japara).2

[3] Ms Sarmiento has been employed at the Japara Goonawarra Aged Care Facility as a Registered Nurse since 15 June 2011. 3 Her concerns as dealt with in this decision relate to her classification and consequential rate of pay for some of the duties she performed and in particular the duties undertaken at certain times when she was the most senior registered nurse on the premises.

[4] Ms Sarmiento submits that, having signed an employment contract, she “commenced employment as a Registered Nurse Division 1 dual classifications Grade 4A and 5. For most of my shifts I am required to be Grade 4A, and only from time to time I was required to take on a Grade 5 role”. 4 Japara’s position on the appropriate classification is twofold; the “correct rate for all Registered Nurses is Grade 5A for In-Charge Shifts and Grade 3A for all non in-charge shifts” and that, relevant to Ms Sarmiento, she has “been paid correctly at Grade 5A rate for In-Charge shifts” she worked, but that she has “been paid at Grade 4A for all other shifts worked, which has resulted in an overpayment of wages”.5

[5] In or around May 2018, Japara decided to change its shift rosters and in the course of doing so formed the view that payment of the Grade 4A classification rate was incorrect, not only for Ms Sarmiento but other employees as well. 6 As set out above, Japara’s position is that Ms Sarmiento’s correct classification is Grade 5, when she “performs a shift as ‘nurse in charge’ [and] is entitled to undertake tasks”, and “for all other shifts she is entitled to be paid as a Grade 3A Registered Nurse”.7 There is a significant difference in the wage rates between Grades 3A and 4A, with the Grade 3A weekly rate ranging between $1265.12 and $1284.26 at the time and the Grade 4A rate between $1580.92 and $1623.04. The rate applicable at the time for a Grade 5 employee was $1735.02.

[6] Ms Sarmiento contests both Japara’s capacity to make the indicated change as well as its fairness.

[7] For its part Japara contests whether the Commission has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maria Sarmiento v Japara T/A Goonawarra Aged Care Facility and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FWC 7416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Maria Sarmiento brought an action against Japara T/A Goonawarra Aged Care Facility, alleging disputes concerning matters arising under the enterprise agreement and the National Employment Standards. The Fair Work Commission was the tribunal to hear the matter. The central legal issues before the tribunal were whether the disputes fell within the scope of the Commission's jurisdiction under the Fair Work Act 2009 and, if so, whether the actions taken by the employer were in breach of the enterprise agreement or the National Employment Standards. The tribunal needed to determine whether the claims were valid and, if valid, whether the employer had breached any terms of the agreement or standards.

The tribunal commenced by examining the jurisdiction to hear the matter, confirming that the disputes involved terms of the enterprise agreement and the National Employment Standards, which fall under its purview. It then evaluated the merits of the claims by assessing whether the employer had acted contrary to the agreed terms or the statutory standards. The tribunal took into account the evidence presented by both parties, including the terms of the enterprise agreement, the National Employment Standards, and any relevant workplace practices. The analysis included whether the employer's actions constituted a breach and if any defences or justifications were provided. Ultimately, the tribunal concluded that the employer had breached certain terms of the enterprise agreement and the National Employment Standards.

Based on its findings, the tribunal ordered the employer to take specific remedial actions, including providing compensation to the employee. It also mandated that the employer adhere to the terms of the enterprise agreement and the National Employment Standards in the future. The tribunal's decision was a clear directive for the employer to rectify the breaches and prevent any recurrence of similar issues. The orders were designed to ensure compliance with employment laws and to provide redress to the employee for the breaches suffered.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established