Marcel Lema v Fondo Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Marcel Lema to application under section 92 of the Act by Fondo Pty Ltd for removal of trade mark number 1409933 (25, 41) – GRAN FONDO (and Device) - in the name of Marcel Lema

Delegate: Nicholas Smith
Representation: Opponent: Brian Goldberg, Trademark.Ventures
Applicant: Self-represented
Decision: 2019 ATMO 14
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ) - section 96 opposition: s 92(4)(b) application for removal - Opponent’s evidence does not show use of the Trade Mark during the relevant period or obstacle to use – exercise of Registrar’s discretion not appropriate – Trade Mark to be removed from the Register

Background

  1. This decision is pursuant to an application made on 1 March 2017 under s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘Act’) by Fondo Pty Ltd (‘Applicant’) to remove the trade mark detailed below from the Register of Trade Marks.  The application is made in respect of all the goods and services in classes 25 and 41 for which the trade mark is registered, that is in effect, an application for complete removal of the trade mark.

Registration No. 1409933
Lodgement date 04 Mar 2011
Goods  and Services Class 25: Apparel (clothing, footwear, headgear); arm warmers (clothing); articles of clothing made from wool; articles of waterproof clothing; articles of water-resistant clothing; articles of weatherproof clothing; articles of windproof clothing; athletic clothing; beach clothing; casual clothing; clothing; clothing for sports; clothing for surfing; clothing of leather; clothing, not being protective clothing, incorporating reflective or fluorescent elements or material; cyclists' clothing; denims (clothing); girl's clothing; gloves (clothing); jackets (clothing); jerseys (clothing); knitted clothing; knitwear (clothing); ladies clothing; mantles (clothing); men's clothing; motorcyclists' clothing (other than for protection against accident or injury); ready-made clothing; ready-to-wear clothing; ski clothing (other than for protection against injury); sports clothing (other than golf gloves); stuff jackets (clothing); thermal clothing; thermally insulated clothing; waterproof clothing; waterproof clothing; water-resistant clothing; weather resistant outer clothing; weatherproof clothing; windbreakers (clothing); women's clothing; woollen clothing; woven articles of clothing
Class 41: Advisory services relating to the organisation of sporting events; arranging of sporting events; booking of tickets for sporting events; event management services (organization of educational, entertainment, sporting or cultural events); handicapping or seeding of sports events; management of cultural events; management of educational events; management of entertainment events; management of sporting events; organisation of ceremonial events; organisation of entertainment events; organisation of musical events; organisation of sporting events; organisation of vehicle racing events; organising events for cultural purposes; organising events for entertainment purposes; organising of entertainment and social events; organising of equestrian events; production of sporting events; providing facilities for sports events; provision of recreational events; provision of sporting events; rental of equipment for use at sporting events; timing of sports events
(‘Registered Goods and Services)
Owner Marcel Lema
Trade Mark  
(‘Trade Mark’)
  1. Marcel Lema (‘Opponent’) has opposed the application to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marcel Lema v Fondo Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition to the removal of a trade mark from the Register, brought by Marcel Lema (the Opponent) against Fondo Pty Ltd (the Applicant). The dispute arose from an application for removal of the trade mark, and the Opponent sought to resist this removal. The decision was made by Nicholas Smith, a Hearing Officer.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Opponent had established use of the trade mark in Australia during the relevant period, as required by section 100 of the relevant Act, or whether the Registrar should exercise discretion under section 101(3) to prevent removal. The court was also required to consider the balance between the Opponent's private commercial interest in maintaining the registration and the public interest in the integrity of the Register.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had failed to establish use of the trade mark in Australia during the relevant period. The evidence presented, including various annexures to a declaration, was considered insufficient to demonstrate use in the course of trade for the registered goods and services. The Hearing Officer noted that while some evidence suggested the Opponent was a prominent advocate for cycling and cycling organisations, this did not equate to use of the trade mark by the Opponent in a commercial context. Furthermore, the evidence did not establish a clear connection or licence between Granfondo Pty Ltd and the Opponent to attribute any use by the company to the Opponent.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer determined that the Opponent's private commercial interest was insufficient to outweigh the public interest in the integrity of the Register, particularly given the limited reputation of the trade mark. The Hearing Officer decided that the opposition to removal had not been established and directed that the trade mark be removed from the Register. The Applicant was awarded costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the Opponent may have a limited private commercial interest in maintaining the registration of the Trade Mark, given the very limited to non-existent reputation of the Trade Mark in Australia, the Opponent’s private commercial interest is insufficient to outweigh the public interest of the integrity of the Register. In those circumstances I am not prepared to exercise the Registrar’s discretion.Decision26. I decide that the Opponent has not established its opposition to removal and the Trade Mark should be removed from the Register in respect of all the goods and services for which it is registered.27. Accordingly, I direct that registration be removed from the Register one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal before then I direct that removal shall not occur until the appeal has either been discontinued or, in the event of a decision from the Court, that the registration be dealt with as the Court sees fit.Costs28. The Applicant has been successful in relation to the application for removal of the Trade Mark and has requested its costs. I direct that costs in relation to trade mark registration no. 1409933 be awarded against the Opponent in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.Nicholas SmithHearing OfficerHearings and Oppositions 1 February 2019

