Margarita Kuzmina v Sprouts Management Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
[2021] FWC 4976
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

REASONS FOR DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Margarita Kuzmina
v
Sprouts Management Pty Ltd
(U2021/4704)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT BOYCE

SYDNEY, 23 AUGUST 2021

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – jurisdictional objection by respondent – “genuine redundancy” – business closure – sale of land – redevelopment of building – application dismissed

Introduction

[1] This Decision was originally made on an ex-tempore basis on transcript. In publishing these Reasons, I have taken the opportunity to revise, make additions to, and/or amend same in accordance with the principles stated by Kirby J in Ex Tempore Judgments - Reasons on the Run (1995) 25 UWALRev 213 (at 229-230, including the authorities cited therein), and the New South Wales Court of Appeal in Bar-Mordecai v Rotman & Ors [2000] NSWCA 123 (at [193]-[195], including the authorities cited therein).

[2] Ms Margarita Kuzmina (Applicant) has filed a Form F2 with the Fair Work Commission (Commission), being an application for an unfair dismissal remedy (Application). By way of that Application, the Applicant claims that she was dismissed from her employment with Sprouts Management Pty Ltd (Respondent) and that her dismissal was “unfair” within the meaning of Part 3-2 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act). The Application was filed on 31 May 2021.

[3] In the Form F3 Employer Response filed with the Commission, the Respondent asserts that the Applicant’s dismissal was a case of “genuine redundancy” within the meaning of s.389 of the Act. This Decision concerns the determination of this genuine redundancy jurisdictional objection.

[4] At the hearing, the Applicant appeared for herself, and Ms Carol Lin, Director, appeared for the Respondent.

Background

[5] The Applicant was first employed by the Respondent on 15 August 2015. On 19 September 2017, she was promoted to Centre Manager. That role is subject to a contract of employment made between the parties MADE on 18 September 2017.

[6] It is not in dispute that the building that the Respondent’s childcare centre (Cremorne Little Sprouts) operates from, at 139 Holt Avenue, Cremorne, was sold by the Respondent, and was subject to an approved development application. It appears that the process in relation to the sale of the property, and the development application, has been ongoing for some time, and has been no secret. Staff, and parents/carers, have been kept aware of progress since the sale occurred (especially given parents/carers would need to eventually make alternative childcare arrangements).

[7] On 6 April 2021, the Respondent sent the Applicant correspondence commencing a consultation process regarding the closure of the Cremorne Little Sprouts (Consultation Letter). Relevantly, the Consultation Letter (which was sent to all staff members) states:

“After months of consideration, we made the very tough decision to surrender the lease for this property. Given the purchaser intends to commence construction on the surrounding sites, we did not feel it would be safe to continue running a childcare centre next to this.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Margarita Kuzmina v Sprouts Management Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FWC 4976
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Fair Work Commission, Margarita Kuzmina sought relief for an unfair dismissal against Sprouts Management Pty Ltd. Kuzmina, a former employee, alleged that her dismissal was unfair and sought reinstatement and compensation. Sprouts Management argued that the dismissal was genuine, occurring due to the redundancy of her position, resulting from the company's decision to close its business, sell the land, and redevelop the building. The Commission was tasked with determining whether Kuzmina's dismissal was unfair and if the respondent's argument of genuine redundancy was valid.

The central issue before the Commission was whether Kuzmina's dismissal was procedurally fair and substantively justified. Specifically, the Court had to assess if the dismissal was due to the redundancy of her position, as claimed by the respondent. This involved examining the respondent's reasons for the dismissal, including the business closure, sale of the land, and redevelopment of the building. The Commission also needed to consider whether the dismissal was handled in accordance with procedural fairness and whether it was substantively justified under the relevant legislative framework.

The Commission found that the respondent had demonstrated a genuine redundancy as the reason for the dismissal. The evidence presented indicated that the business was closing, the land was being sold, and the building was to be redeveloped, leading to the redundancy of Kuzmina's position. The respondent had followed the correct procedural steps in terminating her employment, and the reasons provided were valid. Consequently, the Commission concluded that the dismissal was both procedurally fair and substantively justified. Kuzmina's application for an unfair dismissal remedy was dismissed.

The Commission ordered that the application for an unfair dismissal remedy be dismissed, and no further relief be granted to Margarita Kuzmina.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.