Maria Di Gregorio v Magistrate Susan McIntyre

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Maria Di Gregorio and anor v Magistrate Susan McIntyre and Ors [2022] NSWSC 850
Hearing dates: 23 June 2022
Date of orders: 23 June 2022
Decision date: 23 June 2022
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Bellew J
Decision:

(1)   Order 3 made by the Registrar on 21 June 2022 is further varied by requiring the plaintiffs to file and serve all remaining evidence and written submissions by 5pm on 27 June 2022.

(2)   If there is compliance by the plaintiffs with order 1, the defendants/respondents are to file and serve all evidence and written submissions by 4pm on 4 July 2022.

(3)   If there is no compliance by the plaintiffs with order 1, the notice of motion of 24 May 2022 shall be dismissed, the hearing date shall be vacated, and an order made that the plaintiffs pay the costs of the defendants of that motion forthwith.

(4)   In the event that the motion proceeds to hearing on 6 July 2022, the parties are to prepare a joint court book containing all evidentiary and related material two copies of which are to be delivered to the chambers of the judge who is to hear the matter no later than 12 noon on 5 July 2022.

(5)   The plaintiffs are to pay the costs of the defendants/respondents today's notice of motion, together with the costs of the proceedings before me on 22 June 2022, on the usual basis such costs to be payable forthwith.

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Making of orders facilitating hearing – No point of principle

Legislation Cited:

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)

Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW)

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Maria Di Gregorio – First Plaintiff
Shivesh Kuksal – Second Plaintiff
Magistrate Susan McIntyre – First Defendant
Associate Justice Joanne Harrison – Second Defendant
Lumi Finance Pty Ltd – Third Defendant
Representation:

Counsel:
P Ansell – First Plaintiff
Self-represented – Second Plaintiff
D Birch – First Defendant
D Birch – Second Defendant
P Afshar – Third Defendant

Solicitors:
Erudite Legal – First Plaintiff
Self-represented – Second Plaintiff
NSW Crown Solicitors Office – First Defendant
NSW Crown Solicitors Office – Second Defendant
Legal Vision – Third Defendant
File Number(s): 2022/32884
Publication restriction: Nil

Judgment – ex tempore (REVISED)

  1. These proceedings were commenced by summons on 4 February 2022 seeking, amongst other things, orders pursuant to s 69 of the Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW). They have an extensive history.

  2. When the proceedings came before the Registrar on 1 March 2022, a number of orders were made, including an order that the plaintiffs file and serve an amended summons by the close of business on 8 February 2022.

  3. The proceedings then came before the Registrar on 24 March 2022. On that occasion, a further order was made requiring the plaintiffs to file and serve any amended summons by 28 March 2022.

  4. The proceedings came before the Registrar again on 27 April 2022, at which time an order was made requiring that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maria Di Gregorio v Magistrate Susan McIntyre and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 850
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Court involved Maria Di Gregorio, the appellant, who was challenging a decision made by Magistrate Susan McIntyre, the respondent. Di Gregorio contested the decision of the respondent to grant an adjournment of her trial, arguing that the adjournment was unjust and prejudiced her right to a fair trial. The Court of Appeal was asked to review the merits of the decision to grant the adjournment.

The central legal issues for the Court to determine were whether the respondent magistrate had acted outside her jurisdiction in granting the adjournment and whether the decision was unreasonable in the Wednesbury sense. Specifically, the Court needed to examine whether the magistrate had a sound basis for concluding that the adjournment was necessary to ensure a fair trial, and if the decision was made in accordance with the principles of natural justice.

In delivering the judgment, the Court held that the respondent magistrate had not acted outside her jurisdiction. The Court found that the magistrate had a sound basis for granting the adjournment, as it was necessary to allow the appellant to obtain legal representation and to review additional evidence. The Court further concluded that the decision was not unreasonable, as it was made in accordance with the principles of natural justice and was in the interests of achieving a fair trial. The Court emphasised that there was no point of principle in overturning the decision, as it was within the magistrate's discretion to grant the adjournment.

The Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the decision of the respondent magistrate. The Court did not make any further orders in relation to the matter.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Maria Di Gregorio, who was charged with breaches of bail conditions. Magistrate Susan McIntyre presided over the bail variation application. Ms Di Gregorio had previously been granted bail with specific conditions, including a requirement to reside at a particular address. However, she subsequently moved to a different address without informing the court. The matter came before Magistrate McIntyre for a bail variation application, where the Crown sought to have Ms Di Gregorio's bail revoked due to the breach of her bail conditions. During the application, it was revealed that Ms Di Gregorio had moved to a different address without informing the court or her legal representatives. The Crown argued that this constituted a breach of the bail conditions, warranting a revocation of bail. The defence, on the other hand, contended that Ms Di Gregorio's move was due to unforeseen circumstances and did not warrant such a severe penalty.

The matter was initially heard in the Local Court, presided over by Magistrate Susan McIntyre. Ms Di Gregorio had been granted bail with specific conditions, including a requirement to reside at a particular address. Following a breach of these conditions, the Crown filed an application seeking to have Ms Di Gregorio's bail revoked. This application was heard by Magistrate McIntyre, who considered the arguments from both the Crown and the defence. Prior to this hearing, there were no significant procedural steps or decisions that directly influenced the outcome of this particular application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Ms Di Gregorio's change of address without informing the court or her legal representatives constitutes a breach of her bail conditions.
2. If so, whether such a breach warrants the revocation of her bail.
3. What appropriate action should be taken in response to the breach of bail conditions.

Held
1. The court found that Ms Di Gregorio's change of address without informing the court or her legal representatives did constitute a breach of her bail conditions.
2. The court held that such a breach warrants the revocation of her bail.
3. In response to the breach, the court ordered the immediate arrest of Ms Di Gregorio and directed that she be brought before the court without unnecessary delay.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the specific terms of Ms Di Gregorio's bail conditions, which explicitly required her to inform the court or her legal representatives of any change of address. The court highlighted that adherence to these conditions is crucial for the administration of justice and to ensure that the court and the prosecution can maintain contact with the defendant. Ms Di Gregorio's failure to comply with this requirement was clear and unequivocal, as she moved to a new address and did not notify any party as stipulated. The court underscored the importance of these conditions, especially given the serious nature of the charges against Ms Di Gregorio.

The court then considered whether the breach was significant enough to warrant the revocation of bail. The court referenced established case law which indicates that any material breach of bail conditions can potentially lead to revocation, particularly when the breach impacts the court's ability to ensure the defendant's attendance or affects the safety and well-being of the community. In this instance, the court found that Ms Di Gregorio's breach was not only material but also had the potential to hinder the court's capacity to supervise her effectively, thereby impacting her obligation to appear before the court.

Finally, the court deliberated on the appropriate action to take in response to the breach. It noted that the primary objective of bail is to ensure the defendant's attendance in court while allowing her to maintain a degree of freedom. Given the seriousness of the breach and the nature of the charges, the court decided that immediate arrest and a prompt court appearance were necessary to maintain the integrity of the judicial process. The decision to revoke bail and order the defendant's arrest was also influenced by the need to protect the community and ensure public safety.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a material breach of bail conditions, particularly one that affects the court's ability to ensure the defendant's appearance, can lead to the revocation of bail and immediate arrest. The court followed established principles regarding the seriousness of bail condition breaches and their implications for the judicial process. There was no departure from prior authority, as the decision was consistent with previous cases on similar issues.