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Opponent’s evidence in this matter consists of a declaration made on 20 September 2017 by Marcel Lema, the Opponent (‘Lema Declaration’) with Annexures ‘Evidence 1’ to ‘Evidence 15’. The Lema Declaration contains no statements, rather it simply lists the Annexures. As such my description of the evidence below will simply be a description of the Annexures to the Lema Declaration. The Opponent’s evidence is accompanied by a letter from the Opponent’s representative however as it is not in the form of a declaration and there is no basis to infer any direct personal knowledge, to the extent relevant, this letter shall be treated as submissions. The Lema Declaration contains the following:·An undated letter from the Opponent stating that he has used the Trade Mark for 9 years and seeks to use the Trade Mark further.·Undated photos ofowhat purports to be a website displaying the Trade Mark; othe Beach Road Cyclist Facebook page which features the Trade Mark. oThe Beach Road Cyclist twitter page that states that it is funded by “Granfondo” ·A business name registration for ‘GRANFONDO’ dating from 2007 and a company registration for GRANFONDO PTY LTD.·An undated search report for ‘granfondo australia’ showing images of cyclists and one image of the Trade Mark.·A letter dated 1 June 2017 from the director of Bright Alpine Sporting Events stating that ‘granfondoTM’ has worked with BASE in event management.·A letter from Murray Thompson MP, Victorian State Member for Sandringham stating that the Trade Mark owner has been an active spokesman for cycling interests along Beach Road, tweets under the name @BeachRdCyclist and that he is advised that his ‘Grandfondo emblem’ is also used for the purpose of sales of cycling clothing’·Letters from the Yarra Bicycle Users Group and Cycling Victoria indicating that the Owner has been a supporter of the respective groups.·Five invoices in 2014-16 to Base Events, Crisp Projects and The Bicycle Fitting Store for what appear to be cycling clothing. The invoices are expressed to be from ‘Granfondo Pty’ and display the Trade Mark. It is not clear if the clothing referenced in the invoices bears the Trade Mark.·A bank statement dated 30 November 2016 for Granfondo Pty Ltd. No transaction details are included.·Undated photos of clothing, some of which appear to bear a swing tag displaying the Trade Mark. Discussion To successfully oppose the Application the Opponent must establish that it has used the Trade Mark pursuant to s 100 of the Act (either through use or circumstances that were an obstacle to use) or, in the event that the Opponent fails to establish such use, the Registrar exercises its discretion under s 101(3) to decide that the Trade Mark should not be removed from the Register.Use of the Trade Mark in the relevant period I find that the Opponent has failed to establish that the Trade Mark was used in Australia by the Opponent during the relevant period. The undated annexures to the Lema Declaration are of little relevance to showing use during the relevant period, nor is the evidence of a registered business name and incorporated company under the granfondo name; this evidence does not show use of the Trade Mark in the relevant period. The Lema Declaration does not establish a connection between Granfondo Pty Ltd and the Opponent or a licence between them, such that any use of the Trade Mark by Granfondo Pty Ltd would be authorised use by the Opponent. Furthermore a number of the letters annexed to the Lema Declaration show that the Opponent was a prominent advocate for cycling and cycling organisations; they do not show the use of the Trade Mark, by the Opponent, in the course of trade, for the Registered Goods and Services.